To improve SEO, first identify whether you need technical fixes, strategy and execution, or more capacity to produce content. Then decide whether to hire an engineer, work with an SEO agency, or bring in a writer. If you have ongoing website development needs, consider hiring an engineer. If your team can do the work but needs direction, consider a consultant. If you lack the staff to do the work, compare managed SEO services. If you already have a content direction but cannot get articles written, consider a writer. As for the decline in Google Ads inquiries, the available information cannot explain its cause or establish that investing in SEO would make up for it.
Take stock of the work first—do not expect one role to cover everything
Harris’s overview of SEO services identifies four areas of expertise needed to handle SEO in-house: SEO, project management, engineering, and content. These can guide how you divide responsibilities; they are not a recommendation to hire four people. Welly’s role overview describes an SEO engineer as someone who can directly change technical settings, rather than merely offer advice.
- Technical gaps: Problems with website speed, structure, redirects, or crawler-related settings require someone who can make the necessary changes.
- Strategy gaps: Someone needs to plan keywords and content direction and analyze performance—not simply deliver a set number of articles.
- Content gaps: You already have a direction but lack the time and staff to write and maintain articles.
Hiring an engineer can fill a technical gap, but it does not mean someone will also handle content and strategy. Harris also notes that some website-building platforms generally do not require a separate engineer. Whether to hire one should depend on the changes you actually need, not simply on a decision to work on SEO.
Before outsourcing, decide whether you need advice or someone to do the work
In Harris’s breakdown of service models, consultants mainly provide strategy, guidance, and help developing workflows. The company still needs to assign staff to put the advice into practice. How quickly results emerge also depends on how the internal team carries out the work. If the company cannot find time to update the website, write articles, or publish them, consulting advice alone will not solve that staffing problem.
Managed SEO services can handle analysis, content, and optimization, but the scope varies by provider. When comparing options, clarify who is responsible for website changes, writing, publishing, and performance reporting, as well as what website access you will need to grant. Harris also cautions that some providers focus heavily on individual keywords. Check whether they offer a comprehensive strategy and whether their articles fit your brand’s tone, rather than comparing only whether they charge after reaching the first page.
At Procrustes, for example, we build a separate website as part of the engagement, without needing to modify the client’s existing official website. Our services include page planning, design, and functionality development, as well as planning content topics, writing, and updating content.
Writers add capacity; budgets need to cover the full scope of work
An article by Da Vinci recommends using external writers when no one at the company can write articles or production is too slow, with an SEO team then reviewing and optimizing the content. Writers can fill a content staffing gap, but they cannot replace website fixes or strategic analysis. PTT replies also emphasize the importance of understanding the industry and users’ needs. Treat that as a criterion for selecting content contributors, not a ranking guarantee.
When comparing budgets, consider the approach Welly proposed in a 2021 article: weigh salaries, training costs, and the skills you need against the scope of outsourced services, rather than relying on the prices quoted at the time. For example, if you already have engineering and marketing staff, consider a consultant to provide direction. If you only lack the capacity to produce articles, consider hiring a writer and arranging for someone to review their work. The key is whether the work that previously lacked staff actually gets done once you pay for help.
SEO staffing and outsourcing: perspectives from across the web
If a keyword ranking service charges only after reaching the first page, does that mean it is risk-free?
No. Payment terms need to be considered alongside the methods used, rather than judging solely by whether first-page rankings are achieved. PTT replies note that search results can vary by location, time, and user, and warn that improper manipulation of links or traffic could harm a website. The original poster mentioned a quote with fees tied to first-page rankings, but that was an example from 2017 and should not be treated as current market pricing or a guarantee of results.
Will rankings necessarily drop quickly after you stop outsourcing SEO?
There is no universal answer. The original poster reported that a provider had made this claim. A reply in another PTT thread argued that if the website’s underlying quality and value remain unchanged, ending the engagement should not necessarily cause rankings to fall. These are participants’ views, and the material is insufficient to determine what would happen to any particular website after its contract ends. When choosing a service, first clarify which activities and resources will stop when the engagement ends.
How should you assess an external content team’s understanding of your industry?
Check whether the team understands your industry and users’ needs, not just whether it can deliver drafts. One PTT participant worried that marketing agencies might not understand their clients’ industries, so clients may need to spend time helping them learn about the business early in the engagement. Another reply emphasized the value of experienced industry experts’ knowledge and the importance of writing about what users need to know. If someone in your company knows the business well, involve them in content discussions and reviews.
References
- Re: [閒聊] SEO聘工程師或委外(向seo公司購買關鍵字)www.ptt.cc — Discusses: If a keyword ranking service charges only after reaching the first page, does that mean it is risk-free?; Will rankings necessarily drop quickly after you stop outsourcing SEO?
- 如何找到好的SEO公司?SEO公司推薦、費用、服務流程介紹www.yesharris.com · 2026-09-23T15:08:38+08:00 — Discusses: Will rankings necessarily drop quickly after you stop outsourcing SEO?
- SEO 公司怎麼選?10 間公司服務+費用比較welly.tw · 2021-12-17T09:33:23.376Z — Source used in the article above.
- SEO操作之前,先問問自己這4個問題www.da-vinci.com.tw · 2023-02-05T22:10:47+08:00 — Source used in the article above.
- SEO 工程師是什麼?工作內容、必備技能與 3 大職位差異welly.tw · 2025-01-23T07:22:36.430Z — Source used in the article above.
- [閒聊] 聘請SEO工程師或外包SEOwww.ptt.cc — Discusses: If a keyword ranking service charges only after reaching the first page, does that mean it is risk-free?; Will rankings necessarily drop quickly after you stop outsourcing SEO?


