To turn audit findings into a URL action list, first confirm the new site’s URL structure, then mark each existing URL to be kept, redirected, or retired. For pages that need redirects, list the most relevant new URL rather than sending everything to the homepage. Next, use this mapping to check for omissions, incorrect redirects, and existing technical issues. The approach below draws on articles about site migration and redesign. It does not revisit content value or treat a completed list as a guarantee that rankings will remain unchanged.
Confirm the new URL structure before filling out the action list
A 2024 migration article on Neil Patel’s website recommends confirming the new site’s URL structure first, to avoid changes to destination URLs at launch after the content has already been mapped. A 2022 redesign article recommends first crawling all site URLs, then identifying pages that are important, irrelevant, or in need of redirects or consolidation.
Once the audit is complete, you can organize the action list using the following fields. This is a working format suggested here, not a standardized template prescribed by the sources:
- Existing URL: Enter the original page URL recorded in the audit.
- Action and rationale: Record whether to keep, redirect, or retire the URL, along with the confirmed audit findings.
- Mapped URL: Enter the destination URL when a redirect is needed. If no suitable page is available yet, mark it as undecided rather than filling in the homepage.
- Check results: Record whether the mapping is correct and any errors that need fixing.
Record content changes separately from URL destinations
The 2024 article proposes the “6R” categories: reformat, repurpose, refresh, retire, redirect, and remain. When organizing URLs, simply writing “update content” does not settle what happens to the URL. How the content should change and where the old URL should ultimately lead are two questions that need separate answers.
- Keep: Record the page being kept and the plan for its URL. List content optimization as a separate task rather than mixing it into redirect instructions.
- Redirect: Following the article’s recommendation, use a 301 redirect to the most relevant new page. For example, if an old tutorial is consolidated into an updated tutorial, the destination should be the page covering that topic, not the homepage.
- Retire: When there is no relevant replacement page, the article suggests considering a new page or removing the old URL. There is no need to force a match with an unrelated page just to fill in the mapping field.
Verify that mappings are implemented, not just that the list is complete
Based on these articles, check whether any old URLs needing redirects have been missed, whether destination pages are relevant, and whether incorrect redirects, 5xx errors, and pagination issues identified in the content map have been addressed. The 2022 article also lists forgotten redirects and failure to retain the best-performing content as common redesign mistakes.
For large sites where handling every page individually is not feasible, the 2024 article recommends prioritizing pages that generate the most traffic or revenue. This only sets the order of work; it does not mean the remaining URLs have passed verification. The same article also notes that there is no guarantee SEO rankings will remain unaffected by a site migration.
URL decisions after a content audit: perspectives from across the web
What other problems can a content map help identify?
When building a content map before migration, you can use a URL crawling tool to organize existing pages and identify broken links, errors, and redirects. These findings can guide corrective work and help the team address existing issues before the move. The tool-generated list still needs to be checked; detecting issues should not be treated as having resolved them.
What follow-up work can you plan for underperforming pages you've decided to keep?
If the audit has determined that a page should be kept but its content is underperforming, the 2022 redesign article recommends rewriting it or adding recent links, research, data, expert interviews, and images or videos. These are content updates to consider after deciding to keep a page and should be planned according to its needs. Updating the content does not, by itself, mean that URL mapping is complete.
References
- Neil Patel’s Website Migration Checklistneilpatel.com · 2024-08-12T19:00:00+00:00 — Discusses: What other problems can a content map help identify?
- Website Redesign SEO Checklist: Tips to Avoid Big Drops in Your Rankingsneilpatel.com · 2022-02-18T17:01:54+00:00 — Discusses: What follow-up work can you plan for underperforming pages you've decided to keep?




