If xyz.com links to abc.com and abc.com links back, that alone is not enough to conclude that the links harm SEO. Historical research shows that reciprocal links are fairly common among websites already receiving search traffic, but this does not guarantee safety or better rankings. The key considerations are whether the links are useful to readers and whether the exchange was arranged to manipulate rankings, not simply whether there is a link back.
How common are they? More than 70% of domains in the research sample had reciprocal links
A study published by Ahrefs in 2019 analyzed 140,592 domains. To qualify, domains had to receive at least 10,000 monthly visits from Google, according to Ahrefs estimates. Counting only dofollow links, the study compared the domains linking to each website with the domains that website linked to. It found that 73.6% of the domains studied had reciprocal links, while 26.4% did not.
A separate analysis used roughly 10,000 non-branded queries with keyword difficulty scores of 40–60. Of the 112,440 pages studied that ranked in the top 10 for these queries, 43.7% had reciprocal links. This comparison matched domains linking to a given page against domains linked to by that page’s website; it did not necessarily mean that two pages linked directly to each other.
These figures describe specific samples at the time, not the prevalence across the web today. Nor do they mean that 70% of websites had arranged link exchanges.
Good rankings alongside reciprocal links do not prove that exchanges work
Ahrefs explicitly notes that observing high-ranking pages cannot establish causation: reciprocal links may have helped early on, or the sites may have ranked because of other factors despite having reciprocal links.
The study also has survivorship bias: because it included only domains already receiving search traffic, sites that may have been penalized were likely excluded from the outset. It therefore cannot prove that reciprocal links are completely safe or quantify how much a link exchange might improve rankings.
Public discussions also differ on their benefits. One contributor on Webmasters Stack Exchange suggests that reciprocal links may bring visitors, who might later link to the site themselves. Another considers their SEO value limited and advises against expecting ranking changes. These are contributors’ judgments, not conclusions from controlled experiments.
Assess natural references and deliberate exchanges separately
In a 2024 article, Semrush gives an example of two articles linking to each other: one on choosing lipstick shades and another on date outfits. The example illustrates how relevant links that help both audiences may be beneficial. The same article describes reciprocal links arranged to manipulate rankings as a link scheme that violates Google’s spam policies and warns of possible penalties.
- Start with the purpose: Are you linking to the other site to provide information readers need, or just to obtain a link back?
- Then consider the arrangement: Linking because you each value the other’s content is not the same as making “I’ll link to you only if you link to me” a condition of working together.
- Do not assume a safe ratio: The reciprocal-link ratios in the study are observations, not thresholds below which link exchanges are safe.
Reciprocal links: perspectives from across the web
Is exchanging links with relevant websites worth trying?
Contributors to public discussions disagree on whether it is worth trying. One suggests that reciprocal links with carefully chosen, reputable sites offering complementary content may be useful. Another sees limited potential benefits and a greater risk of loss, recommending linking to other sites only when appropriate. Even when the topics are related, avoid arranging reciprocal links to manipulate rankings, and do not join general-purpose link farms.
Is exchanging sitewide links with others in the same industry a viable approach?
The Ahrefs author advises against this and considers sitewide link exchanges unlikely to work, but also clarifies that this assessment was not tested by his study. Instead, he recommends proactively linking to relevant resources in your field, giving other site owners a chance to notice your website. This might indirectly lead to links later, but there is no guarantee that they will link back.
How should you review links if you have already exchanged them extensively?
If you have exchanged links at scale or used exchanges as a systematic SEO tactic, Semrush recommends reviewing those links carefully. For links that exist solely to manipulate rankings, consider removing them or adding appropriate attributes to reduce risk. In particular, check whether the links reflect genuine partnerships or are useful to readers, rather than merely calculating the proportion of reciprocal links.
References
- Would google consider this a "link scheme"?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.
- Reciprocal Links: Will They Hurt Your SEO? (A Study by Ahrefs)ahrefs.com · 2019-01-29T16:28:34+00:00 — Discusses: Is exchanging sitewide links with others in the same industry a viable approach?
- Toxic Backlinks: What They Are & How to Find Themwww.semrush.com · 2020-04-24T19:24:00Z — Discusses: How should you review links if you have already exchanged them extensively?
- Links Pages - Useful or Harmful?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: Is exchanging links with relevant websites worth trying?
- What Are Reciprocal Links? Are They Good or Bad for SEO?www.semrush.com · 2024-04-30T08:14:00Z — Discusses: Is exchanging links with relevant websites worth trying?
- Is link trading a recommended method of SEO?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: Is exchanging links with relevant websites worth trying?
- Would google consider this a "link scheme"?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.



