Could a ranking drop be related to Google penalties, and how should you investigate and address it?

ProcrustesPR

A ranking drop may be related to a Google manual action, but a decline in rankings or traffic alone does not establish that a site has been penalized. First, check the Manual Actions report in Search Console, then examine the indexing and technical status of the affected pages. If there is no manual action notice, you still need to analyze content, competition, and search demand rather than immediately conclude that an algorithm is responsible. If a manual action is confirmed, address the issues identified instead of automatically removing backlinks.

ProcrustesPRProcrustesPRDo I have to buy backlinks for SEO?

Check for manual actions first; do not substitute search results for the report

A 2024 Semrush overview explains that manual actions can affect specific pages or an entire website, and that notifications are sent through Search Console. A sudden disappearance from the rankings is a starting point for investigation, not proof of a manual action.

  • Check the Manual Actions report: Look for a notice and review the issues identified and the scope of the action.
  • Check page status: Verify whether the affected URLs are indexed and whether there are crawling obstacles, such as blocking by robots.txt.
  • Assess indexing and rankings separately: Being indexed does not guarantee the expected rankings. Semrush’s 2020 explanation also notes that a manual action can prevent indexed pages from appearing in search results.

Results from a site: search therefore cannot substitute for the Manual Actions report. Conversely, the absence of results is not enough on its own to prove a violation.

Without a manual action notice, investigate possible causes one by one

A ranking decline after an algorithm update does not mean a human reviewer has determined that a site violated Google’s policies. Experts interviewed by Semrush in 2020 noted that ranking changes can reflect either a site’s own URLs falling or competing URLs rising. Reduced relevance and queries that favor fresher content can both affect results.

A decline in organic traffic also needs to be distinguished from a ranking decline. For example, lower traffic to Christmas-related pages in January may reflect falling search demand and cannot be attributed directly to a penalty. An investigation should consider rankings, indexing, content, and link data together, rather than treating an update that occurred around the same time as a confirmed cause.

Identify the problem before making fixes, and do not treat a case study as a recovery formula

If the notice concerns unnatural links, investigate those link issues in depth. A 2025 Semrush article recommends first contacting the source websites to request removal of links confirmed to be harmful and intended to manipulate rankings, then considering disavowing links that cannot be removed. This does not mean that every ranking drop calls for submitting a large disavow list.

The site’s 2020 expert interview advises examining each link’s placement, anchor text, and the linking website’s relevance. Excessive removal may also cost a site valuable links.

The same article documents a 2018 case in which the business compiled and categorized its backlinks, kept records of its remediation work, and then submitted a reconsideration request. The manual action received in February was lifted in August. This is a historical example of how a case was handled, not a complete account of current procedures or a promise of recovery within six months. Sites without a manual action notice should not simply apply the same process.

ProcrustesPRProcrustesPRHow can I tell whether an SEO tactic breaks spam rules?

Ranking drops and Google penalties: perspectives from across the web

Are backlinks the only reason for manual actions?

No. A 2015 Semrush overview lists issues including thin content, hacked sites, spam, hidden text, misleading redirects, and keyword stuffing. A 2024 overview also notes that using structured data to manipulate or mislead search engines may lead to a manual action. Having one of these issues does not by itself mean that a site has received a manual action. Check the specific manual action notice to confirm whether the site has been affected and why.

Should you disavow backlinks just because a tool labels them toxic?

You should not decide based solely on a tool's score. In 2020, Semrush described its Toxic Score as an indicator for assessing whether a link might be harmful. The interview in the same article recommends examining each link's placement, anchor text, and the source website's relevance. Excessive removal or disavowal may also cost you high-quality links that bring traffic, so a score cannot replace case-by-case judgment.

If there is no manual action notice, does a recovery after cleaning up links prove that you found the cause?

Not necessarily. Semrush documented a client case in which a site had received no manual action notice and began showing signs of recovery about four months after the business addressed poor-quality links. The author suggested that an algorithmic filter might have been involved, but the sequence of events does not establish causation. An expert interviewed in the same article also observed that some sites saw traffic rise after core updates despite making almost no improvements. A single case therefore cannot guarantee a remedy or a recovery timeline.

ProcrustesPRWill Reposting Social Content on My Website Cause a Duplicate-Content Penalty?

References

  1. SEO FAQ: 25 Questions & Answers for Beginnerswww.semrush.com · 2020-10-22T13:20:00Z — Source used in the article above.
  2. How To Identify and Fix a Google Penaltywww.semrush.com · 2015-04-07T15:00:58Z — Discusses: Are backlinks the only reason for manual actions?
  3. Essential Expert Tips on Fixing and Avoiding Google Penaltieswww.semrush.com · 2020-07-17T11:20:00Z — Discusses: Should you disavow backlinks just because a tool labels them toxic?; If there is no manual action notice, does a recovery after cleaning up links prove that you found the cause?
  4. SEO Tasks to Boost Your Site's Performance and Usabilitywww.semrush.com · 2025-05-05T10:15:00Z — Source used in the article above.
  5. A Comprehensive Guide to Understanding Google Penaltieswww.semrush.com · 2024-02-29T11:40:00Z — Discusses: Are backlinks the only reason for manual actions?

Related articles

Do I have to buy backlinks for SEO?How can I tell whether an SEO tactic breaks spam rules?Will Reposting Social Content on My Website Cause a Duplicate-Content Penalty?Eight SEO essentials for beginners: BacklinksHow can you use multiple domains to build content and traffic while assessing the risks?How do you choose a new domain and maintain external links?Microsite or multiple landing pages? Separate branding needs from ranking expectations firstDoes Google Penalize Black-Hat SEO? First, Distinguish the Tactics and Scope of Impact
ProcrustesPR
ProcrustesPR