When traffic drops, how can you distinguish between manual actions, algorithmic filtering, and core updates?

ProcrustesPR

A traffic drop does not necessarily mean a penalty. Start by checking Search Console for manual action notifications. Then review when traffic fell and which pages were affected, and compare your findings with core update announcements. The absence of a notification does not establish that algorithmic filtering is responsible. Manual actions come with case-specific feedback, while algorithmic effects require step-by-step investigation. Core update timing is only a clue: overlapping dates alone cannot establish the cause.

ProcrustesPRProcrustesPRHow should I divide my DIY SEO budget?

Look for manual action notifications first, rather than guessing from the size of the drop

Semrush’s 2024 overview notes that manual actions come with explicit feedback through Search Console, and lifting them requires a case review by Google’s team. By contrast, algorithm-driven ranking changes do not come with these individual notifications. The first step is therefore to check whether the manual actions report identifies a problem, rather than calling a sudden traffic drop a “penalty.”

  • If there is a manual action notification: plan fixes for the problems identified in the notification, guided by the case-specific feedback.
  • If there is no manual action notification: continue checking indexing status, search demand, and ranking changes. The absence of a notification does not rule out other problems.

Compare the timing with core updates, but also investigate changes in demand

A 2025 Semrush article notes that major core updates are publicly announced. Comparing organic search traffic trends with update timing can help narrow the investigation. However, a decline during the same period does not mean the update caused it, much less establish that the site violated any rules.

For example, a 2020 Semrush article uses Christmas-related pages to illustrate how a January traffic decline could result from lower search demand. The article also recommends checking whether the affected pages are still indexed. These checks help avoid attributing every change in demand or indexing problem to an algorithm.

Algorithmic filtering is an explanation to test, not a confirmed diagnosis

In Semrush’s 2020 expert interview, experts differed in how they described “algorithmic penalties”: Fili Wiese argued that algorithms simply rank pages based on signals, while Kristine Schachinger preferred “algorithmic devaluation” to distinguish it from manual actions. These are expert interpretations, not current official classification rules.

Possible causes listed in the interview include declining page relevance, unnatural links no longer being counted toward rankings, or competing pages moving up. If a page you expect to rank disappears from the results and another page ranks instead, that can provide a clue for investigation. It does not, on its own, prove filtering. Core updates and algorithmic ranking changes should not be treated as entirely mutually exclusive causes, either.

Recovery cases are not formulas for fixing a site

The same 2020 interview describes a client who had received no manual action notification and showed signs of recovery about four months after cleaning up links. The interviewee thought algorithmic filtering might have been involved. This was an assessment of that particular case, not proof that the link cleanup caused the recovery or grounds for promising results within four months. Further action should address identified problems, rather than copy a case study or assume there is only one solution.

ProcrustesPRProcrustesPRWhy is AI not mentioning my brand?

Diagnosing traffic drops: perspectives from across the web

How do core updates differ from updates targeting specific systems?

A 2023 SEO article describes core updates as changes to the overall system that affect a broad range of search results. Updates targeting specific systems focus on areas such as reviews or spam. This distinction can help narrow an investigation, but a page’s category alone does not establish that the corresponding update affected it. Outside observers also cannot easily determine the actual ranking signals or their weights.

Does a manual action always make an entire website disappear from search results?

No. Experts in Semrush’s 2020 interview noted that a manual action can affect only part of a site or be severe enough to remove it entirely from search results. Whether a site can still be found in search therefore does not establish whether it has received a manual action. Check the case-specific information in Search Console to confirm the problem and its impact before planning a response.

Will rankings definitely recover with the next update after a site is improved?

There is no guarantee. In Semrush’s 2020 interview, an interviewee suggested that algorithmic devaluation may involve systemic problems and usually has no simple fix. She had also seen older sites with limited content additions gain traffic after an update. Improvements should therefore target identified problems, but whether and when they will take effect are difficult to predict. A traffic recovery alone also does not prove that a particular change caused it.

ProcrustesPRDoes an AI brand mention bring website visitors?

References

  1. SEO FAQ: 25 Questions & Answers for Beginnerswww.semrush.com · 2020-10-22T13:20:00Z — Source used in the article above.
  2. How to Improve Your Google Rankings (Without Getting Penalized)neilpatel.com · 2023-05-19T19:00:00+00:00 — Source used in the article above.
  3. Essential Expert Tips on Fixing and Avoiding Google Penaltieswww.semrush.com · 2020-07-17T11:20:00Z — Discusses: Does a manual action always make an entire website disappear from search results?; Will rankings definitely recover with the next update after a site is improved?
  4. 與 Google 演算法同行,讓你做好 SEO 沒煩惱!【2023/10 更新】www.awoo.ai · 2023-10-20T11:09:25+00:00 — Discusses: How do core updates differ from updates targeting specific systems?
  5. A Comprehensive Guide to Understanding Google Penaltieswww.semrush.com · 2024-02-29T11:40:00Z — Source used in the article above.
  6. How does Google’s algorithm work?www.semrush.com · 2025-09-25T19:07:00Z — Source used in the article above.

Related articles

How should I divide my DIY SEO budget?Why is AI not mentioning my brand?Does an AI brand mention bring website visitors?How Long Does It Take to Evaluate SEO Results?How do I write titles customers want to click?How is organic traffic different from paid traffic?Why do I have keyword rankings but no customers?Are Google Maps rankings the same as website SEO?
ProcrustesPR
ProcrustesPR