The effectiveness of publishing content at scale depends not just on volume, but on how content is found and cited, and whether visibility translates into clicks and revenue. This article focuses on search: Carolyn Shelby compares strategies for adding pages around 2015 with the AI retrieval environment of 2026, noting that more pages may create more opportunities to rank without guaranteeing sustained traffic. This does not mean that publishing more is necessarily harmful, nor is it a rule that applies to all platforms.
First, distinguish between more pages and more meaningful traffic
In a June 2026 Search Engine Journal article, Carolyn Shelby looks back at how adding pages and covering more keyword variations once increased the chances of some pages ranking. Even average-quality content could attract traffic and generate revenue through display ads. This is her broad account of an earlier SEO model, not a formula for success that worked for every website.
When comparing publishing outcomes, it is therefore important to distinguish at least three measures:
- Search visibility: Whether content earns rankings, impressions, or AI citations.
- Website traffic: Whether users click through to the website after seeing the content.
- Advertising revenue: Whether the advertising revenue from that traffic can still cover the cost of producing content at scale.
In November 2025, Backlinko noted that publishing in bulk may produce a temporary increase in traffic, but that growth may not last. A short-term rise should not be treated as evidence of long-term effectiveness.
AI retrieval changes how content is used
Shelby argues that, unlike traditional search, which centers on ranking documents, AI retrieval systems break content into sections, compare meaning, and combine excerpts into answers. In her analysis, clear, precise answers that are easy to extract matter more than simply increasing the number of articles. This is her explanation of how these systems work, not a publicly established ranking rule shared by all AI systems.
For example, splitting one topic into ten articles with only slight keyword changes might once have expanded search coverage. But Shelby argues that, in an AI retrieval context, those pages may instead overlap without adding unique value. The issue is not that ten articles are too many, but whether each addresses a distinct need.
Another change happens before the click. Shelby notes that AI may answer informational queries directly, reducing users’ need to visit a website. If low-quality informational content no longer brings meaningful traffic, an ad-supported model built on producing content at scale may become economically unviable. This does not mean that every website’s revenue will decline.
Check for duplication and value, not just publishing frequency
In October 2026, Lily Ray reviewed affected websites she had worked with or studied that year. She observed common patterns, including adding large amounts of content in a short period, expanding into topics without practical experience, and using template pages that changed only city or product names. These are observations from affected cases, not proof that publishing at scale itself caused rankings to decline.
She recommends checking whether each page offers value unavailable elsewhere. For underperforming content produced at scale, substantial rewriting, trimming, consolidation, or removal may be worth considering. However, she also explicitly states that this judgment is based on years of observation. Outsiders do not know the exact timing or targets of the next Google update, so deleting articles should not be treated as a guaranteed way to restore rankings.
At Procrustes, our content work turns the questions clients genuinely care about into articles, with ongoing planning, writing, and updates.
Content publishing volume and effectiveness: perspectives from across the web
Should publishing volume increase tenfold now that AI has lowered production costs?
Faster, cheaper production is not in itself a reason to aim for ten times the output. In 2025, Backlinko cited research indicating that AI articles produced at scale rarely appeared in Google search results or AI citations. The article recommends offering foundational explanations and educational content to help readers understand a topic fully, rather than only introducing your own products. This advice concerns search and AI visibility; it does not imply that all AI content lacks value.
Is human review enough to prevent problems with AI content produced at scale?
Not necessarily. Drawing on her research and professional experience in 2026, Lily Ray notes that some affected websites said humans reviewed their AI drafts, yet Google still devalued the content. In her view, the issue extends beyond the quality of individual sentences to the site's overall publishing patterns and content quality. These cases do not prove that human review is ineffective, but they remind editors to check more than whether the writing reads smoothly.
Can publishing press releases in bulk raise similar concerns about effectiveness?
Possibly, but the considerations include media relations as well as search visibility. A 2021 Semrush article notes that distributing large numbers of press releases with little news value to obtain links may waste production and distribution resources. It may also lead media outlets to view the releases as spam, damage the company's credibility, and make journalists less willing to pay attention to future announcements. This is a warning about risks, not a claim that press releases themselves are ineffective. Publishing one may still be worth considering when there is genuine news value.
References
- AI SEO Myths, Debunked: A No-BS Guide For Marketersbacklinko.com · 2025-11-26T10:35:36-05:00 — Discusses: Should publishing volume increase tenfold now that AI has lowered production costs?
- Why Publishing More Content Is Making Your SEO Worsewww.searchenginejournal.com · 2026-06-17T10:00:05+00:00 — Source used in the article above.
- Link Building Services: Why to Be Wary & What Actually Workswww.semrush.com · 2021-07-26T18:21:00Z — Discusses: Can publishing press releases in bulk raise similar concerns about effectiveness?
- Prediction: The Next Massive Google Update Is Around The Cornerwww.searchenginejournal.com · 2026-10-07T17:30:46+00:00 — Discusses: Is human review enough to prevent problems with AI content produced at scale?


