Non-semantic tags are mainly used for styling and layout. They do not, by themselves, clearly describe the role of the content. The sources cited here do not establish bold, italics, or underlining as reliable SEO ranking techniques. They disagree on whether bold text has even a small benefit, and their claims include older articles and community answers—not current search engine rules. The better-supported approach is to choose tags according to the purpose of the content, rather than simply changing the appearance of keywords.
The same appearance can convey different meanings
A Semrush article on semantic HTML dated 2017 explains that semantic tags describe the purpose of content, making code easier for developers and search engines to understand. Generic tags such as div and span are mainly used for styling and layout; they do not describe the role of the content on their own.
One answer on Webmasters Stack Exchange uses quoted content as an example: blockquote identifies a passage as a quotation in the markup, whereas a div named quote does not convey the same meaning. The point is not whether the text looks like a quotation, but whether the tag matches the purpose of the content. Generic containers can still be used; they simply should not be expected to convey a specific meaning on their own.
Does bold text have ranking value? The sources disagree
In a 2017 Semrush article, Jason Barnard argues against using bold, italics, and underlining to improve keyword rankings, broadly describing b, i, s, and u as having no SEO benefit. That is the position taken in the older article, not grounds for concluding that these tags have no meaning or use today.
Another Webmasters Stack Exchange answer suggests that text within b and strong tags may have slightly more SEO value than untagged text, but that the benefit is almost certainly small. One position is “none at all”; the other is “possibly a little.” The sources cited here provide no test data for comparing the effects, so they cannot support a promise of improved rankings.
- “There may be a tiny effect” does not mean “making keywords bold will improve rankings.”
- A claim of no benefit in a single older article is not a rule currently published by search engines.
Identify the role of the content before choosing the markup
When organizing a page, start by asking whether the content is a heading, a quotation, or a list. A community answer notes that the semantic value of headings does not come from their default bold appearance. Making ordinary text bold is therefore not the same as using heading tags.
- Quoted passages: use tags that identify them as quotations, rather than relying only on a container name.
- Ordered lists: use ol to express sequence.
- Items with no required order: use ul without implying a sequence.
These markup choices communicate content structure, but they do not guarantee a ranking boost. HTML validation is a separate issue: valid markup and tags that appropriately convey the meaning of the content are two different things.
Non-semantic formatting tags and SEO: perspectives from across the web
Is HTML necessarily invalid if it does not use heading tags?
Not necessarily. One answer on Webmasters Stack Exchange states that omitting heading tags does not, by itself, make markup invalid. Another explains that passing validation and using tags that appropriately convey the meaning of the content are two different things. Even if the code passes validation, you still need to assess whether its tags match the roles of the content.
Besides ranking concerns, what other problems can underlining keywords cause?
Underlined text may look like a link, leading readers to think it is clickable. For this reason, a 2017 Semrush article advises against using underlining as a technique to improve keyword rankings. This is advice from that historical article; it does not mean that all underlined text should be avoided, nor should it be treated as a current official search engine ranking rule.
References
- Is it important to have semantically correct HTML with regards to SEO?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: Is HTML necessarily invalid if it does not use heading tags?
- Semantic HTML5 for Content Writers — The Essential Guidewww.semrush.com · 2017-11-01T07:00:00Z — Discusses: Besides ranking concerns, what other problems can underlining keywords cause?
- 301 redirect, keyword being in boldwebmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.
- Is "The Art of SEO" book dated?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: Is HTML necessarily invalid if it does not use heading tags?
- What Is Semantic HTML? And How to Use It Correctlywww.semrush.com · 2017-09-25T15:05:00Z — Source used in the article above.




