How to plan and carry out an SEO audit: define the scope first, then turn findings into an action roadmap

ProcrustesPR

When planning an SEO audit, first clarify why it is needed and which business goals it should support, then decide which pages to examine and which data to use. Finally, turn the findings into recommendations aligned with those goals, rather than simply delivering a pile of tool reports. Routine checks, traffic declines, and website redesigns call for different scopes. When auditing for a client, it is also advisable to agree on a report delivery date upfront so the work has a clear deadline.

ProcrustesPRProcrustesPRHow should I divide my DIY SEO budget?

Identify the problem before deciding how broadly to audit

First, clarify the issue: has organic search traffic suddenly dropped, has search visibility declined for specific pages, or have conversion rates fallen? Semrush cautions that jumping straight into a comprehensive audit may produce a long list of issues that is difficult to prioritize. Even after time-consuming fixes, the metrics that actually matter may not improve.

  • Routine checks: Semrush suggests auditing the entire site for small websites with fewer than roughly 50 pages. For larger websites, the audit can initially focus on the approximately 20% of pages with the most traffic and on key conversion paths.
  • Declining metrics: Start with the affected pages and the relevant checks; there is no need to expand every audit to the entire site.
  • Migrations, redesigns, or underperforming sections: Audits for site migrations or redesigns should generally cover the entire site. If only one section is underperforming, audit that section comprehensively.

These page counts and proportions are scoping suggestions from the source, not search engine requirements. NN/g’s article on content audits also notes that the scope should fit the organization’s needs and the team’s capacity. When the audit involves user journeys, it can examine key content along those journeys rather than defining the scope solely by website directory.

Match tools to the problem, starting with crawlability and indexability

When carrying out the audit, first check whether search engines can access the pages and whether those pages can be indexed. Then investigate technical and conversion issues in greater depth according to the audit’s goals. The Backlinko author recommends using tools for the following purposes:

  • Search Console: Identify crawling and indexing issues.
  • Screaming Frog: Check for technical issues such as missing canonical tags and JavaScript problems.
  • GA4: Review which pages have generated conversions, provided conversion tracking has been configured.
  • Semrush: Find maintenance issues such as orphan pages, broken links, and redirect chains.

These are the author’s tool recommendations, not a requirement to use every tool for every audit.

Use business goals to decide which issues are worth addressing

The report should explain the goals and strategy before detailing specific actions. For example, if a B2B SaaS company wants more product demo bookings and free-plan sign-ups, the audit could focus on keyword opportunities for commercial pages, conversion improvements, and content topics that can generate leads. These are suggested directions, not guarantees of results. Nor should every technical warning receive equal priority.

Turn findings into recommendations that can be implemented and tracked

Content inventories and audit findings can be organized in spreadsheets, with fixes recorded and kept up to date in a tracking sheet. When presenting to a client, start with the goals, then show the relevant findings, specific recommendations, and expected outcomes. If you have access to the data, you can include screenshots from GA4 and Search Console as supporting evidence. The Backlinko author also recommends agreeing on the report delivery date at the end of the strategy call or in a follow-up email. This is advice on working with clients, not a technical SEO rule.

ProcrustesPRProcrustesPRWhy is AI not mentioning my brand?

SEO audits: perspectives from across the web

What should you check when auditing a user journey?

If the audit covers multiple touchpoints, you can examine the key content needed at each stage of the user journey to identify information gaps or underperforming content that could harm the overall experience. NN/g’s advice was originally about content inventories and content audits. Whether to adopt this cross-touchpoint scope should still depend on the organization’s needs and the team’s capacity; it should not be treated as a standard requirement for every SEO audit.

Should an audit report enable clients to implement the recommendations themselves?

The Backlinko author recommends giving clients a roadmap with specific actions they can implement themselves, rather than using the report merely to sell services. The author believes companies without an in-house marketing team may still want to outsource implementation. However, this is the author’s practical judgment, not a guarantee that providing comprehensive recommendations will win the work; clients may also choose to handle it themselves.

If a site has robots.txt or llms.txt, do other AI-related aspects of its architecture still need checking?

Yes. The Search Engine Journal author argues that detailed robots.txt directives or an llms.txt file cannot replace improvements to other AI-related aspects of a website’s architecture, nor do they guarantee results. In 2026, the author used Expedia as an example: although the site had published an llms.txt file, that audit still identified issues such as missing JSON-LD and sitemap declarations. This is an observation from a single case and is not enough to infer that all websites will see the same results.

ProcrustesPRDoes an AI brand mention bring website visitors?

References

  1. How to Sell SEO Services in 5 Steps + Expert Tips & Templatesbacklinko.com · 2025-01-31T09:47:58-05:00 — Discusses: Should an audit report enable clients to implement the recommendations themselves?
  2. Content Inventory and Auditing 101www.nngroup.com · 2020-09-27T16:00:00+0000 — Discusses: What should you check when auditing a user journey?
  3. The Technical Signals AI Search Uses That Most SEOs Still Aren’t Optimizingwww.searchenginejournal.com · 2026-09-01T19:00:47+00:00 — Discusses: If a site has robots.txt or llms.txt, do other AI-related aspects of its architecture still need checking?
  4. How to do a website audit in 2026 (+ free tracker)www.semrush.com · 2023-12-28T11:37:00Z — Source used in the article above.

Related articles

How should I divide my DIY SEO budget?Why is AI not mentioning my brand?Does an AI brand mention bring website visitors?How Long Does It Take to Evaluate SEO Results?How do I write titles customers want to click?How is organic traffic different from paid traffic?Why do I have keyword rankings but no customers?Are Google Maps rankings the same as website SEO?
ProcrustesPR
ProcrustesPR