What are the benefits and risks of a strict content silo architecture?

ProcrustesPR

A strict content silo architecture organizes content by topic and establishes a clear hierarchy, making it easier for users and search engines to understand the content. The risk is that it prohibits links between silos even when the information is related. This may cut off readers’ paths to related content and cause the website to miss conversion opportunities. Incomplete internal linking may also leave orphan pages that are difficult to discover. The key is to distinguish between clear categorization and isolated categories: the benefits of the former do not establish that the latter is necessary.

ProcrustesPRProcrustesPRCan a One-Page Website Do SEO?

Strict silos involve more than sorting articles into categories

According to explanations published by Semrush and awoo in 2023, silo architecture groups content by topic and links pages within each category, both across levels and at the same level. The strict version prohibits links between pages in different categories, even when their topics overlap.

For example, a gardening website might have three sections: sowing, plant care, and gardening equipment. An article about summer seeds in the sowing section can link to an article about spring seeds. But pages about organic gardening and seasonal sowing in different sections cannot link to each other, even when related. awoo also draws a distinction: silos are a website architecture principle, while topic clusters and content hubs are content strategies, so these terms should not be treated as synonyms.

The benefits come from a clear hierarchy and meaningful internal links

The potential benefits listed by Semrush mainly concern content organization and site navigation:

  • Easier planning: Grouping content by topic is intuitive, making it easier to plan categories and decide where articles belong.
  • Easier page discovery: Clear internal links allow crawlers to find other pages and understand how their content is related.
  • Easier access to information: A logical hierarchy allows visitors to keep reading about the same topic.

The article also suggests that consistently providing high-quality content on a topic helps build topical authority. However, these benefits come from content quality, categorization, and linking. They do not mean that simply prohibiting links between silos will improve rankings.

At Procrustes, our services include planning pages and content topics for the websites we work on, as well as turning the questions customers genuinely care about into articles that we continue to write and update.

Category boundaries may keep readers from finding related services

Semrush offers a hypothetical example: a visitor arrives through an article about keyword optimization but also needs competitor research services. If silo restrictions prevent the page from providing a relevant link, the visitor may not realize that the website can meet that additional need and may return to the search results or turn to a competitor. This example shows how potential customers might be lost; it does not provide a measured loss rate.

The same article notes that some experts consider siloed content overly contrived and unnatural. This is not a consensus view, but it highlights a trade-off in strict siloing: orderly categories do not necessarily meet readers’ need to explore across topics.

Orphan pages are a risk of incomplete linking, not an inevitable outcome

Orphan pages are pages with no incoming links from other pages on the same website. Semrush cautions that these pages are harder for users to find, and crawlers may struggle to understand their context, potentially harming search performance and traffic. However, strict silos still include links within each category, so prohibiting cross-silo links does not necessarily create orphan pages. The practical check is whether every page can be found through a link from another page on the site.

ProcrustesPRProcrustesPRHow to Use a Marketing Funnel: Fill Page Gaps at Each Stage, Then Build a Conversion Path

Strict content silo architecture: perspectives from across the web

How do content silos differ from topic clusters and content hubs?

In its 2023 article, awoo distinguished silos as a website architecture principle that organizes pages into categories and hierarchical levels. Topic clusters and content hubs, by contrast, are content strategies, so these terms should not be treated as synonyms. According to the article, topic clusters can link to pages outside the cluster when doing so helps meet users’ needs on the site, whereas strict silos prohibit links between categories. Choosing topic clusters therefore does not necessarily mean adopting strict siloing.

How do the risks of organizing content by format differ from those of building topic-based silos?

Separating videos, stories, or publications into different sections is not the same as grouping content by topic. Nielsen Norman Group noted in 2014 that when a topic is scattered across multiple format-based sections, users who want to learn about it in different ways may have to enter each section and repeatedly drill down to find information. This observation concerns the burden of finding information in format-based sections; it does not directly establish that all topic-based silos cause the same problem.

Is strict siloing alone enough to build topical authority?

Siloing alone is not enough. In 2023, Semrush suggested that organizing content by topic can help clarify relationships between pages, but building topical authority also involves consistently providing high-quality content. The article also recommended that content demonstrate experience, expertise, authoritativeness, and trustworthiness. These are the source’s recommendations for content quality, not a claim that prohibiting cross-silo links alone builds authority, nor a guarantee of rankings.

ProcrustesPRWhat types of URLs are there, and what are they used for?

References

  1. Avoid Format-Based Primary Navigationwww.nngroup.com · 2014-06-08T16:00:00+0000 — Discusses: How do the risks of organizing content by format differ from those of building topic-based silos?
  2. What Is Silo SEO and Is There a Better Option?www.semrush.com · 2023-09-27T11:14:00Z — Discusses: Is strict siloing alone enough to build topical authority?
  3. 10 分鐘理解主題集群 Topic Cluster:SEO 經營策略的另一種視角www.awoo.ai · 2023-08-21T10:42:03+00:00 — Discusses: How do content silos differ from topic clusters and content hubs?

Related articles

Can a One-Page Website Do SEO?How to Use a Marketing Funnel: Fill Page Gaps at Each Stage, Then Build a Conversion PathWhat types of URLs are there, and what are they used for?When should you use relative or absolute paths in WordPress?What are www subdomains and relative links used for?How to Create an HTML Sitemap: From Organizing Content to Publishing and UpdatingHow to troubleshoot and fix 404 errors: identify broken URLs first, then address the causeHow to improve on-site content and structure: audit pages first, then address content gaps and internal links
ProcrustesPR
ProcrustesPR