SEO primarily helps people find a website through search, while usability affects whether visitors can understand its content, find the information they need, and complete a desired action—a conversion. Measuring website performance means looking beyond rankings and traffic to what happens after visitors arrive: attracting visitors and serving them are two connected steps. The two can support each other, but better usability does not necessarily mean higher rankings, nor does more traffic necessarily mean more customers.
First, identify the problem: too few visitors, or visitors unable to achieve their goals?
In a 2012 article, Jakob Nielsen distinguished the main roles of SEO and usability by what happens before and after the first click: SEO attracts visitors, while usability focuses on behavior and conversions once they arrive. This framework helps explain the problem, but it does not mean the two never overlap. The same article noted that clear search result titles and descriptions affect whether users are willing to click.
Start by identifying the website’s weaker areas, then decide what to improve first, rather than always prioritizing SEO. For example, if a site already has traffic but struggles to turn visitors into customers, check whether visitors have difficulty navigating the site or understanding its content. If a site is easy to use but attracts few visitors through search, examine its search performance. This is the article’s approach to short-term trade-offs, not a formula that guarantees results.
The shared priority is making content easy to find and read
In an article dated 2023, Semrush recommended improving website speed, mobile friendliness, and usability to help visitors navigate and find content. These are useful areas to examine, but that does not mean each adjustment will improve rankings by a fixed amount.
- Make text easy to understand: Nielsen noted that keyword stuffing makes pages harder to read. Popular search terms may also be harder to understand than simpler wording, especially for users with weaker reading skills.
- Make navigation easy to scan: A footer can provide links to important topics, helping people who reach the bottom of a page without finding what they need. Too many links, however, can make it harder to identify relevant options quickly.
- Make content answer questions: Semrush’s ranking-monitoring article recommended checking whether a page covers important subtopics, answers the user’s search query, and offers sufficient depth and clear navigation.
At Procrustes, our services also combine website and content work: we plan pages, design websites, and build functionality for partner sites. We also turn the questions customers genuinely care about into articles, with ongoing writing and updates.
Measure search performance separately from what happens after visitors arrive
Start with two groups of measures so that focusing on a single number does not hide problems:
- Search performance: Track rankings for important keywords, clicks from search results, and organic traffic to see whether people are finding the website and choosing to visit.
- Results after arrival: Monitor conversion rates and, for e-commerce sites, sales. Semrush’s Shopify SEO overview also listed organic traffic and sales as relevant goals and recommended ongoing monitoring.
A decline in rankings should not automatically be attributed to usability, either. Semrush’s ranking-monitoring article recommended first checking whether the page has changed or become outdated. Then compare results that now rank higher to see whether they offer greater depth, more current information, or a better match for search intent. Those findings can help determine whether to improve the answers, content structure, or navigation.
How SEO and usability affect website performance: perspectives from across the web
Can improving usability alone raise search rankings?
There is no guarantee. Semrush’s overview explained that search algorithms consider several signals, including query wording, page relevance and usability, source expertise, location, and settings. Their relative importance varies with the nature of the query. Improving usability is worthwhile, but you cannot assume it will determine rankings on its own. Other factors, such as whether the content matches search intent, also need to be considered.
How can accessibility checks help improve a website?
Automated accessibility checks can help identify issues that may make a website difficult for people with disabilities to use. In 2024, Screaming Frog explained that SEO Spider could run checks using Deque’s open-source AXE rules. According to the documentation for that version, accessibility extraction and JavaScript rendering must be enabled for the relevant results to appear. The tool can provide a starting point, but automated checks are not a complete usability assessment.
How can you compare keyword rankings in more detail?
Compare rankings by device, location, and date rather than looking at a single ranking number. Semrush’s monitoring article also recommended watching for changes in special search result features to help identify ranking trends for important keywords. If rankings decline, you still need to examine the page and compare it with higher-ranking results. Ranking changes alone do not establish the cause.
References
- SEO FAQ: 25 Questions & Answers for Beginnerswww.semrush.com · 2020-10-22T13:20:00Z — Discusses: Can improving usability alone raise search rankings?
- SEO and Usabilitywww.nngroup.com · 2012-08-13T05:00:00+0000 — Source used in the article above.
- Screaming Frog SEO Spider Update – Version 21.0www.screamingfrog.co.uk · 2024-11-12T09:07:05+00:00 — Discusses: How can accessibility checks help improve a website?
- Ethical SEO Strategies: Driving Organic Traffic the Right Waywww.semrush.com · 2023-11-24T12:10:00Z — Source used in the article above.
- Top 19 Shopify SEO Tools to Boost Your Online Presencewww.semrush.com · 2023-10-23T11:56:00Z — Source used in the article above.
- How to Track Keywords: Tips, Examples & Checklistwww.semrush.com · 2024-04-29T18:30:00Z — Discusses: How can you compare keyword rankings in more detail?


