Competing for higher search rankings with similar recipes is not just about making the recipes different. It is about helping readers understand the steps and get good results, while also addressing loading speed, technical SEO, author credibility, and links from other sites. Chasing speed scores alone is not enough, and longer articles are not an advantage in themselves. The suggestions below come from relevant articles and interviews; they do not guarantee better rankings. Determining why a particular recipe ranks lower still requires the actual pages and target search queries.
When recipes are similar, make the instructions more useful first
In a 2018 interview published by Semrush, Casey Markee used banana cream pie as an example: there are only so many ways to make the same dish, but there is still room to improve how the content is presented. He suggested checking not whether an article was long enough, but whether readers could follow it to make a good dish.
- Clear instructions: Can readers understand what to do at each step without having to fill in essential details themselves?
- Photos that complement the steps: Do detailed photos help readers get it right on their first attempt, rather than merely showcase the finished dish?
- Cues for assessing credibility: Is the author credible, and does the page include genuine ratings or reviews of the recipe from other users?
These are content checks suggested in that interview, not a promise that adding photos or reviews will improve rankings. A page should not add text simply to appear more comprehensive if it does not help readers prepare the dish.
Check both speed and recipe markup
Semrush’s 2023 article notes that Google does not directly use PageSpeed Insights scores to rank websites. Speed is worth improving, but content quality, backlinks, and technical SEO should not be overlooked. A higher speed score alone therefore cannot tell you how a recipe’s ranking will change.
For the technical setup of recipe pages, the 2018 interview recommended a high-quality recipe plugin that generates JSON-LD structured data. It also recommended ensuring that cooking time, preparation time, and nutritional information are correctly marked up and clearly visible on the page. This was advice given at the time; this article has not verified current required fields or plugin compliance requirements.
The same interview also recommended checking loading performance over typical 3G and 4G connections. The interviewee’s suggested loading times should not be treated as universal benchmarks for acceptable performance today.
When comparing competitors, look beyond ingredients and word counts
Similar content does not mean that two pages compete on equal terms in search. Using AllRecipes as an example, the 2018 interview noted that large recipe sites may have built authority and trust and gained links from many other sites over time. Similar ingredients and steps are therefore not enough to conclude that two recipes should rank equally.
At the time, Markee advised recipe bloggers to build and demonstrate expertise. He suggested that this could indirectly improve their chances of success in search, rather than immediately raise their rankings. When comparing pages, examine content usefulness, technical setup, and differences in off-site factors separately. Without specified pages and queries, you cannot conclude that lower rankings are necessarily caused by speed, links, or the author’s background.
Search rankings for similar recipes: perspectives from across the web
Can small recipe blogs outrank large websites?
Yes, but website size alone cannot predict the outcome. The 2018 interview noted that small blogs had competed with and beaten large websites. However, large sites may already have accumulated authority, trust, and links from many sources. Small sites can continue to demonstrate expertise while improving their content and technical implementation, but none of these approaches guarantees a higher ranking for a particular recipe.
Does a higher PageSpeed Insights score mean a recipe will rank higher?
Not necessarily. Semrush noted in 2023 that Google does not directly use PageSpeed Insights scores to rank websites. The article described page speed as a ranking factor, and the score only partly reflects that speed. Improving loading performance is worthwhile, but content quality, backlinks, and technical SEO also matter. A higher score does not guarantee a higher ranking, and a change in the score should not be treated as the sole cause of a ranking change.
Can comparing two similar recipes directly reveal why one ranks lower?
No. Similar recipes alone do not reveal why one ranks lower. Compare how clear the instructions are, how the pages differ in links from other sites and credibility, and how well their loading speed and technical setup work. These conditions may all differ. Without the actual pages and target queries, you can only identify areas to check, not determine why a particular recipe ranks lower.
References
- Google PageSpeed Insights: What It Is & How to Boost Your Scorewww.semrush.com · 2023-07-10T09:40:00Z — Discusses: Does a higher PageSpeed Insights score mean a recipe will rank higher?; Can comparing two similar recipes directly reveal why one ranks lower?
- Advanced SEO for Food Bloggers: An Interview with Casey Markeewww.semrush.com · 2018-11-19T08:00:00Z — Discusses: Can small recipe blogs outrank large websites?; Can comparing two similar recipes directly reveal why one ranks lower?




