When there are too many top-level categories to fit in a horizontal navigation bar, consider left-side vertical navigation for the desktop layout so users can see specific categories directly. Dropdown menus are another option for content-heavy websites, but the two approaches involve different trade-offs. The goal is not to cram every item into one row or reduce the number of categories to suit the layout. Instead, keep labels recognizable and assess how much space navigation takes away from content. Top-level categories can exceed the seven-to-nine range, provided the layout accommodates them appropriately.
Keep sensible categories—do not let horizontal space dictate the structure
In a 2021 article, NN/g noted that shrinking text, crowding items together, or using unnaturally short labels to fit horizontal navigation all create design problems. More importantly, avoid forcing a broad range of information into a few vague categories simply because the navigation bar cannot accommodate them.
Using the Accenture website at the time as an example, the article noted that hiding a broad range of information under a single “Services” category made specific consulting services harder to find. Users had to expand the category, scan the options beneath it, and then determine whether they had taken the wrong path. This was the article’s analysis of the design at the time, not a claim that the website still uses the same layout.
- Do not merge specific top-level categories simply to meet a target count.
- Do not make category labels awkward or unclear just to save horizontal space.
- Having more than seven to nine items does not mean the structure is wrong; plan the categories and navigation format together.
Consider left-side vertical navigation when users need to see specific options directly
For desktop websites that need many top-level categories, left-side vertical navigation can accommodate more items without grouping them under abstract umbrella categories. Labels that clearly describe what users will find make it easier to decide where to go. Showing specific categories directly also saves users from having to expand a broad category before looking for an option.
The Arbor Restaurant website shown in the NN/g article presented thirteen site-wide categories in vertical navigation. This example illustrates how a different layout can accommodate more top-level items; thirteen is neither a recommended upper limit nor a number every website should adopt. A vertical arrangement can also provide room to add categories later.
Dropdown menus and sidebars each have trade-offs—capacity is not everything
Semrush describes horizontal menus as better suited to smaller websites and recommends dropdown menus for websites with extensive content or many categories. NN/g emphasizes how vertical navigation lets users see specific categories directly. These perspectives have different emphases; they do not add up to a rule that “many categories always call for dropdown menus.”
The main drawback of vertical navigation is that it takes up more space, usually leaving less room for content than horizontal navigation does. Semrush also cautions that sidebars may obscure important content. When evaluating a layout, check both whether users can see specific categories directly and whether navigation crowds or obscures the main content. Fitting more links does not necessarily make a layout more suitable.
Navigation layouts for many top-level categories: perspectives from across the web
Should you insist on horizontal navigation to accommodate the F-shaped reading pattern?
There is no need to insist on horizontal navigation for this reason alone. NN/g explains that the F-shaped pattern describes how users’ eyes move when reading unstructured text; it cannot be applied directly to page elements such as navigation bars or headers. The choice of orientation should be based on the website’s categories and layout needs, rather than an assumption that horizontal navigation necessarily aligns with F-shaped reading.
When space is limited, can you put all desktop navigation into a hamburger menu?
You can consider it, but saving space alone is not a good reason to hide all desktop navigation. You also need to check whether users can easily find it. NN/g notes that users may forget to check navigation when it is hidden. Compared with mobile layouts, a hamburger button takes up a smaller proportion of the page on desktop and may be easier to overlook. Limited screen space sometimes requires mobile layouts to hide some or all navigation; on desktop, the decision should not rest solely on how much space the button saves.
What should you watch out for when centering text in vertical navigation?
If you want users to scan a vertical list easily, pay attention to the visual edges created by the text alignment. In an analysis of an older website design, NN/g noted that centered text created uneven edges across the items, undermining the scanning benefits of a vertical list. This was a design analysis of that particular example, not a claim that all centered text necessarily causes the same problem.
References
- Left-Side Vertical Navigation on Desktop: Scalable, Responsive, and Easy to Scanwww.nngroup.com · 2021-05-16T16:00:00+0000 — Discusses: Should you insist on horizontal navigation to accommodate the F-shaped reading pattern?; When space is limited, can you put all desktop navigation into a hamburger menu?
- What Is Website Architecture? (& How to Improve it for SEO)www.semrush.com · 2020-12-22T14:44:00Z — Source used in the article above.



