When planning changes to URLs and pages, first list the existing URLs, then decide whether to keep, move, consolidate, or permanently remove each page. When content moves to a new URL, redirect the old URL to the corresponding page. When content is permanently removed and has no corresponding page, do not redirect it to unrelated content. Redirects are no substitute for updating the site itself: internal links, sitemaps, and other places that use old URLs must still be updated to use the final URLs.
Inventory URLs first, then create a URL mapping table
A Semrush migration article dated 2019 recommends compiling existing URLs from crawlers, search indexes, traffic records, backlinks, XML sitemaps, and the CMS. Using multiple sources helps avoid overlooking important content. The inventory should not be limited to pages currently visible in site menus.
A 2022 article on Neil Patel’s website recommends listing content to keep, retire, or move to a different URL, pairing old URLs with their new destinations, and then handing the mapping table to developers for implementation. The table should clearly state how each old URL will be handled, rather than merely listing the pages about to launch on the new site.
Decide which content to keep, consolidate, or delete
- Content stays and the URL is unchanged: Add it to the list of pages to keep. There is no need to find another destination just to fill in a redirect table.
- Content stays but the URL changes: The Semrush migration article mentioned above recommends setting up a server-side 301 redirect from the old URL to the corresponding new page. This takes visitors to the relocated content and tells search engines that the resource has moved permanently.
- Content overlaps across multiple pages: A 2026 Content Marketing Institute article suggests consolidating it into one comprehensive page, then redirecting the old URLs to the consolidated content. Retiring content does not necessarily mean deleting it outright.
- Content is permanently removed with no corresponding replacement: The Semrush article mentioned above recommends returning a 410 response to indicate that the resource has been permanently removed, rather than redirecting to an unrelated page. This is that article’s recommendation, not a universal rule for every page deletion.
For example, outdated blog posts that will not move to the new site should not all be redirected to the blog homepage simply because it still exists. What matters is whether the destination offers corresponding content, not whether the old URL can send visitors to some page that still loads.
Update old URLs as well as setting up redirects
Following the checklist in the Semrush migration article dated 2019, you can first check links in the navigation, footer, and page content on a staging site, along with XML sitemaps, robots.txt, and canonical tags. If the site has multilingual versions, also check the applicable hreflang annotations. Having redirects in place is no reason to skip these checks.
A 2026 Search Engine Journal article notes that if internal links still point to old URLs, every visit through those links will involve a redirect. Multiple hops add latency, consume crawl resources, and may cause Googlebot to give up before reaching the destination. Internal links should therefore point directly to the final URLs, rather than continuing to rely on redirect chains left over from successive migrations.
URL changes and page deletions: perspectives from across the web
Should low-traffic pages simply be deleted?
Not necessarily. A content-pruning example from Screaming Frog flags pages with zero daily clicks and no more than one daily active user for review. Options include redirecting to a related page, applying noindex, or deleting the page and returning a 410 response. These figures are example thresholds, not deletion criteria that apply to every website; low traffic does not mean deletion is the only option.
What should you check first when you encounter a 404?
First check whether the URL contains a typo, the page has been deleted, or the content has moved without a proper redirect from the old URL. A 404 means the server cannot find content at the requested URL; by itself, it does not establish which of these caused the error. If the error comes from a URL in an internal link or sitemap, address the actual cause rather than automatically setting up a redirect.
How long should redirects remain in place?
A Semrush article dated 2020 recommends keeping redirects in place for at least a year after a URL change, on the grounds that systems need to encounter the redirect multiple times to register the change. This is a recommendation from that historical article and should not be treated as a current platform rule. The supplied material also does not establish that every website can safely remove redirects after one year.
References
- Google Search Console Errors: Identifying and Fixing Themwww.semrush.com · 2024-03-20T10:51:00Z — Discusses: What should you check first when you encounter a 404?
- Why Internal Links Quietly Decay & How To Reclaim The Equity You’re Losingwww.searchenginejournal.com · 2026-06-29T11:00:27+00:00 — Source used in the article above.
- Data-Driven Content Pruning at Scale Using APIs and the Screaming Frog SEO Spiderwww.screamingfrog.co.uk · 2026-01-12T11:15:07+00:00 — Discusses: Should low-traffic pages simply be deleted?
- Website Redesign SEO Checklist: Tips to Avoid Big Drops in Your Rankingsneilpatel.com · 2022-02-18T17:01:54+00:00 — Source used in the article above.
- Your Outdated Content Lives Forever in AI Search: Here's How To Manage Itcontentmarketinginstitute.com · 2026-08-13T10:00:00.000Z — Source used in the article above.
- Redirects: What They Are & How to Use Themwww.semrush.com · 2020-07-20T11:00:00Z — Discusses: How long should redirects remain in place?
- The Complete Website Migration Checklist [SEO-Friendly]www.semrush.com · 2019-03-25T13:30:00Z — Source used in the article above.



