Profile links do not always have to point to the homepage. If the goal is to introduce visitors to you and your business, the homepage is a good fit. If you are introducing specific content or a service, consider the corresponding internal page, including a commercial page. The discussions cited here do not establish that either choice will necessarily improve rankings, nor do they explain the current rules for placing links on platforms such as Firefox and Adobe. The comparison below therefore focuses on whether visitors can find the content introduced in the profile and the information they need after clicking the link, not platform rules or ranking guarantees.
The homepage introduces the business, but it need not be the first stop
On Warrior Forum, Medon favors linking to the homepage so visitors can first understand what the website does, then decide whether to visit a commercial page. XenG offers similar advice, but adds an important condition: if the commercial page already explains who you are and what you offer, visitors may not need to go through the homepage first.
- If the profile introduces the entire website or business, linking to the homepage lets visitors get to know the brand first.
- If the profile introduces a specific service and the destination page provides the necessary background, consider linking directly to that page. Do not rule it out simply because it is a commercial page.
These are participants’ recommendations about what visitors should read first, not experimental findings showing that the homepage necessarily generates more inquiries or sales.
When promoting specific content, link to the corresponding page
On Local Search Forum, Conor Treacy advocates linking to a relevant page. His examples include linking to an article about adhesive for pipe fittings when promoting that article, rather than to the homepage, and considering the corresponding city page when getting a link from a city-specific directory.
This advice concerns content promotion and local directories and should not be treated as a rule for every profile platform. It does, however, offer a practical principle for choosing a page: whatever is introduced before the link should be easy to find after clicking it. Homepages, informational articles, and commercial pages are not inherently better or worse than one another; they serve different purposes.
Do not arbitrarily rotate links to achieve a “natural ratio”
Regarding profile backlinks, Warrior Forum participant strategic seo services recommends linking to both the homepage and commercial pages, arguing that concentrating links on a single page looks unnatural. But this is the participant’s SEO advice. The discussion provides no performance data, so it does not establish a need for a fixed ratio or monthly rotation.
The discussions also offer no consensus on whether these links improve rankings: Arsath considers the effect small, while Naman1234 believes they will not improve rankings. Blakers1 also warns that profile links can easily become spammy and recommends choosing platforms relevant to the business where the brand already has a reason to be active.
Taken together, these discussions suggest choosing a page based on what the profile introduces, then checking whether it answers the questions visitors are likely to have. Neither “always link to the homepage” nor “alternate between the homepage and commercial pages” should be treated as a universal rule. The discussions also do not establish that changing link destinations improves rankings.
Profile link destinations: perspectives from across the web
Can business profiles for multiple locations all link to the same homepage?
If each location has its own business profile, Semrush recommends pointing its website link to the corresponding location page rather than sending everyone to the homepage. This helps visitors find the location they need directly; its article notes, for example, that different locations may have their own phone numbers and opening hours. This recommendation concerns business profiles for multiple locations and should not be treated as a rule for all profile platforms.
Must directory links avoid commercial pages?
There is no consensus in the public discussions that directory links must avoid commercial pages. One forum participant recommends linking to the homepage or informational content rather than commercial pages. Another advocates choosing a relevant page based on what is being promoted—for example, linking from a city-specific directory to the corresponding city page. These are recommendations about page selection, not evidence that avoiding commercial pages is necessarily more effective.
Do you need to match competitors’ ratio of homepage links to internal-page links?
You can use it as a reference, but you do not need to treat the competitor average as a target you must meet. One forum participant recommends examining several competitors’ backlink profiles to see the ratio of homepage links to internal-page links. The same participant also believes profile links will not improve rankings and warns that these links can quickly become spammy. The material provides no evidence that matching a ratio produces results.
References
- Multi-location SEO: How to build a scalable strategywww.semrush.com · 2026-10-07T09:39:00Z — Discusses: Can business profiles for multiple locations all link to the same homepage?
- Backlinks vs Content, anyone tried only one?localsearchforum.com — Discusses: Must directory links avoid commercial pages?
- Question about Profile Linkswww.warriorforum.com — Source used in the article above.
- Question about Profile Linkswww.warriorforum.com — Discusses: Must directory links avoid commercial pages?
- Question about Profile Linkswww.warriorforum.com — Source used in the article above.
- Question about Profile Linkswww.warriorforum.com — Source used in the article above.
- Question about Profile Linkswww.warriorforum.com — Source used in the article above.
- Question about Profile Linkswww.warriorforum.com — Source used in the article above.
- Question about Profile Linkswww.warriorforum.com — Discusses: Do you need to match competitors’ ratio of homepage links to internal-page links?



