Not every website needs a silo structure. A 2023 article on Neil Patel’s website suggests that large websites with diverse content may benefit in particular, while smaller websites with less content may see limited benefits. The decision depends not just on website size, but also on whether the content needs grouping and whether the current structure makes navigation difficult. Existing websites should also consider whether URL and navigation changes are needed, rather than making changes simply to adopt silos.
More content and more topics give you stronger reasons to consider grouping
One part of a silo structure is organizing related content into topic groups. The article on Neil Patel’s website explains that large websites without such grouping may be difficult to navigate. Deciding whether silos are needed should therefore start with the content the website contains, rather than treating silos as an SEO requirement for every site.
- Large websites with diverse content: Start by checking whether different topics are mixed together and whether related content already falls into clear categories.
- Small websites with less content: If the existing structure is easy to understand, do not assume that adding silos will make it better.
For example, a content website covering several topics could first take stock of the pages under each topic. A website with little content could check whether its current categories are sufficient. These suggestions follow from the discussion above; they do not mean that silos will necessarily work—or fail to work—for either type of website.
Identify navigation problems before deciding whether to restructure
The article recommends assessing the benefits of silos based on a website’s content and structure, rather than its size alone. Start by asking:
- Can the existing content be organized into clearly defined topic groups?
- Are related pages scattered, making it difficult to understand how they relate to one another?
- Does the navigation already present these content categories clearly?
These questions help identify structural problems that need addressing. They are not a checklist where a certain number of answers makes silos necessary. The article also mentions potential benefits for user experience, ease of crawling, and rankings, but that does not mean every website will rank higher after restructuring.
Grouping content does not necessarily mean changing URLs
In a Warrior Forum discussion, Dave Earley is quoted as saying that he left existing URLs unchanged because he was concerned about breaking existing links. Jeffery’s reply emphasizes that URL and navigation structures matter too, alongside placing related content in the same silo.
These comments reflect different practical considerations. They should not be read as a claim that changing URLs will necessarily break all links. For an existing website, first clarify how the content and navigation need to be organized, then assess whether URL changes are needed. The discussion does not justify rebuilding every website’s URL structure simply to adopt silos.
At Procrustes, for example, we build a separate website as part of our service, so clients do not need to modify their existing official website. This is how we work with clients, not a recommendation that every business should take the same approach.
The suitability of silo structures: perspectives from across the web
Will adopting a silo structure improve search rankings?
There is no guarantee. A 2023 article on Neil Patel’s website suggests that grouping content may improve the user experience, make it easier for search engines to crawl the site, and potentially help rankings. However, the same article notes that silos may not be necessary or beneficial for every website. Whether they are worth adopting still requires an assessment of the website’s content and structure; potential benefits should not be treated as a promise of higher rankings.
Does an existing website have to change its URLs when adopting a silo structure?
URL changes should not be a blanket requirement, and this discussion does not establish that every website needs them. In the Warrior Forum discussion, Dave Earley says he left existing URLs unchanged to avoid breaking existing links. Jeffery, meanwhile, considers URL and navigation structures important aspects of silos, alongside grouping related content. Their comments reflect different practical considerations. They do not mean that changing URLs will necessarily break all links, nor do they establish that keeping existing URLs is appropriate for every website.
References
- How does google decide what appears in the answer box?www.warriorforum.com — Discusses: Does an existing website have to change its URLs when adopting a silo structure?
- The Expert’s Guide to SEO Siloingneilpatel.com · 2023-10-13T19:00:00+00:00 — Discusses: Will adopting a silo structure improve search rankings?




