Low traffic, duplicate content, or a lack of internal links alone does not tell you whether a problematic URL needs pruning. Once you identify URLs that may contribute to index bloat, redundancy, or duplication, review each one’s search performance, backlinks, and business value. Then decide whether to keep the page, restore internal links, or use a redirect, noindex, or removal. Pruning does not always mean deletion; directly removing pages that still receive organic traffic or have backlinks may sacrifice SEO value that could otherwise be preserved through a 301 redirect.
First, check whether the time period affects your assessment
Start by checking each URL’s impressions, clicks, and rankings across different queries. In a 2021 Screaming Frog article, the author expressed a preference for reviewing at least 12 months of data to account for seasonality. This is the author’s preference, not a minimum period required by search engines. It does not mean you cannot assess a page with less than a year’s data.
- Check whether the URL still receives impressions and clicks for specific queries.
- Review organic keywords and estimated organic traffic, remembering that the traffic figures are only estimates.
- Consider conversions, user behavior, and engagement rather than comparing traffic levels alone.
Also review data for all users, not just those arriving through organic search, to avoid marking content for removal when it still delivers business value.
Backlinks are worth protecting; a low Link Score is only a clue
Semrush’s 2024 article explicitly recommends against pruning underperforming pages with many backlinks because doing so could harm the site’s overall SEO performance. If you decide to keep pages with fewer backlinks, you can also consider building links to them.
Screaming Frog’s 2021 article cautions that directly removing URLs that still receive traffic or have backlinks may produce different results from using 301 redirects. The two sources differ in how they recommend handling these pages, but neither should be read as saying that pages with links can safely be deleted.
The Screaming Frog article also treats a low Link Score in SEO Spider as a sign that a page may have low value, and lists redirects, noindex, and removal as possible options. But the score alone should not determine whether to keep a page. You still need to assess its search performance, links, and business value together.
Orphan pages are not necessarily low-quality pages
Orphan pages are pages with no incoming internal links found during a site crawl. A lack of internal links makes a page harder to find, but does not necessarily mean its content is low quality. If a review shows that the page is still worth keeping, you can restore internal links. If it does add redundancy, you can then consider pruning it. A lack of internal links should therefore be a starting point for investigation, not a reason for deletion.
Record what you plan to do with each URL and why
Use a spreadsheet to record each URL, its relevant metrics, the issues you found, and your planned action. This helps you avoid treating different problems as if they were the same. For example, a low-traffic page with many backlinks calls for a different approach from an orphan page that lacks internal links but still has value. Rather than removing all potentially problematic URLs at once, first identify what value each page has that is worth preserving, then decide how to handle it.
Pruning problematic URLs: perspectives from across the web
Can a URL with very few recent search clicks go straight onto the pruning list?
Recent clicks alone should not determine the decision. First review the individual URL's impressions, clicks, and rankings across different queries, taking seasonality into account. The Screaming Frog author prefers reviewing at least 12 months of data, but this is an assessment preference, not a hard threshold. If search performance is weak, also review conversions, engagement, and data for all users to determine whether the page still has business value before deciding whether to prune it.
How should an underperforming page with many backlinks be handled?
It should not simply be deleted. In 2024, Semrush recommended against pruning such pages because doing so could harm the site's overall SEO performance. Screaming Frog, meanwhile, notes that directly removing URLs with traffic or backlinks may sacrifice value that could otherwise be preserved through a 301 redirect. The two sources describe their approaches differently; their advice does not establish that deletion is risk-free.
Does a very low Link Score mean an orphan page should be removed?
Not necessarily. An orphan page's lack of internal links does not mean it is low quality, and a very low Link Score is only a clue that it may have low value. Also check its backlinks, organic keywords, estimated organic traffic, and business value. If the page is worth keeping, internal links can be restored. If the assessment indicates that pruning is needed, then consider options such as a redirect, noindex, or removal.
References
- Conducting an SEO Content Audit: 6 Things You Might Be Overlookingwww.screamingfrog.co.uk · 2021-11-15T13:37:48+00:00 — Discusses: Can a URL with very few recent search clicks go straight onto the pruning list?; How should an underperforming page with many backlinks be handled?
- Content Pruning: A Step-by-Step Guide to Improving Your SEOwww.semrush.com · 2024-05-09T09:05:00Z — Discusses: How should an underperforming page with many backlinks be handled?



