Vertical navigation accommodates more specific categories, makes scanning easier, and offers flexibility as content grows and designs adapt across devices. The trade-off is that it usually takes up more space than horizontal navigation, leaving less room for content. Long menus may also require scrolling to see all the options. According to a design analysis published by NN/g in 2021, left-side vertical navigation on desktop is particularly well suited to websites with a broad and expanding range of content. Still, designers need to weigh whether keeping categories directly visible is worth the loss of content space.
Show specific categories directly to reduce navigation steps
Horizontal menus are constrained by available width, whereas vertical navigation can accommodate more top-level items. This allows websites to show more specific categories that tell users where to find content. Users do not have to select a broad category first to see the options they actually need.
The original article cited the Arbor Restaurant website as it appeared at the time: its vertical menu accommodated 13 sitewide categories. This was a design example, not a recommendation that every website should have 13 items. For business, government, higher education, or healthcare websites whose services may continue to expand, adding categories usually does not require a major redesign of the navigation interface. However, designers still need to decide how new items fit into the existing category structure.
Easier to scan, but text layout still matters
Psycholinguistic research cited in the original article found that searching vertical lists requires fewer eye fixations than searching horizontal lists, because each fixation captures more information from the surrounding area. However, this does not mean every vertical menu is equally usable.
- Left-align labels to avoid the uneven left edge created by centered text, which hinders scanning from item to item.
- Place keywords at the beginning of labels and retain text rather than requiring users to guess what icons mean.
- For left-to-right interfaces, place navigation on the left and use distinct colors or borders; for right-to-left interfaces, place it on the right.
A shared design does not mean hiding navigation on every device
Horizontal navigation usually needs to switch to a vertical layout on mobile. If desktop navigation is already vertical, typography, spacing, category order, and submenu design can be reused across devices with fewer adjustments.
Whether to hide navigation still needs to be considered separately for each device. The original article recommends keeping desktop navigation visible rather than hiding it in a hamburger menu, where users may be less likely to find it. Some mobile websites, however, may need to hide navigation because of limited screen space. The same approach cannot simply be applied to both.
Weigh space trade-offs against window width and menu length
Vertical navigation usually gives more space to the interface framework and a smaller share to content. This makes the trade-off particularly difficult in small windows and on tablets. In very large windows that already have empty space on both sides, the impact may be minimal. Responsive design should therefore determine the navigation format based on window size, rather than simply distinguishing between desktop and mobile.
In long menus, items that require scrolling to reach may receive less attention. The number of visible items varies across screens, so less important items should be placed at the bottom. Even if users know they can scroll, the initial view must first convince them that the website can help them achieve their goal. Designers therefore cannot assume everyone will look through the entire menu.
Vertical navigation: perspectives from across the web
Can you show only icons to save space?
Icons alone should not be the default: users may overlook the navigation, need an extra interaction to see the text, or have to guess what the icons mean. For applications used daily, consider showing text by default and allowing users familiar with the categories to collapse the navigation themselves. This approach is not recommended for websites that individual users visit only occasionally.
Can horizontal and vertical menus appear together?
If both display the same sitewide menu, duplicating it merely to retain both formats is not recommended. The source argues that a duplicate interface is unnecessary and may confuse users. This recommendation concerns sitewide menus with duplicate content; it should not be taken to mean that all combinations of horizontal and vertical navigation are unsuitable.
Does horizontal navigation fit the F-shaped reading pattern better?
The F-shaped reading pattern cannot be used to justify horizontal navigation as the better choice. The source notes that this pattern describes eye movements when reading unstructured text and does not apply to page framework elements such as navigation bars and headers. Choosing a navigation format should still be based on needs such as categories and available space, rather than applying a text-reading pattern.
References
- Left-Side Vertical Navigation on Desktop: Scalable, Responsive, and Easy to Scanwww.nngroup.com · 2021-05-16T16:00:00+0000 — Discusses: Can you show only icons to save space?; Can horizontal and vertical menus appear together?



