If you cannot write a separate page description and the system can only use the beginning of the article as the meta description, the community answers cited here suggest this approach: when you have no meaningful description to provide, you can omit the tag and let search engines select page content for the search result snippet. There is no need to copy the entire article just to fill the field. However, being unable to customize an excerpt does not necessarily mean being unable to control the meta description. First check whether you can modify the theme or output template, or use a separate description field.
First check which fields and templates you can change
An article excerpt, a meta description, and a search result snippet are three different things. Whether a site uses the article excerpt as its meta description depends on how it generates its output. The search result snippet may not reproduce the site’s description, either. One answer about MODx notes that templates can control the HTML output and use a dedicated description field to set descriptions for individual pages.
- If a separate description field is available, first check whether you can use it to set the meta description rather than simply copying the article excerpt.
- If you can only modify the template, check what text it can access and whether it can omit the description tag.
- If neither the fields nor the template can be adjusted, the sources cited here offer no universal workaround.
The MODx example shows that both fields and templates may give you control over the description output. It does not establish that other platforms offer the same features.
You do not have to use the article’s opening text
Two community answers favor letting search engines select content themselves if the description would merely repeat the beginning of the article. One notes that always using the opening text may leave out a passage elsewhere on the page that more closely matches the search terms. This advice compares two ways of selecting snippet text; it does not guarantee that omitting the tag will increase clicks.
The question, then, is not just whether the field can be filled automatically, but whether the text is meaningful. That answer also cautions that search engines may ignore descriptions they consider suspicious. Providing a meta description does not guarantee which text will appear in search results.
Even if the template cannot shorten the article text, that is no reason to put the entire article into the description. Doing so only duplicates the article content in the HTML without solving the problem of how to provide a suitable description.
Older platform examples and plugin advice are not universal rules
The Tumblr example cited here dates from 2010. The person asking the question said that, at the time, they could neither set a page description nor limit the length of the article text retrieved by the template. This led them to consider using the beginning of the article or even the full text. That explains the origin of the question, but it should not be taken as a description of Tumblr’s current capabilities.
Another questioner reported that a plugin author advised against using excerpts in place of meta descriptions. However, the cited material does not include the author’s reasoning or the conditions under which that advice applies. It therefore cannot be generalized into a rule that excerpts should never be used. In short, if you can write a separate description, consider using the description field. If you can only copy the opening text and have no meaningful description to provide, omitting the tag is an option.
Meta descriptions: perspectives from across the web
When choosing a CMS, is it enough to check whether it offers SEO features?
Do not look only at feature names; also check what the template you will actually use can output. One answer about MODx argues that SEO depends largely on the template rather than the CMS itself. In that example, the template's control over HTML and the description field provided by the core system both help with setting page descriptions. These are things to check when choosing a system, not a guarantee of what other CMS platforms offer.
References
- MODx CMS and SEOwebmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: When choosing a CMS, is it enough to check whether it offers SEO features?
- SEO: Is there a limit to how long titles/descriptions should be?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.
- SEO: Is there a limit to how long titles/descriptions should be?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.
- SEO: Is there a limit to how long titles/descriptions should be?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.
- Using Excerpts as Meta Descriptions?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.
- SEO: Is there a limit to how long titles/descriptions should be?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.
