SEO practitioners disagree about disavowing “toxic links” mainly over which links are genuinely harmful and when to act. In the articles discussed here, some authors advocate assessing, removing, or disavowing suspicious links. Others oppose acting solely on tool-generated flags, arguing that the benefits are limited and useful links may be disavowed by mistake. There is more common ground on one point: receiving a manual action for unnatural links, or having a large number of manipulative links, provides clearer grounds for an in-depth review. These recommendations come from authors writing at different times and should not be taken as current official rules.
Different definitions of “toxic” lead to different recommendations
A roundup on WarriorForum notes that some practitioners use “toxic” to describe unnatural links that violate Google’s link guidelines. Others use it for spam links that Google says its algorithms ignore. The post also states that Google itself does not have a concept of “toxic links.”
Before deciding whether to disavow links, it is important to clarify whether they were purchased to manipulate rankings or are spam links flagged as suspicious by a tool. Sharing the “toxic” label does not mean both call for the same response.
Caution about disavowing does not mean all links are harmless
In a 2024 Ahrefs article, Joshua Hardwick argues that his data suggests blindly disavowing toxic links flagged by SEO tools is unlikely to bring significant benefits. He cites Marie Haynes’s view that SEO tools rarely identify the links that could genuinely harm a site through the algorithms.
The article also describes a 2021 test: after all links to the same set of three articles were disavowed, traffic fell sharply. This was not a test of disavowing only toxic links, so it does not establish that every cleanup will hurt rankings. It supports only a narrower caution: if a tool incorrectly labels helpful links as toxic, disavowing everything it flags could harm traffic.
Hardwick also acknowledges that many SEO practitioners disagree with him and believe disavowing links helps. However, the excerpts cited here do not describe the circumstances of their individual cases, so they do not establish that disavowing links is generally effective.
Recommendations also differ on when to act
- The 2024 Ahrefs article quotes Haynes as recommending a full review followed by submission of a disavow file when a site has received a manual action for unnatural links or has a large number of links that the webspam team might consider manipulative.
- A Semrush guide dated 2020 recommends considering disavowal only when links clearly threaten search visibility and warns that mistakenly disavowing useful links could harm SEO.
- Sydney Go’s 2024 Semrush article focuses on lowering a tool’s toxicity score. It lists options such as acquiring high-quality links, requesting removal, and assessing whether to disavow, rather than recommending disavowal across the board.
These recommendations address different problems: lowering a tool’s score, addressing a clear risk, and improving search traffic are not the same thing. When weighing individual cases and recommendations, focus on the conditions for taking action rather than simply sorting opinions into “for” and “against.”
Disavowing toxic links: perspectives from across the web
What can you do if you do not want to disavow links right away?
If you believe particular links are harming your site, you can first contact the site owners and ask them to remove the links. A Semrush article also lists acquiring more high-quality links as a way to lower a tool’s toxicity score. However, a lower score is not proof that search traffic will improve. Whether to disavow still requires a separate assessment, rather than a decision based solely on changes in the score.
Should you disavow an entire domain if it has many suspicious links?
The decision should not be based on quantity alone. A Semrush article dated 2020 recommends carefully investigating each link. Adding a domain to a disavow file may be worth considering only if a large number of toxic links from that domain are known to be harming SEO. This is the author’s recommendation under specific conditions; a high number of suspicious links does not itself prove harm.
Will disavowing links lift a manual action for unnatural links?
There is no guarantee. A Semrush article recommends disavowing toxic backlinks to address this type of action. A 2013 article on Neil Patel’s website also recommends making efforts to have links removed after confirming the problem, and submitting a reconsideration request in cases involving a manual penalty. These are recommendations from authors writing at different times, not current official requirements for lifting a manual action or guarantees of success.
References
- I Disavowed “Toxic Backlinks”: Here’s What Happenedahrefs.com · 2024-08-29T13:34:32+00:00 — Source used in the article above.
- Who Links to My Site? How to Find and Analyze Backlinkswww.semrush.com · 2024-01-10T16:51:00Z — Discusses: What can you do if you do not want to disavow links right away?
- 50 Reasons Your Website Deserves to Be Penalized By Googleneilpatel.com · 2013-07-03T17:20:23+00:00 — Discusses: Will disavowing links lift a manual action for unnatural links?
- Toxic links and disavows: A comprehensive SEO guidewww.warriorforum.com — Source used in the article above.
- Google Search Console: the ultimate guide for 2026www.semrush.com · 2019-10-30T07:00:00Z — Discusses: Will disavowing links lift a manual action for unnatural links?
- Essential Expert Tips on Fixing and Avoiding Google Penaltieswww.semrush.com · 2020-07-17T11:20:00Z — Discusses: Should you disavow an entire domain if it has many suspicious links?
- How to Disavow Backlinks (+ Find Out if You Really Should)www.semrush.com · 2020-07-10T11:00:00Z — Source used in the article above.
- Private Blog Networks (PBNs): What Are They & Do They Work?www.semrush.com · 2020-11-12T18:00:00Z — Discusses: What can you do if you do not want to disavow links right away?



