Consider using nofollow for paid links, links in user-generated content that is difficult to moderate, and links to external websites you cannot or do not wish to endorse. If dealer links appear on different pages to cover multiple locations, having many links, repeating them across pages, or wanting to prevent PageRank from flowing out is not enough to justify adding nofollow to all of them. Public discussion also includes arguments against using it to hoard link equity. The key questions are whether a link is paid, who provided it, and whether the site owner is willing to endorse the destination—not simply how many links there are.
Assess paid links, user-generated content, and references you do not wish to endorse separately
A 2022 article by Welly SEO lists three use cases as a starting point for deciding when to use nofollow. However, its descriptions of platform rules should not be treated as current official requirements:
- Paid links: If someone pays to obtain a link, the article suggests using nofollow or sponsored to indicate its advertising or promotional nature. This differs from an ordinary editorial reference; the trustworthiness of the destination website is not the only consideration.
- User-submitted links: When individual comments or forum posts are difficult to review, the article recommends using nofollow or ugc to manage external links. This is about managing the risk of spam links, not assuming that all user-generated content is unreliable.
- References you do not wish to endorse: If an article needs to reference a website but cannot vouch for it, consider using nofollow to express that reservation.
A 2024 Semrush article also notes that when some search engines do not support ugc or sponsored, these attributes can be combined with nofollow—for example, rel=”nofollow sponsored”. This addresses compatibility in specific circumstances; it does not mean every link needs multiple attributes.
Links to hundreds of dealers: ask three questions first
If a website has a separate page for each dealer, answer these questions before adding nofollow to every dealer link:
- Did the dealer pay to obtain this link? If so, assess it as a paid link.
- Was the URL selected and verified by the site owner, or was it submitted directly by an external user and difficult to review? Only the latter raises the user-generated content moderation issue described above.
- Does the site owner trust the destination and wish to endorse it? If there are reservations, consider whether to use nofollow to express them.
A discussion on Webmasters Stack Exchange argues that adding nofollow to hoard PageRank offers no benefit and states that the “extra equity” does not remain within the site as a result. This is a community response, not a guarantee of ranking effects. The sources discussed here also do not establish that a dealer URL needs nofollow simply because it appears on multiple pages.
Do not broadly apply exceptions for internal links
Another undated discussion uses shopping cart pages to illustrate a limited use case for nofollow on internal links: their content differs for each user and each visit. However, participants disagree on whether this still constitutes PageRank sculpting, and some caution that nofollow should generally be used carefully on internal links. These comments alone do not justify applying the shopping cart approach broadly to internal pages.
Welly SEO’s 2022 article also notes that Google has treated nofollow as a hint since 2020. Therefore, expressing a lack of endorsement does not guarantee that search engines will not follow the link, and adding nofollow should not be expected to automatically improve rankings.
When to use nofollow: perspectives from across the web
Why might all links in a comment section receive nofollow even when the commenters seem trustworthy?
This may be a moderation policy rather than a judgment that each commenter is untrustworthy. The public discussion notes that reviewing externally submitted links individually can be time-consuming and lead to conflict. Applying the attribute uniformly to comments that are difficult to moderate can therefore help manage spam links. If links are selected and verified by the website itself, however, the same rationale should not automatically apply.
If a paid link points to a trustworthy website, should you still consider adding an attribute?
Yes. Whether the destination is trustworthy and whether the link is paid are separate questions. Welly SEO’s 2022 article recommends using nofollow or sponsored for paid links with an advertising or promotional purpose. A trustworthy destination does not make the paid relationship irrelevant. This is the approach proposed in that article and should not be treated as a current official rule.
Does adding nofollow guarantee that the destination URL will not be followed or considered in rankings?
No. Welly SEO’s 2022 article notes that search engines may handle nofollow differently. Some may not follow the link or consider it in rankings, while others treat the attribute as a hint and may still follow the link or use it as a ranking input. Therefore, when using nofollow to express that you do not wish to endorse a destination, do not treat it as a guarantee against link following or ranking effects.
References
- What Are UGC Links? (Vs. Sponsored and Nofollow)www.semrush.com · 2024-09-05T09:38:00Z — Source used in the article above.
- nofollow是什麼?不想權重被瓜分?這項SEO技術非懂不可!welly.tw · 2022-03-28T03:16:56.479Z — Discusses: Why might all links in a comment section receive nofollow even when the commenters seem trustworthy?; If a paid link points to a trustworthy website, should you still consider adding an attribute?
- How to handle hundred of external links in a site?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.
- How to handle hundred of external links in a site?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.
- How to handle hundred of external links in a site?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.
- How to handle hundred of external links in a site?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: If a paid link points to a trustworthy website, should you still consider adding an attribute?
- How to handle hundred of external links in a site?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: Why might all links in a comment section receive nofollow even when the commenters seem trustworthy?

