Why might rankings keep falling after website changes, and how should you interpret the decline?

ProcrustesPR

When rankings keep falling after website changes, the sequence alone does not prove that the changes caused the decline. This public discussion raises possible explanations, including ranking fluctuations and changes coinciding with algorithm updates. One participant also notes that a lack of improvement for target keywords does not mean other keyword groups have made no progress. However, the discussion does not specify the changes or provide update dates that can be checked. It offers ways to assess the situation, but cannot confirm the cause in this case or rule out problems with the changes themselves.

ProcrustesPRProcrustesPRHow should I divide my DIY SEO budget?

Repeated declines over a month warrant investigation, but do not prove causation

JoeyJoeJoeJoestar reported that, over a month after joining a small agency, rankings for important keywords dropped immediately after every change he made. He believed those changes would benefit SEO and user experience. This is his publicly shared account, not proof that the changes caused the declines.

He also reported that, on the same website, pages he changed lost rankings, while two unchanged pages rose from the third page of search results to the top five on the first page. That difference is worth comparing, but it does not imply that leaving pages unchanged will make their rankings rise. The discussion does not explain whether the pages were otherwise comparable or provide a list of changes to examine.

The decline may be bad timing, but algorithm updates are not automatically the explanation

Conor Treacy suggested that the decline might be bad timing rather than a direct result of the changes. He recommended continuing to monitor whether rankings recovered for the sites that had been changed. Rankings rise and fall, he noted, so a decline this week does not rule out a rebound later. This is a reminder that the outlook remains uncertain, not a guarantee that waiting will bring recovery.

Colan Nielsen mentioned that several major algorithm updates had occurred shortly before the discussion and might be related to the decline. The word “might” matters. The supplied material includes no discussion date, update names, or details of their scope. His comment therefore cannot be treated as referring to an update happening now, nor can it rule out any particular change as a cause.

Look at timing, pages, and keyword groups—not just “changes followed by declines”

The discussion suggests three things to distinguish when assessing a case:

  • Timing: Separate the immediate drop after a change from the later trend. Watch whether rankings keep falling or recover, rather than treating a single observation as the final outcome.
  • Scope: List the performance of changed and unchanged pages separately. Different trends on the same site need further explanation; they are not proof that the changes were problematic.
  • Keyword groups: Examine the original target keywords separately from other keyword groups. In Conor’s experience, changes may fail to improve rankings for target keywords while improving rankings for another group.

These comparisons help clarify the problem, but cannot determine its cause on their own. Gains for other keyword groups do not necessarily offset the impact of declines for important keywords. A ranking decline alone also cannot identify which change, if any, was problematic.

ProcrustesPRProcrustesPRWhy is AI not mentioning my brand?

Ranking declines after website changes: perspectives from across the web

If rankings drop immediately after every change, can you be sure the changes caused it?

No. The person reported that this happened repeatedly over a month, and the recurring timing deserves attention. However, another participant suggested that it could simply be bad timing, since rankings naturally fluctuate. Both possibilities remain open. Without details of the changes, the material cannot establish whether any particular change caused the decline.

If unchanged pages on the same site rise in rankings, does that prove something is wrong with the changes?

No. The person reported that changed pages on one website lost rankings while two unchanged pages rose. This difference warrants further comparison, but the material does not establish whether the pages had comparable conditions or explain why the unchanged pages rose. This comparison alone therefore cannot establish that the changes were harmful or that leaving pages unchanged will improve their rankings.

When target keywords lose rankings, what else is worth monitoring?

Continue monitoring the site's subsequent performance and examine other keyword groups separately. Conor Treacy shared that, in his experience, changes may not improve rankings for the original target keywords but may improve another group. He also recommended watching whether sites that had been changed recovered. These are suggestions for what to observe, not guarantees that rankings will recover or that other keyword groups will benefit.

ProcrustesPRDoes an AI brand mention bring website visitors?

References

  1. Have you ever gone on a streak where every single change you made on a website resulted in a rankings drop?localsearchforum.com — Discusses: If rankings drop immediately after every change, can you be sure the changes caused it?; When target keywords lose rankings, what else is worth monitoring?
  2. Have you ever gone on a streak where every single change you made on a website resulted in a rankings drop?localsearchforum.com — Discusses: If rankings drop immediately after every change, can you be sure the changes caused it?; If unchanged pages on the same site rise in rankings, does that prove something is wrong with the changes?
  3. Have you ever gone on a streak where every single change you made on a website resulted in a rankings drop?localsearchforum.com — Source used in the article above.

Related articles

How should I divide my DIY SEO budget?Why is AI not mentioning my brand?Does an AI brand mention bring website visitors?How Long Does It Take to Evaluate SEO Results?How do I write titles customers want to click?How is organic traffic different from paid traffic?Why do I have keyword rankings but no customers?Are Google Maps rankings the same as website SEO?
ProcrustesPR
ProcrustesPR