A temporary redirect does not mean that all search signals from the source URL are transferred to the destination URL. According to the official Google documentation cited here, Googlebot follows temporary redirects, but the indexing process does not treat the redirect itself as a signal that the destination URL should be canonical. The destination page may still be indexed because of other canonicalization signals. In a 2023 article, Ahrefs explicitly argued that signals are consolidated in the opposite direction, toward the source URL. This does not, however, justify attributing every ranking change to temporary redirects or assuming a fixed time threshold exists.
Following a redirect does not mean treating the destination URL as canonical
Google’s documentation distinguishes permanent and temporary redirects on two points: which URL is intended to appear in search results, and whether the redirect provides a canonicalization signal. A permanent redirect signals that the destination URL should be canonical. A temporary redirect indicates that the source URL should remain in search results and does not provide the same signal.
- Crawling: Googlebot can follow a temporary redirect to the destination page.
- Canonical URL: A crawler reaching the destination page does not, by itself, establish that the destination URL has replaced the source URL.
- Indexing: The destination page may still be indexed because of other canonicalization signals. Using a 302 does not guarantee that it will never be indexed.
For example, if A temporarily redirects to B, the crawler will follow the redirect. That does not mean all of A’s signals have been assigned to B.
“Not consolidating toward the destination URL” does not mean “no consolidation at all”
In a 2023 article, Ahrefs author Patrick Stox argued that temporary redirects consolidate signals in the opposite direction, toward the original URL. He also said that many SEO practitioners still did not believe this explanation at the time. This is Patrick Stox’s explanation of how signals are consolidated; the Google documentation cited here does not explicitly confirm the full mechanism.
By contrast, awoo’s 2020 article explained 302 redirects as “transferring traffic only, not ranking weight” and claimed that search engines retain the old URL’s indexing, rankings, and ranking weight. This is not the same as Ahrefs’ explanation of where signals are consolidated: even if signals are not passed toward the destination URL, that does not mean no consolidation occurs, nor does it guarantee unchanged rankings.
These accounts do not establish when rankings might be affected
awoo’s 2020 article also warned that prolonged use of a 302 could affect the old page’s rankings, offering explanations such as users mistaking which URL is canonical. However, the content cited here provides no verifiable duration in days, observation methods, or ranking-change data. The warning therefore should not be treated as a current rule that “rankings drop after a certain number of days.”
When interpreting redirect outcomes, record each factor separately: the redirect type, its duration, the URL displayed in search results, and whether other canonicalization signals are present. The destination page being indexed does not, by itself, establish that the 302 has transferred all ranking weight to the destination URL. If the redirect will definitely not be reversed, Google’s documentation recommends a permanent redirect. Following that recommendation has a more direct basis in the documentation than guessing when a search engine might reinterpret a temporary redirect.
Search signal attribution during temporary redirects: perspectives from across the web
Which type of redirect is appropriate for A/B testing?
If you expect to remove the redirect after the test, a 302 can temporarily direct visitors to different versions. Using homepage A/B testing as an example, awoo explains how this can help compare user behavior. However, its claim that the original URL’s rankings and ranking weight remain unaffected after testing should not be treated as a guarantee. Google’s documentation also notes that the destination page may still be indexed because of other canonicalization signals.
Should you keep using a 302 once you know the URL move will not be reversed?
If you know the redirect will not be reversed, Google’s documentation recommends using a permanent redirect rather than continuing to represent the move as temporary. A permanent redirect signals that the destination URL should be canonical. If you want to change the URL displayed in Google search results, the documentation recommends using a permanent server-side redirect, such as a 301 or 308, whenever possible.
If the old page’s rankings change after prolonged use of a 302, can you conclude that the redirect caused it?
No. Ranking changes alone do not show that the redirect caused them. In a 2020 article, awoo warned that prolonged use of a 302 might affect the old page’s rankings. However, the content cited here provides no verifiable duration in days, observation methods, or ranking data, so it does not establish how long a 302 can remain in place before rankings drop. When interpreting the outcome, record the redirect’s duration, the URL displayed in search results, and other canonicalization signals.
References
- 重新導向與 Google 搜尋 | Google 搜尋中心 | Documentation | Google for Developersdevelopers.google.com — Discusses: Which type of redirect is appropriate for A/B testing?; Should you keep using a 302 once you know the URL move will not be reversed?
- 301/302轉址如何影響網站SEO?三大要點讓你做好網站SEOwww.awoo.ai · 2020-01-07T09:09:52+00:00 — Discusses: Which type of redirect is appropriate for A/B testing?; If the old page’s rankings change after prolonged use of a 302, can you conclude that the redirect caused it?
- Is It OK to Remove 301 Redirects After a Year? We Tested Itahrefs.com · 2023-06-09T05:10:58+00:00 — Source used in the article above.



