When does personalization make people uneasy?

ProcrustesPR

Personalization is more likely to make people uneasy when sensitive information appears in an inappropriate setting, ads seem to know about users’ activity on other websites or devices, or a single search triggers a flood of related messages. Reactions vary, however: some people feel watched, while others are mainly bothered by repetitive ads or seeing a lower price after making a purchase. A research article published by NN/g in 2019 illustrates these differences. What matters is not just whether the content is relevant, but also whether data is used in ways users do not expect.

ProcrustesPRProcrustesPRDo I still need SEO if I already run Google Ads?

When sensitive content appears in the wrong context

Examples listed by NN/g include pregnancy information and products, funeral preparations, and embarrassing medical issues. When this content appears outside its original context, it can trigger strong emotions, rather than simply making a recommendation seem inaccurate.

When an interaction involves sensitive information or information users expect to remain confidential, it needs to stay private or be handled with greater care. That does not mean all recommendations involving such information are unsettling; the context in which they appear still matters.

Why does the computer seem to know about activity on the phone?

Most participants in the study knew that websites used on-site interactions to tailor ads, but did not understand how data was used across websites and devices. Personalization can seem especially creepy when content goes beyond what users think a website or device “should know.”

  • One study participant in China understood why their phone showed content related to what they had browsed on it, but felt uneasy when similar ads appeared on their computer.
  • A user in Raleigh found Facebook unsettling because it seemed to know about and use her search data from Amazon and Google.

The latter reflects the user’s feelings and interpretation of the ads; the research article did not confirm that these websites had passed the data to Facebook. These two examples show how personalization can exceed users’ expectations about where their data is used, but they do not establish that everyone rejects cross-device personalization.

One search, followed by seemingly endless related ads

NN/g also noted that a single action can trigger a flood of related content, including direct mail, email, other ads, and articles, which can feel unsettling. One participant in China described searching for a toilet on Taobao: afterward, information about bathroom products appeared everywhere, and the ads continued even after the purchase.

The participant described two sources of frustration: repetitive ads were annoying, and seeing a lower price after purchasing was also upsetting. These reactions differ from concern about private information being exposed and should not all be treated as “fear of being tracked.”

Different views on privacy and email advertising

In 2004, Search Engine Journal reported on the controversy surrounding Gmail’s beta launch: did contextual ads in private email violate privacy? The article noted that some people argued privacy violations did not count when a service was free, while some interviewees felt uneasy about the potential privacy implications of these ads.

However, most interviewees in that report were active Google advertisers, so their views cannot be taken as representative of ordinary email users. The claim that “it does not count as a violation if it is free” was also just one position. This historical report illustrates disagreements at the time; it does not describe Gmail’s current advertising or data-handling rules.

ProcrustesPRProcrustesPRHow is organic traffic different from paid traffic?

Personalization: perspectives from across the web

Why can recommendations feel unsettling even when they are relevant?

Relevant content does not necessarily appear at an appropriate time or place. When pregnancy, funeral preparations, or embarrassing medical issues are involved, users may expect the interaction to remain private. Related content appearing in an inappropriate context can trigger strong emotions. This does not mean that all recommendations involving sensitive topics are unsettling; reactions still depend on the context.

Does accepting on-site personalization necessarily mean users accept cross-device advertising?

Not necessarily. Most participants in NN/g’s study knew that websites used data from interactions on their own sites, but did not understand how data was used across websites or devices. One participant in China understood why content on their phone related to their browsing activity on that phone, but found it unsettling when related ads appeared on their computer. This reflects an individual user’s reaction and does not establish that everyone opposes cross-device personalization.

Does a free email service eliminate privacy concerns about its ads?

Privacy concerns can still arise. During Gmail’s beta testing in 2004, some people argued that privacy violations did not count when a service was free, while some interviewees felt uneasy about the privacy implications of contextual ads in private email. Most interviewees in that report were active Google advertisers and cannot represent ordinary users. Nor can this controversy be used to determine today’s service rules.

ProcrustesPRHow do cookies work, and what are their uses and privacy risks?

References

  1. The Dangers of Overpersonalizationwww.nngroup.com · 2019-01-20T17:00:00+0000 — Discusses: Why can recommendations feel unsettling even when they are relevant?; Does accepting on-site personalization necessarily mean users accept cross-device advertising?
  2. Google Advertisers Like GMail, But Want Lower Rateswww.searchenginejournal.com · 2004-05-11T16:26:22+00:00 — Discusses: Does a free email service eliminate privacy concerns about its ads?

Related articles

Do I still need SEO if I already run Google Ads?How is organic traffic different from paid traffic?How do cookies work, and what are their uses and privacy risks?Can AdSense Be Used for SEO? Ad Monetization Is Not Ranking OptimizationWhat Value Does SEO Offer the Travel Industry?How Do SEO and PPC Differ? Speed, Costs, Benefits, and LimitationsHow Are SEO, SEM, and Backlinks Related?How Are SEO, Paid Search, and SEM Related?
ProcrustesPR
ProcrustesPR