Old pages should not be deleted simply because of their age, nor should they all be redirected to the homepage. First, check whether a page still serves a purpose and whether its content needs updating. Then look for a replacement that meets the same needs. Content that still has value should be reviewed and revised first. Consider a one-to-one 301 redirect only when a corresponding replacement page exists. If a page no longer serves a purpose and has no replacement content, returning a 404 or 410 is an option. Preserving link value does not guarantee unchanged rankings, and sending visitors to just any working page is not enough.
Check the content before deleting a page because of declining traffic
In a 2019 article, Semrush recommended checking pages with declining traffic for outdated content, overlap with other pages, an unclear keyword focus, or insufficient information. These are recommendations for reviewing content, not search engine rules requiring old articles to be deleted. They do not establish that any one of these issues necessarily caused the traffic decline.
- Outdated content: First identify which information needs correcting rather than assuming the entire page is no longer useful.
- Overlapping topics or insufficient information: Check whether the page clearly answers the original question before deciding how to revise it.
- No purpose and no traffic: Only under these conditions does the article recommend considering removal. If a suitable replacement page exists, arrange a redirect.
At Procrustes, our work for partner websites includes planning content topics, writing articles, and updating content.
Redirect an old URL only when a genuine replacement page exists
An October 2026 Search Engine Journal report cited advice from Prommawin and Illyes: Use a one-to-one redirect only when a genuinely relevant replacement page exists. Examples include an updated version of the same article or a new model of the same product. What matters is not whether the two pages broadly fall into the same category, but whether the new page can genuinely replace the old one.
A 2020 Semrush article likewise stated that 301 redirects should lead to equivalent or nearly equivalent pages that meet the same needs. It also said that redirects “may” preserve search visibility and traffic. If an old tutorial has an updated version, you can consider redirecting to it. A homepage, however, is not a suitable replacement simply because it exists.
Do not send every old URL to the homepage just to avoid error pages. The article warned that irrelevant redirects may confuse users and search systems. When reviewing a redirect map, check that each destination provides the content visitors originally wanted, not just that it loads.
When there is no replacement content, let visitors know what happened
The 2026 report stated that returning a 404 or 410 is an option when no replacement page exists; there is no need to force a redirect. In a public Q&A, a participant also suggested returning a 410 for permanently discontinued products while explaining on the page that the product has been discontinued, showing potentially suitable current products, and providing access to the main navigation.
This was a discussion participant’s suggestion, not an official rule that every discontinued-product page must follow. Offering other products for visitors to choose from does not mean claiming they are all direct replacements for the original product. A page can return an error status and still give visitors clear guidance on what to do next.
Handling old pages: perspectives from across the web
Should a permanent redirect be used when a page is only temporarily under maintenance?
If a page is temporarily unavailable or undergoing maintenance, a 302 temporary redirect can be considered to keep visitors away from incomplete pages or pages under construction. A 2023 Semrush article stated that this may also preserve the original URL's rankings and link value. However, the primary purpose of a 302 is to handle temporary situations. Those effects should not be treated as guaranteed, and a 302 is not suitable for permanent changes to a site's URL structure.
When should redirects be set up when moving pages?
If a suitable corresponding page has been confirmed, a 301 redirect can be set up before moving or removing the content so that visitors using old links reach a valid destination rather than encountering an error first. Semrush's recommendations also include testing links before publication. After setup, each destination should still be checked for correctness, rather than merely confirming that the URL loads.
Can JavaScript redirects replace server-side redirects?
For search engine optimization, relying on JavaScript redirects instead of server-side redirects is generally not recommended. A 2021 Semrush article cautioned that search engines may find JavaScript-dependent websites harder to crawl and index. JavaScript can still send users to another URL, such as a confirmation page after a form submission or a fallback destination for a deleted page. Whether to use it depends on the page's purpose.
Can a broader page on a similar topic serve as a replacement?
A similar topic alone is not enough to establish that it can. A 2020 Semrush article gave the example of redirecting a page about a specific service to a broader service information page, but also required the destination to be equivalent or nearly equivalent and capable of meeting the same needs. The 2026 report, meanwhile, emphasized the need for a genuine, directly relevant replacement page. If the broader page cannot take the original content's place, a redirect should not be forced.
References
- JavaScript Redirect: How to Redirect to a New URLwww.semrush.com · 2021-10-14T17:25:00Z — Discusses: Can JavaScript redirects replace server-side redirects?
- Google Recommends Using Custom 404 Error Pageswww.searchenginejournal.com · 2026-10-29T11:07:37+00:00 — Discusses: Can a broader page on a similar topic serve as a replacement?
- 301 Redirects: How to Use Them & How They Affect SEOwww.semrush.com · 2020-05-08T15:32:00Z — Discusses: Can a broader page on a similar topic serve as a replacement?
- Broken Links: Common Causes and How to Fix Themwww.semrush.com · 2021-06-07T21:58:00Z — Discusses: When should redirects be set up when moving pages?
- A Complete SEO Audit Template + How to Use Itwww.semrush.com · 2019-08-29T07:00:00Z — Source used in the article above.
- How to deal with obselete product pages on an e-commerce site?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.
- What’s a 302 Redirect? And When Should You (Actually) Use It?www.semrush.com · 2023-07-17T09:16:00Z — Discusses: Should a permanent redirect be used when a page is only temporarily under maintenance?




