The possibility of turning posts into conversion-focused pages later is not enough, on its own, to justify removing /blog/ and setting up 301 redirects now. These discussions suggest that a change may be worth considering if the future use is clear and the expected benefits justify the risk of losing revenue from existing pages. If repurposing the content is only a possibility, there is not enough here to conclude that changing the URLs now is the better choice. A 301 redirect handles a URL move; it does not guarantee future rankings or conversions.
Are you changing the content or the URL?
Warrior Forum user ganderson, who asked the question, described his past approach with a flat URL structure: he would write articles on a topic, then replace some with conversion-focused pages at the same URLs once they ranked. He said this worked very well in some cases. For example, /great-topic/ could stay the same even when the content’s purpose changed.
His experience does not establish that the flat URL structure was responsible for those results, or that removing /blog/ is necessary to repurpose content. He also stated that having /blog/ in a URL is not inherently a problem from Google’s perspective. This is a participant’s claim, however; the supplied sources do not include official Google guidance on it. Removing /blog/ therefore should not be treated as correcting an existing SEO mistake.
A 301 redirect handles a move; it does not make the move worthwhile
A Semrush article dated May 8, 2020 recommends setting up a 301 redirect from the old URL to the new one when a page moves to a different path. It also recommends planning the URL structure well from the outset to avoid needing redirects later.
This historical article offers advice on handling a move, but it does not mean that restructuring URLs that already rank is necessarily better now. Avoiding a future move and moving existing pages now are two different decisions. Forum participant tukemon favored the change, saying it would allow a return to content creation afterward. Stella Warren expected a possible short-term impact on rankings but long-term benefits for new articles. These are participants’ judgments, with no accompanying data sufficient to confirm the results.
Weigh current revenue and future use, not just conversion volume
dave_hermansen focused on the revenue the URLs generate each day and whether long-term gains could offset potential losses. Following that reasoning, first clarify:
- Future use: Which articles do you actually intend to turn into conversion-focused pages, rather than merely considering it if they rank well?
- Potential losses: How much revenue do these URLs generate each day? Few conversions do not mean the risks of moving them can be ignored.
- Expected benefits: What improvements do you expect? Why would they justify the risk of reduced revenue from existing pages?
dave_hermansen’s reply suggested that there might be no loss, or that losses might last a week or two. This was only a hypothetical scenario, not an assurance of recovery within that period. If future benefits remain unclear, that estimate should not be used to justify the change. First clarify the intended use and the losses you can tolerate; that gives you a basis for deciding whether changing the URLs now is worthwhile.
Removing /blog/ and setting up 301 redirects: perspectives from across the web
If articles generate few conversions, does that mean changing their URLs has little cost?
No. Conversion volume alone is not enough to judge. Forum respondent dave_hermansen suggested looking at the revenue the relevant URLs generate each day, then weighing potential losses against expected long-term gains. Even if conversions are currently low, first work out how much revenue the pages generate and how much you can afford to lose. The available data is not enough to estimate the cost of changing the URLs in this case.
Did participants agree on changing the URLs now?
No. Stella Warren believed updating the URLs could temporarily affect rankings but would benefit new articles in the long run. tukemon also favored the change, reasoning that once it was done, the focus could return to creating content. By contrast, dave_hermansen advocated weighing existing revenue against potential long-term gains. These are participants' expectations and judgments, not guarantees of results.
If you decide to change the path, when does the recommendation to use a 301 redirect apply?
In its 2020 article, Semrush recommended setting up a 301 redirect from the old URL to the new one when a page moves to a different URL path. This is advice on handling a move once the decision has been made, not a reason that a move is necessary. The article is historical material and should not be treated as a current platform rule.
References
- To change URL structure, or not to change URL structure?www.warriorforum.com — Source used in the article above.
- 301 Redirects: How to Use Them & How They Affect SEOwww.semrush.com · 2020-05-08T15:32:00Z — Discusses: If you decide to change the path, when does the recommendation to use a 301 redirect apply?
- To change URL structure, or not to change URL structure?www.warriorforum.com — Discusses: Did participants agree on changing the URLs now?
- To change URL structure, or not to change URL structure?www.warriorforum.com — Discusses: If articles generate few conversions, does that mean changing their URLs has little cost?; Did participants agree on changing the URLs now?
- To change URL structure, or not to change URL structure?www.warriorforum.com — Discusses: Did participants agree on changing the URLs now?

