Possibly, but it depends on what is wrong with the sitemap. According to the Semrush article, a sitemap containing broken URLs, redirecting pages, or pages marked noindex may negatively affect SEO. These URLs direct search engines to crawl content that should not be prioritized or cannot be indexed. What matters is which URLs the sitemap includes. An error alone does not mean the site has been penalized or that rankings will definitely drop.
Broken URLs: Content Is No Longer Accessible
Keeping broken URLs in a sitemap may direct search engines to crawl content that is no longer accessible. When checking a sitemap, do not just confirm that the file exists; verify that its URLs are still valid.
These errors may direct search engines to unsuitable URLs, but Semrush does not specify how many broken URLs would affect rankings or quantify the potential harm. You cannot estimate how much traffic a site will lose simply because its sitemap contains broken URLs.
Redirecting Pages: The Issue Is Their Inclusion in the Sitemap
Semrush also notes that including redirecting pages in a sitemap may negatively affect SEO. Focus on whether the sitemap still lists these URLs, rather than treating every redirect on a website as an SEO error.
- First, identify which URLs in the sitemap redirect.
- Check these separately from broken URLs rather than treating them as the same problem.
- Do not assume that the site has been demoted in search rankings simply because the sitemap includes these URLs.
Noindex Pages: Listed but Not Intended for Indexing
A sitemap containing pages marked noindex may direct search engines to crawl content that cannot be indexed. This is another risk identified by Semrush, so check whether the listed pages carry a noindex directive.
This differs from a broken URL: checking whether a page loads will not tell you whether it carries a noindex directive. Check for these issues separately, and do not remove noindex directives indiscriminately just to resolve sitemap issues.
Couldn’t Fetch: First Check Why the File Is Inaccessible
Semrush also explains that Search Console’s “Couldn’t fetch sitemap” message means Google cannot access the sitemap file. Common causes include server downtime or slow responses, an incorrect file path, and access restrictions. This is a different problem from listing inappropriate URLs within the file. Identify why the file is inaccessible rather than assuming the site has received a ranking penalty.
The above is based on a Semrush article dated June 16, 2021, not Google’s current official rules. The article recommends checking sitemaps regularly. In practice, start by distinguishing between an inaccessible file and problems with the URLs listed in it, then check each issue individually.
Sitemap errors: perspectives from across the web
How often should you check for sitemap errors?
Semrush's 2021 article recommends checking sitemaps regularly and notes that its Site Audit tool can be set up to run automatic weekly or monthly scans and send error notifications. These are scheduling options offered by the tool, not a requirement for every website to follow a fixed schedule or a guarantee that every scan will detect all problems.
References
- How to Submit a Sitemap to Google (in 3 Simple Steps)www.semrush.com · 2021-06-16T21:05:00Z — Discusses: How often should you check for sitemap errors?



