The difference between paid and free links is not simply whether money changes hands. It also depends on whether something of value is exchanged for a link and whether the link is used to manipulate rankings. Articles on the topic indicate that buying links that pass ranking signals carries a risk of ranking losses and manual actions. That does not mean all paid links immediately lower rankings, nor is there sufficient evidence that spammy paid links can consistently improve rankings. Getting a link for free is no guarantee of quality, either. Actively buying links should not be confused with unfamiliar websites choosing to link to yours.
No cash payment does not mean nothing was exchanged
The iThome article focuses on buying and selling links that pass PageRank. Its examples include buying articles containing links, exchanging goods or services for links, and offering free products in return for links. Recipients may therefore pay nothing for a gift but still be expected to provide a link in exchange.
- Direct payment: Paying for links or buying articles containing links intended to improve rankings.
- Non-cash exchanges: Offering goods, services, or the chance to keep a trial product in return for links in an article.
- No exchange required: Getting a link for free does not, by itself, establish its ranking value. Its context and how it was obtained still matter.
Distinguishing these ways of obtaining links helps clarify what was exchanged and why. It does not mean treating all commercial partnerships as the same SEO practice.
Product loans versus gifts: the benefit received matters
In a 2014 article discussing Matt Cutts’s remarks, awoo distinguished between borrowing a camera and returning it after a trial, and receiving one as a gift. The article also compared two other examples: a film critic attending a screening for free, and a journalist demanding a laptop they could keep as a condition of covering a startup. The former falls within reasonable professional expectations; the latter is closer to payment for the coverage.
These historical examples show why asking only “Was money transferred?” is not enough to identify an exchange of value. However, they are not a current compliance checklist, nor do they mean that loans are always safe and gifts always violate the rules. The purpose of the exchange and whether a link is required still matter.
Spammy paid links: possible gains do not make the risk worthwhile
The iThome article argues that link manipulation may work in the short term but carries long-term risks. It does not establish that any particular spammy link scheme works, predict how much rankings might improve, or estimate the likelihood of a penalty. “It might work” should therefore not be taken as a recommendation to buy.
Public discussions also reflect differing views. One respondent on Webmasters Stack Exchange argues that bad links are, at worst, worthless, and that association with link farms is what causes problems. A respondent in another discussion warns that although some people sell paid links without being penalized, a penalty can have a severe impact and make recovery difficult. These are the respondents’ judgments, not an official consensus.
You therefore cannot assume that buying links is safe just because others have escaped consequences so far. Nor do spammy links from unfamiliar websites necessarily mean your website will be penalized. Taken together, these articles and discussions better support a narrower conclusion: exchanging something of value for links to manipulate rankings carries risks, and spammy paid links offer no guarantee of consistent results.
Paid and free links: perspectives from across the web
How does renting links differ from buying them outright for SEO?
Renting typically involves monthly payments, and the links may change from time to time. Rented links are still paid links, however, despite the different payment arrangement. A 2013 article noted that some experts considered rented links useful for SEO, while the author still regarded them as paid links. This reflects disagreement about their effectiveness at the time, not evidence that the practice is safe today or guaranteed to improve rankings.
Does unnatural anchor text prove that a link was purchased?
Anchor text alone is not enough to draw that conclusion. The iThome article notes that repeatedly requesting specific wording when buying links can result in many identical anchors. Site owners can check common linking text in Search Console's links report for clues worth investigating. However, repeated wording alone does not prove that a transaction occurred or establish that the website will face enforcement action.
What might paid links affect besides rankings?
Reader trust and search quality also matter. The iThome article argues that failing to disclose an exchange of value behind a link may affect readers' perceptions, and that using links to manipulate rankings may harm search quality. However, a commercial partnership does not necessarily amount to ranking manipulation. Any assessment still needs to distinguish the terms of the exchange, the purpose of the link, and what was disclosed.
References
- 3+4 個 Google 判斷付費連結 (Paid Links) 的方法ithelp.ithome.com.tw — Discusses: Does unnatural anchor text prove that a link was purchased?; What might paid links affect besides rankings?
- Search engine impact of irrelevant inbound links?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.
- SEO網站觀念:四個GOOGLE判斷付費連結的方式www.awoo.ai · 2014-04-14T08:12:55+00:00 — Source used in the article above.
- 50 Reasons Your Website Deserves to Be Penalized By Googleneilpatel.com · 2013-07-03T17:20:23+00:00 — Discusses: How does renting links differ from buying them outright for SEO?
- Risk for hosting SEO linkswebmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.



