Based on the supplied material, there is not enough evidence to establish that subdomains themselves reduce website authority or that subdirectories necessarily lead to higher rankings. The material includes industry explanations about consolidating SEO equity, older articles recounting statements by a Google representative, and challenges raised in public discussions. It does not include comparative tests with methods and results that can be checked. These sources illustrate the debate, but they neither establish an authority gap between the two URL structures nor prove that the structures are equivalent in every situation.
“Both are acceptable” does not mean their authority is identical
Both awoo’s 2018 article and Welly’s 2022 article recount statements by John Mueller that Googlebot or Google’s algorithms can work with both subdomains and subdirectories. The choice can take into account ease of setup, long-term brand development, and the ability to maintain the site over time.
This supports only the conclusion that either structure can be used, not that all pages will achieve the same rankings. awoo provides a video title and timestamp, but the supplied material does not include the wording from the video. Both articles recount past statements and should not be treated as complete accounts of current official rules.
Claims about consolidating SEO equity lack details needed for verification
In a 2025 article, Olivia argues that Google sometimes treats subdomains as separate websites, so their SEO equity does not directly benefit the main site. Subdirectories, by contrast, help consolidate equity and are generally more suitable for those seeking to improve their brand website’s rankings. Welly’s 2022 article also argues that subdirectories can draw on the main site’s SEO equity, while linking a subdomain and the main site to each other is similar to adding external link channels.
These are the authors’ explanations of how the structures work, along with their recommendations. The supplied passages do not explain how authority was measured, which samples were compared, or what the tests found. These claims therefore cannot yet be treated as verified search engine rules. Three distinctions matter here:
- The benefits of adding content, pages, and links are not the same as the benefits of the URL structure itself.
- “Generally more suitable” is a conditional recommendation, not a guarantee that adopting the structure will improve rankings.
- Even when ranking changes are observed, sufficient data is still needed to attribute them to structural differences.
Public discussion highlights evidence gaps without settling the debate
One critic on Stack Exchange points out that the listed sources do not cite search engines’ explanations of trust or authority for the two structures, while acknowledging that they had not carefully checked every link. Another respondent expresses confidence that SEOmoz conducts tests and questions whether statements by Google representatives necessarily reflect how the search engine actually works. However, that passage includes no test design or data. It offers reasons for the respondent’s position, not evidence from a test.
A 2022 article on Neil Patel’s website reaches a more moderate conclusion: the difference between the structures is minimal in most cases, and content audits and mobile optimization are more worthwhile investments. However, the article also allows for different outcomes depending on content relevance and reputation.
The articles and discussions above can therefore be cited as sources of claims about authority differences. But the supplied evidence is still insufficient to establish how large those differences are or what causes them.
Authority differences between subdomains and subdirectories: perspectives from across the web
Can linking a subdomain and the main site to each other improve authority?
Links between the two alone are not enough to establish that authority or rankings will improve. In 2022, Welly suggested that connecting a subdomain with the main site is similar to adding pathways for external links. However, the supplied passage contains no comparative tests or measurements that would establish the effect of link quantity itself. This is a claim worth further investigation, not an established search engine rule.
Does how closely the content relates to the main site affect the choice of structure?
It may be a factor to consider, but the material is insufficient to quantify its effect on authority. A 2022 article on Neil Patel’s website argues that if a subdomain’s content is entirely different from the main site’s, keeping it separate may help manage reputational risk. If the content is closely related, however, concentrating both links and content on the subdomain may be disadvantageous. The article also states that the difference between the two structures is minimal in most cases; it does not demonstrate that these scenarios necessarily produce ranking differences.
When the evidence is inconclusive, what practical factors can still be compared?
You can start by comparing brand positioning, ease of setup, and long-term maintenance capabilities, without assuming that either structure necessarily has greater authority. awoo’s 2018 article also advises evaluating hosting capacity, speed, certificates, and staffing costs based on the actual configuration. For example, whether an existing certificate covers a subdomain needs to be checked individually. These are planning considerations, not evidence of ranking differences.
References
- Sitemap for site with translationswebmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.
- 子網域是什麼?子網域設定步驟教學、與子目錄優缺比較welly.tw · 2022-04-06T05:16:25.987Z — Discusses: Can linking a subdomain and the main site to each other improve authority?; When the evidence is inconclusive, what practical factors can still be compared?
- 子網域好還是子目錄好?架設部落格、新網站必備評估www.awoo.ai · 2018-09-26T07:32:44+00:00 — Discusses: When the evidence is inconclusive, what practical factors can still be compared?
- 子網域搞懂了嗎?獨家子網域設定與SEO優化術,讓你稱霸搜尋引擎!www.da-vinci.com.tw · 2025-05-05T08:37:22+08:00 — Source used in the article above.
- What is a Subdomain and How Does it Affect Your Site’s SEO?neilpatel.com · 2022-07-01T19:00:00+00:00 — Discusses: Does how closely the content relates to the main site affect the choice of structure?
- Sitemap for site with translationswebmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.
- Sitemap for site with translationswebmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.
