Unnatural linking means deliberately arranging links to manipulate search rankings, rather than using them to reference content normally. It includes both backlinks pointing to a website and outbound links from that website. Unnatural links may affect search performance, but losing the ranking benefits a link once provided is not the same as receiving a manual action for link manipulation. Unfamiliar links alone do not mean a website will be penalized.
Look at how links are created, not just how many there are
Check how links were created, whether they were intended to manipulate rankings, and what anchor text they use. Anchor text is the clickable text of a link.
- Buying links for rankings: Buying large numbers of links and requiring different websites to use the same specified keywords may reveal a pattern of ranking manipulation.
- Repeated exact-match keywords: An article on the iThome platform gives this example: if many links mentioning a brand use “SEO company” as their anchor text rather than the brand name, it is worth examining how those links were created.
These are clues to investigate, not a way to determine whether links are unnatural based on a percentage alone. Suggested anchor text ratios should not be treated as Google’s official safety thresholds.
Reciprocal links do not necessarily mean ranking manipulation
When two websites cite each other, their links should not be considered unnatural simply because they are reciprocal. A 2019 observational study by Ahrefs found that some websites with relatively high proportions of reciprocal links still performed reasonably well on Google.
However, the study included only websites with search traffic. This may have excluded penalized websites from the outset, introducing survivorship bias. The study therefore proves neither that reciprocal links are entirely safe nor that linking to each other improves rankings. Normal references and deliberate manipulation still need to be assessed separately.
Distinguish lost link benefits from manual actions
Welly’s overview of the December 2022 link spam update explains that SpamBrain is used to detect spammy links. The focus is on removing the ranking benefits of unnatural links rather than lowering rankings as a penalty. This describes that particular update; it does not mean that unnatural links never lead to penalties.
A 2024 Semrush article explains that manipulative linking practices may trigger a manual action, potentially resulting in lower rankings or even removal from the index. Losing link benefits and receiving a manual action are different outcomes. Nor should every ranking decline be attributed to unnatural links.
Address clear risks, not every warning
In 2024, Ahrefs cited consultant Marie Haynes’s advice: a thorough link audit and submission of a disavow file are recommended only when a website has received a manual action notice for unnatural links through Search Console or has a large number of links that could be considered manipulative.
This advice applies under specific conditions; it is not a recommendation for every website to disavow suspicious links. The article also cautions that blindly disavowing “toxic links” flagged by SEO tools may not help and could carry risks. Normal links that point naturally to content can generally be kept.
Unnatural links: perspectives from across the web
Do large numbers of links from unfamiliar websites mean you are under a negative SEO attack?
Not necessarily. Negative SEO may involve large numbers of unnatural links intended to get a competitor penalized. However, spam articles may also add external links at random to appear credible, without targeting a website for an attack. Semrush's article notes that these attacks are uncommon and that Google is increasingly able to ignore attack-related links. When unfamiliar links appear, first examine their sources and the overall situation rather than immediately drawing conclusions about intent or penalties.
What is the problem when link text does not match the destination content?
If link text promises hotel deals but takes readers to a video game website, it may mislead them. A URL that appears to point to a marketing article but unexpectedly redirects to unrelated content presents a similar problem. One article lists these practices as examples of unnatural links because they may deceive users and harm their experience. When checking a link, examine its clickable text, actual destination, and content after any redirects.
How should websites that accept comments or submissions monitor links added by users?
Regularly review links in comments and submissions, checking whether they are relevant to the website's users and helpful to readers rather than placed solely to manipulate rankings. For links that are difficult to assess immediately, one article recommends recording them and continuing to monitor them with Search Console. This is a management recommendation for websites that allow users to publish content, not a claim that every user-added link harms search performance.
References
- Negative SEO – Should You Monitor Your Backlinks?www.screamingfrog.co.uk · 2014-03-17T15:43:49+00:00 — Discusses: Do large numbers of links from unfamiliar websites mean you are under a negative SEO attack?
- Google 演算法最新整理!SEO 優化必學的 6 大演算法!welly.tw · 2022-06-27T06:43:31.235Z — Source used in the article above.
- I Disavowed “Toxic Backlinks”: Here’s What Happenedahrefs.com · 2024-08-29T13:34:32+00:00 — Source used in the article above.
- 認識 Google Penguin – 黑帽 SEO與反向連結的守門員www.yesharris.com — Discusses: What is the problem when link text does not match the destination content?; How should websites that accept comments or submissions monitor links added by users?
- What Is Black Hat SEO? 9 Risky Techniques To Avoidwww.semrush.com · 2020-11-19T14:31:00Z — Discusses: Do large numbers of links from unfamiliar websites mean you are under a negative SEO attack?
- 3+4 個 Google 判斷付費連結 (Paid Links) 的方法ithelp.ithome.com.tw — Source used in the article above.
- Unnatural Links: What They Are and How to Fix Your Link Profilewww.semrush.com · 2024-02-28T13:10:00Z — Source used in the article above.
- Reciprocal Links: Will They Hurt Your SEO? (A Study by Ahrefs)ahrefs.com · 2019-01-29T16:28:34+00:00 — Source used in the article above.



