To audit a website’s H1s, start by checking the tags on individual pages, then crawl the entire site to identify missing, empty, and duplicate H1s, as well as pages with multiple H1s. Address missing headings first, then check that each main heading clearly reflects the content and use H2s and H3s to organize subsections. One main H1 per page is a practical recommendation. Tool warnings are not search engine penalties, and making changes does not guarantee traffic growth.
Check the tags first, then identify sitewide issues
To check an individual page, search its source code for H1 tags or use a browser extension that identifies heading levels. For larger numbers of pages, use a site audit tool to find issues in one place. Semrush describes these methods and notes that tools can identify missing, duplicate, or empty tags.
Neil Patel’s 2021 article demonstrates how to crawl a website with Screaming Frog, filter separately for missing, duplicate, and multiple H1s, export the lists, and finally review all H1s. You can use these categories to organize audit findings. However, the article’s menu names and licensing conditions reflect information available at the time and should not be treated as current product specifications.
- Missing or empty: Check whether the page has no H1 or whether the tag contains no main heading text.
- Duplicate: Review the listed pages and headings to determine whether the wording accurately describes each page’s content.
- Multiple H1s on one page: Identify which headings are main headings for the entire page and which are actually section headings.
Prioritize missing H1s, but consider exceptions
Neil Patel recommends addressing pages with missing H1s first, followed by duplicate H1s and pages with multiple H1s. For a website with tens of thousands of pages and limited resources, fixing missing headings may be all that is feasible initially. This is the author’s suggested workflow, not an official rule that every website must follow.
The same article also mentions an exception: the author chose not to include an H1 on his own article index page. This is his approach, not a reason to conclude that all listing pages can do without an H1. When a heading is missing, check the page’s purpose and the reason for omitting a main heading rather than adding irrelevant text simply to clear a warning.
Improve wording and hierarchy, not just clear warnings
Semrush’s 2024 guidance recommends using H1 for the main heading, H2 for major sections, and H3 for subsections. Headings should be concise and descriptive, accurately reflecting the content beneath them. One main H1 per page is preferable; incorporate keywords naturally rather than repeating them just to increase their count.
For example, if a page explains how to choose hiking boot sizes, its main heading could be “How to Choose the Right Hiking Boot Size,” with “How to Measure Your Feet” and “What to Check When Trying Boots On” as H2s. This illustrates heading hierarchy; it is not a proven ranking formula.
For ongoing maintenance, you can follow Semrush’s recommendation to run regular audits, address the tool’s warnings before its notices, and schedule recurring reports to track new issues. Keep checking the page’s content to ensure that headings help readers scan the page and understand its topic, rather than focusing solely on clearing items from a list.
Auditing and improving website H1s: perspectives from across the web
Can an H1 audit replace a full content audit?
An H1 audit should not be treated as a substitute for a full content audit. In his 2021 article, Neil Patel recommends conducting an H1 audit before considering a full content audit because he sees it as a faster option with the potential to improve organic traffic. This is his suggested sequence, not evidence that the two types of audit deliver the same results. An H1 list alone is still not enough to evaluate the content itself.
Why is it important to distinguish H1s from title tags during an H1 audit?
They serve different purposes: the H1 is the main heading on the page, while the title tag specifies the webpage’s title and may be used as the clickable title in search results. When checking whether H1s are clear, you can separately review title tags for missing or duplicate titles or titles that do not include the target query. However, these are separate checks: fixing one does not mean the other is already in good shape.
References
- How to Create the Perfect H1 Tag for SEOneilpatel.com · 2021-04-16T15:30:00+00:00 — Discusses: Can an H1 audit replace a full content audit?
- What Is an H1 Tag? Why It Matters & Best Practices for SEOwww.semrush.com · 2020-12-18T12:00:00Z — Discusses: Why is it important to distinguish H1s from title tags during an H1 audit?
- NLP in SEO: What It Is & How to Use It to Optimize Your Contentwww.semrush.com · 2024-09-04T10:09:00Z — Source used in the article above.
- A Complete SEO Audit Template + How to Use Itwww.semrush.com · 2019-08-29T07:00:00Z — Discusses: Why is it important to distinguish H1s from title tags during an H1 audit?
- How to do a website audit in 2026 (+ free tracker)www.semrush.com · 2023-12-28T11:37:00Z — Discusses: Why is it important to distinguish H1s from title tags during an H1 audit?
- How to Analyze a Website’s SEO: Your Step-By-Step Guidewww.semrush.com · 2024-11-07T11:39:00Z — Source used in the article above.


