Preserving old web pages and URLs helps people continue to find useful information and keeps external links and bookmarks from breaking. Consider the content and the URL separately: if the content is still useful as a reference, keep the page; if it is no longer applicable but a relevant replacement page exists, redirect the old URL to that page. If the only reason for moving is that a new domain name sounds better, the forum advice discussed below favors keeping an established domain that ranks well. When migration is genuinely necessary, map each old page to its new destination and check the redirects rather than sending everything to the new homepage.
Old content can still be useful
In a 1998 article, Jakob Nielsen advocated keeping old pages available over the long term. Information about older products can still help readers decide whether a product meets their needs, and historical content can provide context. For example, someone considering buying a used, older-model printer may need the product information from that time rather than an introduction to the latest model.
He also noted that links from other websites and users’ bookmarks may continue to bring people to old pages. This gives us two separate questions to consider: whether a page is still worth reading and whether readers still need to find relevant content through its old URL. No longer actively promoting a piece of content does not mean its existing links are useless. However, keeping pages available “permanently” is the article’s recommendation, not a current rule that all websites must follow.
A more appealing name may not justify moving a site
On Warrior Forum, Kay King and Frank Donovan both favored keeping the old domain for a website that had been running for nearly ten years and ranked well. Their advice applied to a specific situation: the website was already successful, while the main reason for changing its name was simply that the new name sounded better.
- If you simply prefer another name, consider keeping the old domain rather than rushing to replace the existing website.
- A newly acquired domain can be kept; Donovan also mentioned redirecting it to the existing website if needed.
- If moving the site is genuinely necessary, redirects are one way to handle it, but they do not guarantee a trouble-free migration.
These are suggestions from forum participants, not official search engine rules. They also do not establish that every old domain has an advantage over a new one.
At Procrustes, we build a separate website as part of our service, without requiring changes to the client’s existing official website. This is how we work, not an approach every business needs to adopt.
When migration is necessary, redirect old URLs to relevant content
ElizabethRule on Local Search Forum recommended setting up correct 301 redirects for each page during a domain migration, rather than sending every old page to the new homepage. Once set up, the redirects should be checked with a crawling tool and manually. For example, if an old product page has a corresponding new product page, that should be the preferred destination instead of making readers start searching again from the homepage.
A separate answer on Webmasters Stack Exchange suggested that a 301 redirect should allow Google and other search engines to recognize a URL change. That advice was tentative, however: it did not promise that rankings would be retained or that search results would update immediately.
Preservation costs depend on maintenance requirements
Nielsen’s 1998 article argued that maintenance costs could be very low if old files followed HTML standards or were stored in a publishing database. However, that assessment reflected how websites were managed at the time. It does not mean that every website today can preserve old content at no cost. When deciding what to keep, consider whether the content is useful, whether readers still need to find content through old URLs, and whether ongoing maintenance is feasible—not simply the age of the files.
Preserving old web pages and URLs: perspectives from across the web
When should you update the website URL in a business profile during a domain migration?
ElizabethRule on Local Search Forum recommended completing the redirects from the old domain before updating the website URL in Google Business Profile. After setup, use a crawling tool and manual checks to confirm that old URLs lead to their intended pages. This is practical advice for a domain migration, not a confirmed current platform requirement.
Can old pages still be mapped when the old and new websites have different URL structures?
You can assess whether individual rewrite rules can map some of the pages. The person asking the question on Webmasters Stack Exchange believed that many pages could be handled this way even when the old and new URLs differed. For websites with identical URL structures, another answer proposed redirecting old domains to the main domain while preserving the paths. Both approaches need to be designed around the actual URL structures; a single rule cannot be assumed to work for every website.
References
- Changing Domain URL - What To Be Careful About & Post Domain Change Activitieslocalsearchforum.com — Discusses: When should you update the website URL in a business profile during a domain migration?
- Consolidating multiple domain nameswebmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: Can old pages still be mapped when the old and new websites have different URL structures?
- Business on domain for almost a decade.... but have a better domain name for seo?www.warriorforum.com — Source used in the article above.
- Business on domain for almost a decade.... but have a better domain name for seo?www.warriorforum.com — Source used in the article above.
- Web Pages Must Live Foreverwww.nngroup.com · 1998-11-29T06:00:00+0000 — Source used in the article above.
- Consolidating multiple domain nameswebmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: Can old pages still be mapped when the old and new websites have different URL structures?
- Business on domain for almost a decade.... but have a better domain name for seo?www.warriorforum.com — Source used in the article above.
- what's better for SEO : a 301 moved page vs an alias?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.
