The traffic drop may be related to the permalink change, but the timing alone does not establish it as the sole cause. In a public discussion, a site owner reported that traffic to a website they had run for years fell to zero within a month. The only recent change they could think of was modifying the permalinks based on Yoast’s advice. The main fix suggested in the replies was to set up a 301 redirect from each old URL to its corresponding new URL and update internal links still pointing to old URLs. However, the discussion includes no results after any fixes, so there is no guarantee that these changes will restore traffic.
First check whether old URLs redirect to new pages, not just whether they are readable
The site owner described switching from URLs such as “?p=123” to another permalink structure. MikeFriedman argued that this changed the internal linking structure and also affected external links pointing to the old pages, so he recommended setting up 301 redirects for each URL. This was a forum participant’s assessment of the case, not a verified diagnosis.
Start with two checks: do old URLs now redirect to the corresponding content, and do articles on the site still link to old URLs? Do not assume the change was handled properly simply because the new URLs are easier to read. The site owner reported that Search Console showed “URL is on Google, but has issues,” but provided no details about those issues. That message alone is not enough to pinpoint the problem.
A path toward recovery: match old and new URLs page by page and update internal links
- Map old URLs to new ones: The discussion recommended setting up a 301 redirect from each old URL to its corresponding new URL, rather than addressing only the homepage. For example, the old URL for article A should redirect to the new URL for article A.
- Check text links within articles: Another respondent noted that if the platform does not redirect automatically and pages already contain text links to other articles, those links should be updated to the new URLs.
- Using a tool still requires page-by-page checks: The discussion mentioned WordPress plugins such as Redirection as ways to set up 301 redirects, but did not verify their current features or compatibility. Using a tool does not replace checking that each old URL points to the correct new URL.
Do not assume that having no backlinks means there is no problem
Another discussion concerned a different situation: a website that was just over a month old and still under construction, whose owner said they had not yet built any backlinks. It was in this context that a respondent offered a more optimistic assessment and mentioned that temporary indexing errors might appear while Google processed the changes.
That differs from a long-established website that already ranked for keywords, so it does not justify treating a drop to zero traffic as a normal waiting period. At this stage, check redirects and internal links first, then clarify the specific issues shown in Search Console. The forum advice offers a starting point for troubleshooting, but it does not prove that these fixes will work or indicate how long traffic recovery might take.
Permalink changes and lost traffic: perspectives from across the web
Besides the permalink change, what other causes are possible?
Other possible causes mentioned in the forum replies include a recent switch to HTTPS, duplicate content, and the site blocking search engines from indexing its pages. However, these are only potential factors in search ranking problems. The discussion does not establish that this website had any of these issues or that any of them caused the traffic decline. Check them against the site’s actual changes and specific issues rather than treating possibilities as confirmed causes.
Are canonical URLs worth checking too?
Yes, but do not assume that a canonical URL issue caused traffic to fall to zero. A participant pointed out that the canonical URLs in this case were incomplete and gave an example using a relative path. This was only an observation about an individual website, and the discussion provides no results after a correction. There is therefore no guarantee that changing the canonical URLs will restore traffic.
If traffic has already hit rock bottom, should the old URL structure simply be restored?
A drop to rock bottom is not enough on its own to conclude that you should restore the old URL structure. A participant suggested this option on the condition that the site’s performance had already hit rock bottom, but it was not a proven recovery method. The same reply also mentioned starting over. The discussion neither compares the effectiveness of the two approaches nor records traffic after either was implemented, so it does not establish that restoring the old structure will necessarily work.
References
- How long for Google to rank sites/articles these days?www.warriorforum.com — Discusses: Besides the permalink change, what other causes are possible?
- Chaning permalinks on a 1 month old website. How detrimental?www.warriorforum.com — Source used in the article above.
- Chaning permalinks on a 1 month old website. How detrimental?www.warriorforum.com — Source used in the article above.
- My site disappeared from Google results...(Please help!)www.warriorforum.com — Source used in the article above.
- Chaning permalinks on a 1 month old website. How detrimental?www.warriorforum.com — Source used in the article above.
- My site disappeared from Google results...(Please help!)www.warriorforum.com — Discusses: Are canonical URLs worth checking too?; If traffic has already hit rock bottom, should the old URL structure simply be restored?
- My site disappeared from Google results...(Please help!)www.warriorforum.com — Source used in the article above.



