It includes both: duplicate content refers not only to duplication across pages on the same website, but also to content that is identical or similar to content on other websites. If a page copies a city description from Wikipedia, it may still count as cross-site duplication even if that description appears only once on your own site. However, “where the content is duplicated” and “whether the duplication affects rankings” are separate questions. Duplicate content does not necessarily mean a penalty.
Within-site and cross-site duplication compare different sets of pages
In an article dated 2020, Semrush includes both content copied from other websites and content repeated within your own website in its discussion of duplicate or near-duplicate content. The article covers not just entire pages, but also individual title tags.
- Within-site duplication: Compare different pages on your own website to see whether they contain identical or highly similar content.
- Cross-site duplication: Compare your pages with pages on other websites, such as Wikipedia, to see whether they contain identical or highly similar content.
Both types of duplication can occur at the same time. A passage that appears only once on your site may still appear on another website. Conversely, checking only for content copied from other sites will not tell you whether pages within your own site repeat the same content.
Having just one page per city does not rule out duplication with Wikipedia
A city-code example in a public discussion described a site where each page listed the code for just one city, and each city had only one page. The participant therefore argued that the Wikipedia city information used on each page was unique relative to the site’s other city pages. That argument only compares pages within the site: it answers “Is there duplication between different city pages?” rather than “Is the text identical to Wikipedia?”
For example, pages for City A and City B describe different cities, so their content can differ from one another. But if each copies its description directly from Wikipedia, cross-site duplication remains an issue. One page per city is simply a way of organizing pages; it does not mean their content differs from content on other websites.
Duplicate content does not necessarily mean a penalty
One comment in a public discussion claims that “duplication within a site is not penalized; only copying from other sites is penalized.” But this is a participant’s assertion, not an official search engine rule. Semrush’s older article instead says duplicate content “may harm rankings.” It explains that similar pages may make it difficult for Google to determine which page to prioritize, and that near-duplicates lack unique value.
In short, duplicate content includes both within-site and cross-site duplication, but “may affect rankings” does not mean “will definitely incur a penalty.” These articles and discussions clarify what counts as duplicate content, but do not establish how search engines would currently treat a particular website.
Duplicate content: perspectives from across the web
Can duplicate content arise when only the order of URL parameters differs?
Yes. A public discussion notes that changing the order of URL parameters may produce apparent duplicate content. The assessment should compare the content actually displayed at those URLs, rather than assume it is different merely because the URL strings differ. The discussion does not explain how search engines currently handle such URLs.
Do duplicate-content checks need to cover only entire articles?
No. Semrush's 2020 article also includes individual title tags in its discussion of duplicate content, so checks can cover individual page elements as well as whole pages. However, the article does not explain when a duplicated tag would affect rankings. It does not establish that every duplicated tag affects rankings.
Can changing a page's voting mechanism eliminate content duplication?
No. If the content itself remains identical, changing the voting mechanism will not eliminate the duplication. A participant in a public discussion further argued that duplicate content would be filtered out, making copying content not worthwhile from a search engine optimization perspective. But this is the participant's assessment; it does not mean the platform will necessarily filter out duplicate content today.
References
- Penalty issue for a duplicate page in site but original page doesn't exist anymorewebmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.
- SEO FAQ: 25 Questions & Answers for Beginnerswww.semrush.com · 2020-10-22T13:20:00Z — Discusses: Do duplicate-content checks need to cover only entire articles?
- Cloning a site and avoiding SEO problemswebmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: Can changing a page's voting mechanism eliminate content duplication?
- Is a URL with a query string better or worse for SEO then one without one?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: Can duplicate content arise when only the order of URL parameters differs?
- How to tackle this duplicate content issue?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.

