Why do websites, including forums, receive thin content penalties?

ProcrustesPR

When a website or forum receives a manual action for thin content, start with the notice’s reference to “little or no added value.” Originality, writing costs, and the number of posts alone do not explain a page’s value. The cases discussed here involve large numbers of location pages, multiple nearly duplicate websites, and potential content problems with automated forum replies. However, many of the suggested explanations came from people who had not reviewed the sites, so they cannot be treated as confirmed causes in individual cases.

ProcrustesPRProcrustesPRCan AI-written articles work for SEO?

First, confirm the type of notice and which pages are affected

Daniel, who runs a UK home services website, explicitly said he received a manual action notice for thin content. The discussion included a suggestion that “Google may simply be reassessing the value of service pages, rather than imposing a penalty.” But that suggestion does not account for the manual action notice he reported. Check each of these points:

  • Whether the site received a manual action notice, rather than just experiencing a decline in search traffic.
  • Whether the notice identifies the entire site or a specific URL section as affected.
  • Whether it provides example URLs for a closer comparison of the content.

Search Engine Journal reported a forum case in July 2026. According to the site owner, the notice listed only windowsforum.com/threads/, covering 168,290 visible threads and more than half a million posts. It did not provide example URLs. This was a partial manual action, not a sitewide penalty; other sections were not affected by this action.

Originality and content volume alone do not establish a page’s value

Daniel said the content was human-written, entirely unique, and produced at considerable expense. But these statements from the site owner do not establish whether each location page provides distinct, useful information. Having only skimmed the discussion without reviewing the website, gyitsakalakis speculated that the location pages might be considered doorway pages. Marie Haynes also thought the three thousand location pages might be related to the action, but stressed that a deeper investigation was needed. Page count alone was not enough to reach a conclusion.

Marie suggested checking whether content that could have been covered on one page or a few pages had been expanded into thousands of pages for search visibility. In an interview published in 2020, she also recalled a case involving multiple nearly duplicate sites. That was her experience with a past case, not evidence of a current rule that “running multiple sites will get you penalized.”

The forum case raised another question: according to the report, the forum’s AI bot had posted more than one hundred thousand replies since 2023. SEO practitioners speculated that the large volume of automated replies might have triggered the action. However, the available information contains no evidence that Google confirmed the cause, so this case does not establish that using AI leads to a penalty.

Speculation about competitor reports cannot replace a content assessment

Was the action against the site using location pages triggered by a competitor’s report? The available information does not establish this. Fergster and Daniel both suspected it was, while keyserholiday believed Google had acted on its own. Neither side provided verifiable evidence of what triggered the action. Competitors still having similar pages does not prove that this site was singled out.

Participants recommended revising the content first, then submitting a reconsideration request through Search Console. Removing suspected doorway pages may help get the action lifted, but does not guarantee that traffic will recover. Expanding the page content does not guarantee a successful reconsideration request either. The first step should be to clarify the purpose and value of the affected pages, rather than treating a higher word count or page removal as a guaranteed fix.

ProcrustesPRProcrustesPRHow should you use AI for SEO keyword research?

Thin content penalties: perspectives from across the web

Why did other sections of the forum that seemed thinner not receive the same action?

The notice alone does not establish why other sections were not included. In the July 2026 forum case, the site owner noted that syndicated headlines and an archived knowledge base had been inactive for three years but were not named; the partial manual action applied to the threads section. This difference does not prove that the forum content was worse, nor is it enough to infer whether other sections might face action later.

Could running multiple similar websites be related to a thin content action?

Possibly, but running multiple sites alone is not enough to establish a violation. In an interview published in 2020, Marie Haynes recalled a payday loan company with multiple nearly duplicate sites that might have been viewed as doorway sites. Immediately after its unnatural links action was lifted, it received a thin content action. This is an account of an individual case, not a rule that applies to all multi-site operations today.

How long does a thin content manual action usually last?

There is no fixed timeline that applies to every website. Participants noted that recovery time depends on the circumstances; if a site does not change the content Google considers thin, the action may remain in place for a long time. Marie Haynes also cautioned that lost traffic may be difficult to recover even after the action is lifted, so the removal of an action and a full traffic recovery should be treated as separate outcomes.

ProcrustesPRDo AI Text Watermarks Affect Search Rankings?

References

  1. Google Manual Penalty - Thin Contentlocalsearchforum.com — Discusses: How long does a thin content manual action usually last?
  2. Google May Be Penalizing AI-Generated Content As Thin Contentwww.searchenginejournal.com · 2026-07-27T11:49:14+00:00 — Discusses: Why did other sections of the forum that seemed thinner not receive the same action?
  3. Google Manual Penalty - Thin Contentlocalsearchforum.com — Source used in the article above.
  4. Google Manual Penalty - Thin Contentlocalsearchforum.com — Source used in the article above.
  5. Essential Expert Tips on Fixing and Avoiding Google Penaltieswww.semrush.com · 2020-07-17T11:20:00Z — Discusses: Could running multiple similar websites be related to a thin content action?
  6. Google Manual Penalty - Thin Contentlocalsearchforum.com — Source used in the article above.
  7. Google Manual Penalty - Thin Contentlocalsearchforum.com — Source used in the article above.
  8. Google Manual Penalty - Thin Contentlocalsearchforum.com — Discusses: How long does a thin content manual action usually last?
  9. Google Manual Penalty - Thin Contentlocalsearchforum.com — Source used in the article above.
  10. Google Manual Penalty - Thin Contentlocalsearchforum.com — Source used in the article above.
  11. Google Manual Penalty - Thin Contentlocalsearchforum.com — Source used in the article above.

Related articles

Can AI-written articles work for SEO?How should you use AI for SEO keyword research?Do AI Text Watermarks Affect Search Rankings?How can you improve AI-generated websites and their search performance?How Can Human-Led SEO Build a Long-Term Advantage?Which SEO practices or mistakes can affect rankings?What are the risks of AI-generated content, and how can it be improved?How Can AI Help Writers Overcome the Blank Page and Foster Creativity?
ProcrustesPR
ProcrustesPR