What problems arise with mobile phone verification, and what are the alternatives?

ProcrustesPR

Problems with mobile phone verification go beyond an extra step at login. Users may struggle to change the number linked to an account after it becomes inactive, and customer support may be unable to help. In a forum discussion, users mentioned options such as logging in directly with an account, scanning a QR code through a messaging app, and switching to another website. However, whether these can replace SMS verification depends on the login methods each service offers; scanning a QR code does not necessarily eliminate the need for a phone. These are users’ experiences and suggestions, not rules that can be assumed to apply across platforms today.

ProcrustesPRProcrustesPRDoes my website need a speed score of 100?

Users may be unable to change the linked number after it becomes inactive

The original poster said that sometimes the number used to register an account had become inactive, but they could not change it on the website. This is different from simply finding verification inconvenient: the user needs a way to change the number linked to the account, not just to receive another verification code.

One participant suggested contacting customer support if the website did not strictly require a phone for login. The original poster then pointed out that support was a chatbot rather than a person. The discussion does not say whether the issue was eventually resolved. Contacting support is therefore not a guaranteed solution, and the discussion offers no confirmed account recovery steps.

Explanations for verification requirements may not apply to every service

One respondent suggested that when someone accesses a Chinese service from Taiwan, an overseas IP address might be classified as high-risk, triggering SMS verification. Another thought that linking a phone number was mainly about account security but might also serve promotional purposes. These are the respondents’ explanations, not criteria published by the websites involved.

SMS verification is not limited to Chinese websites. One participant recalled encountering SMS one-time password (OTP) verification when paying online with a Citi credit card at the time. However, payment verification and ordinary website login are different contexts, so this example does not mean that all services require the same process.

Alternatives depend on what the service offers and whether they still require a phone

  • Logging in directly with an account: One reply noted that not all Chinese websites require login through a messaging app; many also allow users to log in directly with an account. However, the reply did not name the websites, so it is unclear whether the services the original poster encountered offer this option.
  • Scanning a QR code through a messaging app: Respondents described services where users can scan a QR code with QQ or WeChat, then confirm the login on their phone. This may remove the need to enter an SMS code, but it still requires confirmation on a phone and is not a fully phone-free solution.
  • Switching to another website: One participant suggested trying overseas websites, and the original poster also felt that foreign websites had fewer requirements. However, the discussion did not compare specific services or features. This is an option to explore, not an assurance that all overseas websites let users skip verification.

When choosing an alternative, first identify your goal: entering a verification code less often, no longer relying on the original phone number, or switching to another service. These are three different needs, and the suggestions in the discussion may not solve the same problem.

ProcrustesPRProcrustesPREight SEO essentials for beginners: Website speed

Mobile phone verification: perspectives from across the web

Is the security benefit of mobile phone verification worth the hassle?

That depends on how users weigh the extra effort against account protection. One respondent felt that although phone-based security verification was inconvenient, its benefits outweighed its drawbacks given the risk of account theft. Another suggested that linking a phone number might serve promotional purposes as well as account security. These are participants’ assessments and do not establish that verification has the same effect or purpose for every service.

If you do not want to provide a phone number, would using an identity document be more convenient?

Not necessarily. One participant said they had encountered websites that required users to upload a Chinese national ID card or a Mainland Travel Permit for Taiwan Residents before proceeding. Having neither document made those websites difficult to use, and the participant considered phone verification a better option by comparison. This is an individual experience, not evidence that all websites accept identity documents instead of phone verification, nor can the same requirements be assumed to remain in place today.

What privacy concerns arise when logging in through a messaging app?

Participants were concerned that their login or payment activity could be tracked and their data accessed, but they disagreed about the possible scope of monitoring. Some believed messaging apps could be used to trace these activities. Others questioned claims of blanket surveillance and suggested that monitoring might target only particular people when needed. The discussion does not provide enough evidence to confirm the actual scope of monitoring, so these speculations cannot be treated as established practices of the services concerned.

ProcrustesPRWhat Ten Years of SEO Taught Me About Its Real Purpose

References

  1. 為什麼大陸的網站輸入帳戶和密碼登入後,還要用手機號碼驗證1次(幾乎每次都要)www.mobile01.com — Source used in the article above.
  2. 為什麼大陸的網站輸入帳戶和密碼登入後,還要用手機號碼驗證1次(幾乎每次都要)www.mobile01.com — Discusses: Is the security benefit of mobile phone verification worth the hassle?
  3. 為什麼大陸的網站輸入帳戶和密碼登入後,還要用手機號碼驗證1次(幾乎每次都要)www.mobile01.com — Source used in the article above.
  4. 為什麼大陸的網站輸入帳戶和密碼登入後,還要用手機號碼驗證1次(幾乎每次都要)www.mobile01.com — Discusses: If you do not want to provide a phone number, would using an identity document be more convenient?
  5. 為什麼大陸的網站輸入帳戶和密碼登入後,還要用手機號碼驗證1次(幾乎每次都要)www.mobile01.com — Discusses: What privacy concerns arise when logging in through a messaging app?
  6. 為什麼大陸的網站輸入帳戶和密碼登入後,還要用手機號碼驗證1次(幾乎每次都要)www.mobile01.com — Source used in the article above.
  7. 為什麼大陸的網站輸入帳戶和密碼登入後,還要用手機號碼驗證1次(幾乎每次都要)www.mobile01.com — Source used in the article above.
  8. 為什麼大陸的網站輸入帳戶和密碼登入後,還要用手機號碼驗證1次(幾乎每次都要)www.mobile01.com — Source used in the article above.
  9. 為什麼大陸的網站輸入帳戶和密碼登入後,還要用手機號碼驗證1次(幾乎每次都要)www.mobile01.com — Discusses: What privacy concerns arise when logging in through a messaging app?
  10. 為什麼大陸的網站輸入帳戶和密碼登入後,還要用手機號碼驗證1次(幾乎每次都要)www.mobile01.com — Discusses: Is the security benefit of mobile phone verification worth the hassle?
  11. 為什麼大陸的網站輸入帳戶和密碼登入後,還要用手機號碼驗證1次(幾乎每次都要)www.mobile01.com — Source used in the article above.

Related articles

Does my website need a speed score of 100?Eight SEO essentials for beginners: Website speedWhat Ten Years of SEO Taught Me About Its Real PurposeHow Do RWD and AWD Work, and Which Should You Choose for Your Website?What are the benefits and development challenges of SPAs?How do UTF-8 and Big5 differ in their effects on search rankings and user experience?What are single-page websites best suited for, and what are their pros and cons?Keep different topics on one site or split them up? Start with audience overlap and maintenance capacity
ProcrustesPR
ProcrustesPR