The absence of noindex does not guarantee that submitted URLs will be indexed. Submitting a sitemap, having search engines discover URLs, crawling pages, and indexing them are separate steps. To investigate, start by checking the URL’s current status, whether the expected content can be retrieved, and whether the content offers unique value. Without inspection results for individual URLs, however, you cannot determine why they remain unindexed.
Submission helps search engines discover content, but does not guarantee indexing
A Semrush article marked as published in 2021 states that sitemaps help search engines discover content but do not guarantee that pages will be indexed. Duplicate or low-quality pages, or those with a noindex directive, may not be indexed. Ruling out noindex therefore eliminates only one possibility; it does not mean everything else is in order.
A Webmasters Stack Exchange discussion also distinguishes crawling from indexing, suggesting that factors such as unique content and links still affect indexing. These explanations do not mean that submitted URLs are guaranteed to be crawled, or that crawling or indexing will be completed within a fixed timeframe.
Start with the URL’s status, not just how long you have waited
- “Discovered – currently not indexed”: Do not take this status alone as evidence that the search engine has rejected the content. One forum contributor reported still seeing this status about 20 days after submitting a sitemap and requesting indexing, but did not provide enough inspection results to establish the cause.
- Redirects when no cookie is set: Another case involved all pages redirecting to a consent page when no cookie was set. If a URL behaves the same way, first determine whether the content actually retrieved is the article or the consent page, rather than repeatedly submitting the sitemap.
- New pages remain unindexed: Creating another sitemap does not mean the problem has been resolved. One site owner reported that two new pages had remained unindexed for about 20 days. Even after they submitted a new sitemap, the pages were still unindexed at the time of posting.
These waiting periods reflect individual experiences, not Google’s processing deadlines. The redirect case does not imply that a site’s security must be weakened, either.
Check the content, but do not judge the cause by length alone
In the “Discovered” case mentioned above, the site owner wondered whether articles of about 800 Chinese characters were too short and whether content moved from an old site was being treated as duplicate content. These were the owner’s concerns, not established causes. They do not justify recommending the deletion of all short articles or articles moved from an old site.
Views on duplicate content also differ across discussions: some suggest that similar or thin content may affect crawling, while others point out that duplicate content can still be indexed. A more cautious approach is to check content quality and uniqueness without treating them alone as an explanation for why a page remains unindexed. Consider the URL’s actual status and redirect behavior as well, rather than taking the absence of noindex as proof that there are no technical or content issues.
Unindexed URLs without noindex: common questions from web discussions
Does Google always index new pages automatically?
There is no such guarantee. In one forum case, a site owner had heard that new pages would be indexed automatically, but two new pages remained unindexed after about 20 days. Creating and submitting another sitemap had not changed the situation by the time they posted. This experience cannot establish how long other sites should expect to wait, nor does it prove that no new pages are indexed automatically. It only refutes the claim that new pages are always indexed automatically.
Do links pointing to a page guarantee that it will be indexed?
No. A Webmasters Stack Exchange discussion lists links and unique content as factors that may affect indexing. Another discussion suggests that backlinks or site navigation may influence whether search engines can discover a page. These are areas worth checking, not rules guaranteeing indexing if more links are added. Nor does a page’s absence from the index, on its own, establish that it lacks links.
Does a site with a large social media following still need to investigate indexing issues?
Yes. In May 2024, one site owner reported that their site had been publishing news and articles for about a year and a half, yet pages remained unindexed despite a social media following of around 150,000. This is an individual experience that did not establish the reason for the indexing issue, and it cannot establish a causal relationship between follower counts and indexing. The size of a social media following is no substitute for checking URL status.
References
- Google is not indexing my posts?www.warriorforum.com — Source used in the article above.
- Google is not indexing my posts?www.warriorforum.com — Source used in the article above.
- How to Submit a Sitemap to Google (in 3 Simple Steps)www.semrush.com · 2021-06-16T21:05:00Z — Source used in the article above.
- Why did google stop indexing only my Blog pages?www.warriorforum.com — Source used in the article above.
- Adult website crawlability issuewebmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.
- How quickly does Bing index URLs submitted through Webmaster Tools?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: Do links pointing to a page guarantee that it will be indexed?
- Multiple Sitemap.xml Issuewww.warriorforum.com — Discusses: Does Google always index new pages automatically?
- Google is not indexing URLs in my XML SiteMap?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: Do links pointing to a page guarantee that it will be indexed?
- Why did google stop indexing only my Blog pages?www.warriorforum.com — Discusses: Does a site with a large social media following still need to investigate indexing issues?

