Before hiring an agency, clarify whether you are buying organic search optimization or paid search advertising, then examine its ranking promises, methods, what its fees cover, and past work. Promises of a number-one ranking on Google, claims of special relationships, or a refusal to explain website changes are all reasons to be wary. Low prices, fixed packages, or a lack of case studies warrant further questions, but none alone proves a scam. The following focuses mainly on hiring an SEO provider; ad visibility must not be passed off as organic search rankings.
First, unpack promises of “guaranteed rankings”
Google’s official documentation clearly states that no one can guarantee a number-one ranking on Google. It also warns website owners about claims of “special relationships” and “priority submission.” If a provider guarantees a particular ranking within a specific timeframe, ask what supports that promise rather than treating it as proof of expertise.
During discussions, ask directly: “When you say the first page, do you mean an ad placement or an organic search result?” An article by Tenten also identifies passing off paid ad placements as organic rankings as a warning sign. This does not mean advertising services are inherently problematic; providers must not substitute ad results for the organic rankings they promised.
Methods may be technical, but they should still be explained
Google advises caution with companies that are secretive or unwilling to explain what they intend to do and why. Ask which pages they plan to change, why, and what official documentation supports their recommendations. If a company you hire creates deceptive or misleading content on your behalf, your website could be removed from the index; website owners remain responsible for the actions of companies they hire.
- Be wary of claims that a tool is endorsed by Google Search: Google says it does not evaluate or endorse third-party SEO tools, and these tools do not have access to its internal ranking data.
- If a provider promises to submit your website to thousands of search engines, Google says such practices are generally futile and do not deliver the ranking benefits claimed.
- If you are only commissioning an SEO audit, Google recommends granting read-only access to Search Console at this stage, not write access.
With low prices and packages, focus on what you are getting
Neil Patel’s website warns in an article about choosing a provider that extremely low quotes may involve cutting corners or low-quality outsourcing. That is a quality risk, not proof of a scam. When comparing quotes, confirm the scope of work, timeline, each party’s responsibilities, and who will develop and execute the strategy.
Backlinko treats preset packages as a milder warning sign. Packages offering fixed quantities of work may not address a website’s actual problems, but they can make budgets more predictable and suit people who understand SEO but lack the time to do the work. Ask: “Do you charge hourly, monthly, or by project? What does the fee include? What additional expenses are there?”
At Procrustes, for example, we provide SEO and GEO services for organic visibility, with fees based on achieving the results agreed upon for the engagement. This does not mean we guarantee rankings or orders.
Probe case studies rather than relying on ranking screenshots
Google recommends requesting examples of past work and success stories. Ask the client references an agency provides whether the service was effective, the working relationship went smoothly, and the work produced positive business results. Also ask prospective agencies about their industry experience, expected results, the time required, and how results will be evaluated.
A lack of case studies warrants further scrutiny. Even when an agency can provide them, you still need to confirm whether its experience applies to your business.
Choosing an SEO or search marketing agency: perspectives from across the web
How should you assess a provider that emphasizes large numbers of backlinks?
Do not focus only on link counts. Ask how the links are acquired, which websites they come from, and whether the strategy follows search engine guidelines. Neil Patel's website warns that excessive low-quality link building may deliver only short-lived results and could lead to penalties; Google advises avoiding services that claim to use link schemes. The point is to examine the specific practices, not to treat all backlinks as a problem.
Does a case study showing substantial traffic growth prove that the service works?
Not necessarily. Traffic figures alone do not show whether the service attracted visitors or generated conversions aligned with business goals. Ask the provider to explain the case study's goals, measurement methods, and results beyond traffic, then assess whether they match your needs. A forum contributor gave an example of a website whose traffic had surged but that was not monetized at the time. This is a reminder not to make decisions based solely on eye-catching growth figures, not proof that all high-traffic case studies are fabricated.
What are the risks if most traffic comes from the provider's own network of websites?
The main risk is that your traffic may depend on the provider and could disappear if you stop paying. Ask whether the work improves your website or primarily directs traffic through pages the provider controls. A 2004 article in Search Engine Journal warned that the latter approach might bring traffic, but that traffic could disappear when payments stop. This does not mean all traffic generated through other websites is a scam. Before deciding, ask the provider to show the actual work involved and example pages.
References
- 您需要 SEO 嗎?雇用 SEO 專家的訣竅 | Google 搜尋中心 | Documentation | Google for Developersdevelopers.google.com — Discusses: How should you assess a provider that emphasizes large numbers of backlinks?; Does a case study showing substantial traffic growth prove that the service works?
- How to Choose an SEO Agencyneilpatel.com · 2024-05-13T19:00:00+00:00 — Discusses: How should you assess a provider that emphasizes large numbers of backlinks?
- SEO Consultants Guide: When to Hire and What to Expectbacklinko.com · 2024-06-28T10:09:12-05:00 — Source used in the article above.
- 組建SEO團隊 VS 雇用SEO公司:您該考慮的利與弊tenten.co · 2023-07-28T23:54:22.000Z — Source used in the article above.
- How SEO Agencies Fool You with Website Traffic Numberswww.warriorforum.com — Discusses: Does a case study showing substantial traffic growth prove that the service works?
- Hiring a Search Engine Marketerwww.searchenginejournal.com · 2004-06-28T12:26:39+00:00 — Discusses: What are the risks if most traffic comes from the provider's own network of websites?


