Redirects influence which URL Google considers representative of the content, but they do not guarantee that search results will always display the destination URL. According to Google’s documentation, permanent redirects signal that the destination should become the canonical URL; temporary redirects do not provide this signal on their own. However, the destination of a temporary redirect may still be indexed based on other canonicalization signals. When interpreting the results, distinguish between redirect type, canonical URL selection, and search result display: even if the new URL has been indexed, the old URL may still appear as an alternative name.
Permanent and temporary redirects express different URL preferences
Google tracks the redirect’s source and destination URLs and considers signals such as whether the redirect is permanent or temporary when selecting a canonical URL. So even when visitors reach the new page, search results will not necessarily switch to the new URL.
- Permanent redirects: 301 and 308 indicate that a page has permanently moved to a new location, signaling that the destination should become the canonical URL. These redirects are appropriate for moves that you are certain will not be reversed.
- Temporary redirects: 302, 303, and 307 are temporary redirects. Googlebot will still follow them, but will not select the destination as canonical on that basis alone; the destination may still be indexed if other canonicalization signals are present.
For example, retiring old URLs and permanently moving to corresponding new pages during a website merger expresses a different intent from temporarily sending visitors elsewhere. These should not be treated as equivalent configurations simply because both redirect visitors.
Make redirects and other canonicalization signals point to the same URL
Canonicalization is the process of selecting the most representative version among duplicate or highly similar pages. In addition to redirects, Google considers whether a URL uses HTTP or HTTPS, canonical annotations, and the URLs provided in a sitemap.
Google’s canonicalization documentation lists redirects and canonical annotations as strong signals, while sitemap inclusion is a weaker signal. However, the distinction between permanent and temporary redirects still matters. Making these settings consistently point to the preferred URL can increase its chances of appearing in search results, but a preference is a hint, not a command.
For example, if the same homepage is accessible through multiple URLs, you can first choose a preferred HTTPS URL, redirect the other URLs to it, and ensure that canonical annotations and the sitemap point to that same URL. This aligns the signals; it does not guarantee that Google will choose that URL.
An old URL appearing in search results does not necessarily mean the redirect failed
Google’s documentation states that, after a redirect, the URL not selected as canonical can become an “alternative name” for the canonical URL. If a query suggests that the user trusts the old URL more, search results may occasionally display it even if the new URL has been indexed. This can be normal after a domain change and usually requires no action.
However, if a URL points to an entirely unexpected destination, check whether the CMS or a plugin has set an incorrect canonical annotation or is issuing an incorrect 3xx redirect. Google also notes that cross-domain redirects or canonical annotations may be inserted after a site is hacked. These are only potential causes to investigate; a single unusual search result is not enough to conclude that the site has been hacked or that the migration has failed.
Redirects and canonical URLs: perspectives from across the web
How can you check which canonical URL Google has selected?
Enter the URL you want to check in Google Search Console's URL Inspection tool, then compare the "Google-selected canonical" with the "User-declared canonical." If they differ, check whether signals such as canonical annotations and redirects consistently point to the intended version. This can help identify conflicting settings, but declaring a preference does not mean Google will necessarily follow it.
Is it okay for a redirect destination to redirect again or declare a different canonical URL?
It is better to redirect directly to the intended canonical URL. Avoid a destination whose canonical annotation points elsewhere or that issues another 301 redirect. Redirecting again can create a redirect chain, requiring browsers and search systems to make multiple requests; if the chain forms a loop, the destination may be unreachable. When making changes, also confirm that the sitemap contains the URLs you want displayed in search results.
Are redirects appropriate when you need to keep two similar pages?
If both versions need to remain accessible to users, you should not redirect one away solely for canonicalization; consider using a canonical annotation to express a preference among duplicate or similar pages. If the old URL has been retired and there is no need to retain an alternative page, a redirect is appropriate for sending visitors and search systems to the destination page. A canonical annotation is only a signal, not a binding instruction for search results.
References
- 修正標準化問題 | Google 搜尋中心 | Documentation | Google for Developersdevelopers.google.com — Source used in the article above.
- 重新導向與 Google 搜尋 | Google 搜尋中心 | Documentation | Google for Developersdevelopers.google.com — Source used in the article above.
- 如何使用 rel="canonical" 和其他方法指定標準網址 | Google 搜尋中心 | Documentation | Google for Developersdevelopers.google.com — Source used in the article above.
- 什麼是網址標準化 | Google 搜尋中心 | Documentation | Google for Developersdevelopers.google.com — Discusses: How can you check which canonical URL Google has selected?; Are redirects appropriate when you need to keep two similar pages?
- Canonical URLs: SEO Best Practices, Common Issues, and How to Fix Themwww.semrush.com · 2020-05-15T17:19:00Z — Discusses: How can you check which canonical URL Google has selected?; Are redirects appropriate when you need to keep two similar pages?
- 301 Redirects: How to Use Them & How They Affect SEOwww.semrush.com · 2020-05-08T15:32:00Z — Discusses: Is it okay for a redirect destination to redirect again or declare a different canonical URL?

