Semantic similarity analysis can help identify pages that cover the same topics using different wording, similar titles, and content that may stray from a website’s main topics. Combined with a content cluster map, it can also reveal internal linking opportunities worth investigating. These are only clues, however: high similarity does not mean identical intent, an outlier does not necessarily warrant deletion, and a score alone cannot prove that rankings have suffered.
Finding pages with different wording but overlapping content
Traditional text comparison focuses on whether pages contain identical text; semantic analysis uses embeddings to capture the meanings of words and the relationships between them. In its 2025 release notes for SEO Spider 22.0, Screaming Frog described using this approach to identify pages that repeatedly cover the same topics using different wording.
This overlap may cause pages to compete with one another or reduce crawling and indexing efficiency, but similarity scores alone cannot establish that these problems have occurred. When reviewing results, distinguish between:
- Overlapping body content: Read the similar pages listed by the tool to check whether they repeatedly answer the same question.
- Similar titles: This version can also generate embeddings from page titles. Those results show title similarity, not necessarily duplication of the full content.
- Different intent: Even when wording is similar, qualifiers such as location, product, or audience may give each page a distinct purpose.
Finding content that may be off-topic or lack internal links
Comparing each page’s embedding with the average embedding of the pages in the crawl can identify outliers that differ from the overall themes. Here, an outlier is simply a page whose topic differs from the content included in that analysis. It is not an overall judgment of page quality.
In Screaming Frog’s example, articles about the Olympic torch and returning to work after maternity leave, along with a login page, were identified as diverging from the website’s main focus on technical SEO. The author nevertheless explicitly stated that these pages would not be deleted. This shows that content outside a website’s main topic can still be worth keeping.
A content cluster map groups semantically similar URLs on a two-dimensional chart, making it easier to see the size of each topic cluster and the relationships between them. If a group of pages covers related content but users cannot easily navigate between them, the internal links are worth reviewing. Proximity on the map alone, however, does not prove that linking is insufficient.
Check the model and intent before interpreting scores
To interpret a similarity threshold, first check the tool and version. For example, the 2025 version mentioned above treated pages with similarity scores above 0.95 as semantically similar by default. This was the tool’s setting at the time, not a universal standard used by search engines to identify duplicate content. It does not mean the same setting is still in use.
A 2026 Search Engine Journal article cited research noting that model training, regularization, and data all affect embedding spaces. Even when scores are high, scores from different embedding spaces cannot simply be treated as equivalent.
Beyond differences between models, query intent also matters. Another article published on the site used car rental queries for Charleston and Charlestown to illustrate how similar names can still point to different commercial goals. Before merging pages, check key qualifiers such as location, product, or audience rather than simply sorting by score.
Semantic similarity analysis: perspectives from across the web
Can semantic clustering help identify content gaps?
It can provide clues for finding gaps. Grouping keywords by meaning and search intent, then comparing those groups with existing pages, can reveal topics that are not adequately covered or content worth considering for consolidation. Large language models can also expand seed keywords and simulate audience questions and purchase concerns. However, these outputs cannot replace search volume data from keyword tools; demand and intent still need to be verified.
If pages with a shared template are flagged as similar, does that mean their body content is duplicated?
Not necessarily. When shared template elements such as headers and footers account for a large proportion of a page, duplicate content checks may flag pages even if each contains a small amount of distinct body content. For location pages, for example, check whether the information about each branch genuinely differs rather than relying solely on the flag. The detection threshold described in the Semrush article is a setting for that tool, not a universal rule for all semantic analysis.
Can it assess whether content aligns with an audience’s decision-making needs?
It can help, but similarity alone is not enough to draw a conclusion. Sentence embeddings and semantic similarity let you compare brand messaging and offerings with data on what motivates audience decisions. This can help estimate how closely they align and identify gaps worth examining. The results depend on the motivation data included in the comparison, so they should serve only as a supplementary metric. Rankings, clicks, and impressions remain useful; similarity alone cannot determine whether an audience takes action.
Can you limit the scope when comparing website content?
Yes. When using vector embeddings for analysis, some tools let you define the comparison scope through URL patterns—for example, comparing only two specific sections of a website, or comparing a page with external pages. When matching pages for redirects, you can also exclude websites you do not want included to reduce irrelevant candidates. However, the most similar URL is still only a suggested match requiring review; check whether the page’s purpose is appropriate.
References
- You Can Finally Measure Content Alignment. That’s The Dangerous Partwww.searchenginejournal.com · 2026-06-04T13:30:11+00:00 — Source used in the article above.
- How to Do Keyword Research for SEOneilpatel.com · 2026-04-10T19:00:00+00:00 — Discusses: Can semantic clustering help identify content gaps?
- Multi-location SEO: How to build a scalable strategywww.semrush.com · 2026-10-07T09:39:00Z — Discusses: If pages with a shared template are flagged as similar, does that mean their body content is duplicated?
- Screaming Frog SEO Spider Update – Version 22.0www.screamingfrog.co.uk · 2025-06-10T08:45:44+00:00 — Source used in the article above.
- The Metric Most SEOs Are Still Not Measuring In The Age Of AIwww.searchenginejournal.com · 2026-08-11T19:00:19+00:00 — Discusses: Can it assess whether content aligns with an audience’s decision-making needs?
- Screaming Frog SEO Spider Update – Version 23.0www.screamingfrog.co.uk · 2025-10-20T09:49:55+00:00 — Discusses: Can you limit the scope when comparing website content?
- What Matters In An AI Prompt? Intent or Keywords?www.searchenginejournal.com · 2026-06-15T16:39:23+00:00 — Source used in the article above.

