Yes. If citycpa.com keeps its own URL and both it and mainsite.com/city directly display the same content, this counts as “duplicate content” according to the discussions cited here. What matters is not whether the domain is called a parked domain, but whether the same content is accessible at two different URLs. Duplicate content does not necessarily mean a ranking penalty, however; these discussions differ on its SEO impact.
What matters is how the URLs serve the content
This is not simply a case of two pages covering similar topics. Here, citycpa.com keeps its URL while displaying the content of mainsite.com/city. The answer in the original discussion explicitly identifies the same content accessible at two different URLs as duplicate content.
The distinction is between two URLs each displaying the same page and an additional domain redirecting visitors to the main site. The first describes this scenario; the second is a solution suggested in the discussions. Another discussion notes that a permanent redirect can tell search engines that a URL has moved, even if the server and IP address stay the same.
First decide whether both URLs need to display the content directly
The discussions cited here suggest two main approaches. The choice depends on whether visitors need to keep reading the content on the additional domain:
- If you do not need to keep the additional URL: One discussion recommends a 301 redirect from the parked domain to the main domain to avoid serving the same content at multiple URLs. In this example, that means redirecting citycpa.com to mainsite.com/city rather than having both URLs display the same page.
- If both URLs need to keep displaying the content: Two other discussions recommend using a canonical tag to identify the preferred URL. If mainsite.com/city is the preferred version, point the canonical tag on the corresponding page to it.
The approaches work differently: a 301 redirect sends visitors to another URL, while a canonical tag identifies the preferred URL. In one discussion, the person asking the question did not want to redirect because users had different domain preferences. That was a need specific to that case, not a reason for every site to keep two domains.
Duplicate content should not be equated with a ranking penalty
One discussion argues that Google will choose the page it considers primary and filter out duplicate pages. Another states more explicitly that duplicate content does not lower rankings; instead, search results will show one of the URLs. A different discussion, however, warns that identical content may harm SEO.
These are views from public discussions, not current official rules provided with this article. The cautious conclusion is: according to these discussions, this scenario is duplicate content, and a 301 redirect or canonical tag can help address the choice of a primary URL. But this does not establish that a penalty will follow, nor does either approach guarantee that search results will show only the specified version. Before choosing an approach, confirm whether both URLs really need to display the content directly.
Parked domains and duplicate content: perspectives from across the web
Once you have decided to use a 301 redirect, where can you start with the setup?
One discussion suggests starting with .htaccess to configure a 301 redirect for the additional domain. Another recommends redirecting the parked domain to the main domain to avoid serving the same content at multiple URLs. In this scenario, make sure the redirect points to the corresponding page on the main site. These discussions do not provide ready-to-use configuration syntax or establish that the same configuration will work on every server.
What else should you consider before using an existing domain as a parked domain?
First, check whether the domain has a problematic history, such as involvement in link farms or malware distribution. One discussion suggests that if search engines associate the parked domain with the main domain, its poor reputation could affect the main domain. This is a risk raised by the commenter, not an outcome the material establishes as inevitable. It should be considered separately from the question of whether two URLs serve the same content.
References
- Shop owner wants multiple domains, what do I to tell him?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: Once you have decided to use a 301 redirect, where can you start with the setup?
- Shop owner wants multiple domains, what do I to tell him?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.
- Consolidating google results for 2 domains with the same contentwebmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.
- How do I adjust our "default" domainwebmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.
- problem showing my website correctly in search engineswebmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.
- Duplicated content in Google. Same subpage different linkwebmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.
- Can parking a domain on my primary domain have an effect on primary domain's SEO?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: Once you have decided to use a 301 redirect, where can you start with the setup?; What else should you consider before using an existing domain as a parked domain?
- Domain Masking / Cloaking?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.
- Url's with same content , but different: trailing slash and .htmlwebmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.
- "Search Friendly" domain nameswebmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.
- "Search Friendly" domain nameswebmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.
