Can SEO Tools Identify Links That Need to Be Disavowed?

ProcrustesPR

SEO tools can flag potentially problematic links worth reviewing, but a “toxic” label alone cannot determine which links need to be disavowed. Tools are a starting point for review, not a basis for automatic action. Scores still require human judgment, taking into account where links come from and how they were created. Blindly disavowing links may not improve traffic and risks disavowing beneficial ones.

ProcrustesPRProcrustesPRHow should I divide my DIY SEO budget?

Tools flag concerns, not confirmed harm

A WarriorForum discussion notes that “toxic links” is used inconsistently: some people mean unnatural links intended to manipulate rankings, while others broadly mean spam links that algorithms may ignore. These two categories are not interchangeable, and a tool’s classification should not be treated as Google’s judgment on an individual link.

Based on personal experience, the discussion’s author believes that most links reported by tools are spam or noise, while links that could actually trigger an algorithmic drop in rankings are rarely identified. The author also believes that such harm generally requires excessive link manipulation at scale. These are personal judgments, not test results measuring tool accuracy or official rules.

Scores can help prioritize reviews, but each link still needs checking

A 2020 Semrush case study uses Toxic Score as an assessment metric, but also records referring domains, anchor text, and target URLs. It also involves manually identifying link types, such as paid and legitimate links. The point is to consider scores alongside link context, rather than disavowing a link simply because its score is high.

  • Check how the link was created: Look for paid or manipulative arrangements rather than relying solely on a tool’s warning.
  • Distinguish appearance from an actual problem: Another 2020 Semrush article states that low website quality, poor design, or unrelated content alone is not sufficient reason to disavow a link.
  • Keep no action as an option: The case study lists outreach, disavowal, and no action as possible responses. Not every reviewed link needs to be removed.

Traffic changes after disavowal do not prove it worked

In a 2024 Ahrefs article, Joshua Hardwick compares traffic over the 20 days before and the 20 days after disavowing links. One page’s organic traffic fell from 291 to 267, which the author interpreted as a possible negative effect of disavowal. Another page’s organic traffic rose from 156 to 176, but it had already been trending upward, while estimated traffic declined slightly in both periods. The author therefore concluded that disavowal had little or no effect on that page. These short-term before-and-after comparisons cannot establish causation on their own.

On this basis, the article argues against blindly disavowing links flagged by tools, but it does not suggest that links should never be disavowed. The author treats sites with an existing manual action for unnatural links or a large volume of manipulative links as different cases. These were the article’s recommendations at the time, not a substitute for current official rules.

A 2024 Semrush article also warns that mistakenly disavowing beneficial links could hurt rankings and traffic. It recommends using the disavow tool as a last resort and only when confident about which links to target. Tools can help answer “Which links should we check first?” but deciding why a link needs to be disavowed still requires specific reasons.

ProcrustesPRProcrustesPRWhy is AI not mentioning my brand?

Using SEO tools to identify links for disavowal: perspectives from across the web

If a tool does not flag a link, does that mean it is definitely safe?

No. Based on personal experience, the WarriorForum author believes that most links reported by tools are spam or noise, while links that could actually trigger an algorithmic drop in rankings are rarely identified. The author also believes that such harm generally requires excessive link manipulation at scale. These are personal judgments, not test results measuring tool accuracy or official rules.

Is there also a risk in leaving harmful links off a disavow list?

A 2024 Semrush article warns that failing to disavow links that continue to cause harm could affect a website’s authority and trust signals, potentially reducing rankings and traffic. However, mistakenly disavowing links that help rankings also carries risks. The article therefore recommends using the disavow tool only as a last resort and only when confident about which links to target.

Once a link is identified as potentially harmful, is disavowal the only option?

Not necessarily. A 2020 Semrush case study lists outreach, disavowal, and no action as options when reviewing links. Another article from the same year recommends carefully analyzing harmful links and, if necessary, trying to remove them yourself before considering disavowal. These were the approaches proposed in those articles at the time and should not be treated as current official rules.

ProcrustesPRDoes an AI brand mention bring website visitors?

References

  1. Toxic links and disavows: A comprehensive SEO guidewww.warriorforum.com — Discusses: If a tool does not flag a link, does that mean it is definitely safe?
  2. I Disavowed “Toxic Backlinks”: Here’s What Happenedahrefs.com · 2024-08-29T13:34:32+00:00 — Source used in the article above.
  3. Essential Expert Tips on Fixing and Avoiding Google Penaltieswww.semrush.com · 2020-07-17T11:20:00Z — Discusses: Once a link is identified as potentially harmful, is disavowal the only option?
  4. How to Disavow Backlinks (+ Find Out if You Really Should)www.semrush.com · 2020-07-10T11:00:00Z — Discusses: Once a link is identified as potentially harmful, is disavowal the only option?
  5. A Comprehensive Guide to Understanding Google Penaltieswww.semrush.com · 2024-02-29T11:40:00Z — Discusses: Is there also a risk in leaving harmful links off a disavow list?

Related articles

How should I divide my DIY SEO budget?Why is AI not mentioning my brand?Does an AI brand mention bring website visitors?How Long Does It Take to Evaluate SEO Results?How do I write titles customers want to click?How is organic traffic different from paid traffic?Why do I have keyword rankings but no customers?Are Google Maps rankings the same as website SEO?
ProcrustesPR
ProcrustesPR