The main limitation of SEO silos arises when content groups are kept completely isolated: although the categories are clear, this may prevent PageRank from flowing to related pages in other groups. An article on Neil Patel’s website suggests two alternatives: retain topic-based categories but allow links between related content in different silos, or consider a top-down, pyramid-style site structure. The point is not to abandon categorization, but to avoid blocking links between related content simply to maintain separation.
The limitation lies in complete isolation, not topic-based categorization itself
SEO siloing is a way of organizing website content into distinct topic groups. The article, published on Neil Patel’s website in 2023, argues that this helps users understand a site and makes its content easier for search engines to understand and index. However, it also notes that completely separating these groups may be a drawback for SEO.
This criticism applies under a specific condition: when content groups are completely isolated, PageRank cannot flow through cross-group links, even if there are related pages in other groups. This should not be generalized into a claim that using silos always leads to lower rankings. Clear categorization is not a guarantee of better rankings, either. The available material provides no data on the size of the impact or the results.
Keep the categories, but link related content across groups
To avoid completely isolating content, you can adopt the compromise suggested in the article: retain topic-based groups while linking related content across different silos.
- Focus on whether the content is related. Do not rule out a link simply because the pages belong to different categories.
- For example, suppose a site has categories for “Hiking Gear” and “Route Planning.” When a gear article discusses the requirements of a particular route, consider linking to the relevant route page. This is only an illustration of the approach, not evidence of its effectiveness.
- The original article leaves open whether a structure with cross-group links still qualifies as a strict SEO silo.
A pyramid structure is another option, but the excerpt does not provide a complete design
The article reports that Google’s John Mueller and the Ahrefs team recommend switching to a top-down or pyramid-style structure. This is only the article’s account of their views, not a current official Google rule for website architecture. The available excerpt also does not specify the levels, link arrangements, or site sizes to which this approach applies.
Based on the available material, a useful starting point when choosing a site structure is to consider two questions separately: Does the site need clear topic-based categories? Do related pages need links across categories? Clear categorization does not require banning cross-category links. The article also mentions menus, navigation bars, breadcrumbs, and URL structure as ways to make site categories easier to recognize. These are design options, not a requirement for every site to change all of them or a reason to isolate content.
SEO silos: perspectives from across the web
Does a structure still count as an SEO silo after adding cross-group links?
There is no settled answer on whether this still counts as an SEO silo. Neil Patel’s article suggests linking related content in different silos to avoid complete isolation, but leaves readers to decide whether the term still applies. When discussing a structure with cross-group links, first clarify whether “SEO silo” refers specifically to a strictly isolated structure.
When choosing a pyramid structure, can you simply adopt a fixed set of levels?
You cannot use this article alone to justify adopting a fixed set of levels or link arrangements. Neil Patel’s article reports that John Mueller and the Ahrefs team recommend a top-down or pyramid structure, but the available excerpt provides neither a complete design nor an explanation of how it applies to sites of different sizes. It therefore does not establish that a site needs any particular number of levels.
References
- The Expert’s Guide to SEO Siloingneilpatel.com · 2023-10-13T19:00:00+00:00 — Discusses: Does a structure still count as an SEO silo after adding cross-group links?; When choosing a pyramid structure, can you simply adopt a fixed set of levels?

