The original signals may remain with the redirect’s destination page, but “removing a redirect after a year will not cause signal loss” is not a proven general rule. In a small-scale test published in 2023, Ahrefs author Patrick Stox did not observe a widespread, substantial drop in traffic to the destination articles after removing redirects. However, he remained cautious about his conclusions, saying more testing was needed. These results support the possibility that signals persist, but they cannot guarantee outcomes for individual URLs or be treated as a current Google rule.
“Permanent consolidation after a year” is a historical statement, and the starting point matters
According to the article, Google’s Gary Illyes stated in 2021 that redirect signals would be permanently consolidated at the new location after a year. That year starts when Google crawls the redirect, not when the website implements it.
By that reasoning, even if the redirect is later removed and the original page restored, signals from old links would remain with the former destination page. The original page would have to build up signals again. However, this is the article’s theoretical interpretation of a historical statement, not a verified result from restoring an original page.
The article also describes another common understanding in SEO: removing a redirect causes signals to be lost, while restoring the original page allows signals to accumulate there again. That differs from the idea that signals remain with the destination page; these are two distinct interpretations.
A test involving four articles does not prove that all signals remained
On January 30, 2023, Stox removed redirects from old pages to four articles covering content syndication, structured data, keyword search volume, and HTTPS. The old pages covered the same topics as the destination articles. In the author’s judgment, they had enough links and referring domains to observe the effects of removing the redirects.
- After the redirects were removed, the number of referring domains for the articles declined substantially.
- Traffic did not fall across the board: one article gained traffic, one lost traffic, and two remained relatively stable.
- The article that lost traffic covered keyword search volume. A sharp drop had already occurred on January 24, before the redirects were removed.
The sharp drop on January 24 therefore cannot be attributed to removing the redirects. However, the article’s traffic still declined during the test, and the author did not rule out a negative effect from their removal. Fewer referring domains alongside largely stable traffic is an observation, not direct proof that all signals were permanently retained.
Clarify URL roles and timing before assessing an individual case
To determine whether this discussion applies to a particular website, clarify at least the following:
- Original URL and destination URL: Are you asking whether the destination page can retain signals, or whether the restored original page can recover them? These are different questions.
- Redirect duration: Is there evidence that a full year has passed since Google crawled the redirect, rather than just since the website implemented it?
- Status after removal: Has the original page been restored? Theoretical reasoning about restoring an original page cannot be applied directly to other situations.
In particular, old links still pointing to the original URL do not mean that restoring the original page will necessarily recover its former value. The discussion and preliminary testing so far are not enough to guarantee outcomes for individual URLs.
Signal retention after redirect removal: perspectives from across the web
If you buy a domain that previously redirected elsewhere, can you still expect value from its old links?
Old links to a domain do not guarantee that you will gain their value by buying it. The Ahrefs author notes that if a domain redirected elsewhere for more than a year and its link value was permanently transferred to another domain, buying it to build a website or redirect it again could be far less valuable. However, permanent signal consolidation remains a hypothesis, and the available information is not enough to determine a particular domain’s value. Start by checking where it previously redirected and for how long.
Why is it worth checking the redirect history of a 404 page with external links?
Checking a page’s redirect history can help you assess whether it needs to be redirected again. The Ahrefs author says that, if signals are permanently consolidated, you may need to distinguish between 404 pages with external links that previously redirected for more than a year and those that did not. The amount of work needed to handle these pages might also be reduced. However, these are possible implications of the hypothesis, not proof that a particular 404 page’s signals have been permanently transferred elsewhere.
References
- Is It OK to Remove 301 Redirects After a Year? We Tested Itahrefs.com · 2023-06-09T05:10:58+00:00 — Discusses: If you buy a domain that previously redirected elsewhere, can you still expect value from its old links?; Why is it worth checking the redirect history of a 404 page with external links?



