To balance marketing and user experience in website design and proposals, start by discussing both what the website needs to achieve and how users need to read and interact with it. Then let clients try the website to assess whether the design works, rather than judging only its appearance. The case discussed here supports this approach, but provides no performance data and cannot guarantee enrollment or marketing results. Evaluation should remain focused on the project’s purpose, content readability, and ease of interaction.
Use marketing goals as a basis for design discussions
In an article shared in 2022, a designer looked back on a 2021 website project for a National Taiwan University program. He said he centered client discussions on marketing to validate the website’s effectiveness and the rationale behind its design. He did not see either design or marketing as taking precedence, but regarded both as equally important parts of the work.
The program was recruiting its first students, and the biggest content challenge at the time was having text but no images. This example reminds those preparing proposals that visual concepts must account for the materials actually available, rather than merely showcase an ideal design. Early in the proposal process, clarify:
- What the website needs to accomplish, such as introducing a new program, rather than simply “making it distinctive.”
- Whether the existing content communicates the message clearly, and which concepts still depend on materials that have not yet been supplied.
- How the proposed colors, layouts, and effects help users read and interact with the website.
Let clients try the website, not just judge its appearance
To win the project, the designer in this case took the extra step of building a working website for the client to try. In his view, a website needs to be experienced through interaction. Static images cannot give clients a feel for how it works or how the layout guides their attention, so discussions can easily become confined to details such as background images or color choices.
This was the author’s approach to a proposal, not a requirement to complete an entire website in advance for every project. The useful principle is: A proposal should help clients understand what reading and interacting with the website will actually feel like, narrowing the gap between the concept and the finished product. Evaluation should go beyond asking whether clients like it. It should also examine how content is presented and whether interactions work as expected.
Animation, in particular, needs to be discussed clearly early on. The author cautioned that if extensive animation is not planned but clients are led to expect it at the outset, those expectations may be difficult to scale back later, causing the project to lose focus. Unnecessary animation may also interfere with reading. This is not a blanket objection to animation, but a recommendation to discuss its purpose before deciding whether to include it.
Include the interface and mobile design while accounting for budget limits
A participant in a Mobile01 discussion noted that website design extends beyond visuals to include the user interface and user experience (UI/UX), as well as how a responsive website appears on different devices to meet users’ needs. The scope can be adjusted to suit the client’s budget. A proposal should therefore do more than seek approval for a single desktop layout. It should also specify what design work is included for the interface, interactions, and mobile version.
The discussion also noted that work does not end when a website is completed and launched; subsequent marketing remains important. Proposals should therefore distinguish between the problems the design can address and the benefits that still depend on follow-up work, rather than equating website delivery with the achievement of marketing goals.
At Procrustes, our services cover page planning, design, and feature development for the websites we build through client partnerships, as well as ongoing content topic planning, writing, updates, and efforts to grow visibility.
Website design and proposals: perspectives from across the web
How much weight should appearance carry when evaluating website design?
Appearance can be part of the discussion, but it should not be the sole criterion. One participant argued that beauty is subjective and that layout and user experience deserve more attention. Another discussion included the interface, user experience, and responsive presentation that meets users’ needs within the scope of design. These aspects can therefore be assessed together when reviewing a design, rather than making a decision based solely on personal preference.
Does a marketing-centered approach prove that a website is effective?
No. The designer in the case said he centered client discussions on marketing to validate the website’s effectiveness and the rationale behind its design. But his article does not specify validation methods, measurement criteria, or performance data. A marketing-centered approach is therefore a starting point for discussion and evaluation, not proof that the website has achieved its marketing goals.
Which should take priority: design or development?
These discussions do not establish that either design or development should always come first. One participant considered website development generally more important than design, while also emphasizing layout and user experience. Another discussion noted that design itself encompasses the interface, user experience, and responsive presentation. The two views draw the line between design and development differently and emphasize different aspects of the work. Before setting priorities, clarify what each side means by design and development.
References
- [心得] 學術網站企劃過程的一些心得www.ptt.cc — Discusses: Does a marketing-centered approach prove that a website is effective?
- How much does web design matter in SEO?www.warriorforum.com — Discusses: How much weight should appearance carry when evaluating website design?; Which should take priority: design or development?
- 開價20幾萬的網站設計www.mobile01.com — Discusses: How much weight should appearance carry when evaluating website design?; Which should take priority: design or development?




