Including the exact phrase “estructuras truss” on a new page does not mean it will rank higher than an older page. This public discussion highlights two things to check before concluding that the wording changes failed: whether the new URL opens correctly and whether any links point to the new page. However, the discussion does not provide enough information to determine what caused the ranking gap.
First, check that the new page opens correctly rather than adding more keywords
The person asking the question said that the new page still did not appear in Google’s top 100 results after being updated to include the exact target phrase, while the older page could still be found. But when a respondent opened the new URL provided, they saw “The requested page does not exist” and asked for the correct URL. The first question is therefore: is the page everyone is checking actually the one that was optimized?
- Check that the new URL being used for the ranking comparison points to the page intended for publication.
- Open that URL and confirm whether it displays content or an error message.
- If an incorrect link was provided, correct it before discussing differences between the new and old content.
This was only the respondent’s finding at the time; it does not establish the website’s current state. The discussion also lacks enough information to determine the technical cause of the error.
Compare links to the new and old pages, not just their wording
Another respondent noted that Google rankings depend not only on keywords but also on links pointing to a page, and suggested that a brand-new page might not have any links yet. That remains an unconfirmed possibility: the discussion gives no actual link counts for either page, so it does not establish that the older page ranks better because it has more links.
Start by checking which internal links originally pointed to the older page and whether any now point to the new page. For example, if the navigation still links to the old URL but has no corresponding link to the new page, that is a concrete difference worth addressing rather than repeatedly adjusting the target phrase. This example illustrates how to compare the pages; it is not a confirmed description of the website’s current state.
If the page has actually moved to a new URL, consider a 301 redirect
One suggestion in the discussion was to use a 301 redirect from the old page to the new one to let search engines know that the page has moved. This assumes that the new page genuinely replaces the old one. If the pages serve different purposes and both are being retained, the migration advice should not be applied simply because the new page ranks lower.
The discussion provides no follow-up results and does not specify the publication date, when the rankings were checked, or the search conditions. For now, the recommendation is to work through the checks above—not to expect that fixing the URL, adding links, or setting up a redirect will guarantee a place in the top 100.
Rankings of new and old pages: perspectives from across the web
Were there internal links pointing to the old page, and are there now links pointing to the new page?
That cannot currently be confirmed. The discussion does not list internal links, so it is unclear which links originally pointed to the old page or whether any now point to the new page. A respondent only suggested that the new page “might” not have any links yet. To compare the pages, check the links pointing to each URL separately rather than treating speculation as a confirmed difference.
Do broken links on the website explain why the new page ranks lower?
That conclusion cannot be drawn directly. One respondent said at the time that the website had many broken links. This is a lead worth checking, but the material does not list those links or prove that they caused the ranking gap between the new and old pages. If broken links still exist, first check which URLs they point to rather than judging the website’s current state solely from that old response.
References
- Why does a broad-phrase rank better than new optimized exact-phrase?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: Do broken links on the website explain why the new page ranks lower?
- Why does a broad-phrase rank better than new optimized exact-phrase?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: Were there internal links pointing to the old page, and are there now links pointing to the new page?
- Why does a broad-phrase rank better than new optimized exact-phrase?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.

