A manual action is a measure taken after a human review finds a violation; an algorithm change is an adjustment to an automated ranking system. Both can reduce search visibility, but a drop in rankings does not mean a site has received a manual action. The key to telling them apart is whether there is an action notification for the site, not how sharply its traffic has fallen. The two are also related: automated systems and human review can both detect violations and spam, but this does not mean an update necessarily triggers a manual action.
The difference lies in the mechanism, not just the “penalty” label
Semrush’s 2024 overview explains that manual actions involve human reviews of individual cases, while algorithms automatically adjust rankings based on signals. A manual action may target specific pages or affect an entire site; an algorithm-driven ranking change does not necessarily mean a site has violated any rules.
- Manual actions: A human reviews the case, and the site receives a Search Console notification. Effects may include reduced visibility or removal from search results.
- Algorithm changes: These may adjust how content is matched to search intent or address attempts to manipulate rankings. A site may also drop in rankings because competing pages have moved up.
There is still disagreement over what counts as a “penalty.” In Semrush’s 2020 interviews, Fili Wiese rejected the term “algorithmic penalty,” describing it instead as an algorithm ranking pages based on signals. Dan Petrovic would only call manual actions severe enough to constitute a ban “penalties.” Understanding the actual mechanisms matters more than agreeing on a single label.
Notifications are direct evidence; update dates are only clues
According to Semrush’s 2024 article, manual actions can be viewed in the relevant Search Console report. Algorithm-driven ranking changes for individual sites do not come with equivalent action notifications. This is separate from whether Google publicly announces an update.
A 2023 article on Neil Patel’s website recommends comparing traffic changes with the timing of major updates. This can help narrow an investigation, but matching dates alone cannot establish causation. The manual actions report does not show whether algorithms have affected a site: the absence of a manual action notification does not confirm that a site has been affected by an algorithm.
For example, a traffic decline during an update could still be related to seasonal demand or technical problems. An awoo overview from 2025 notes that accidentally adding noindex tags can cause large numbers of pages to drop out of the index. Similar traffic patterns do not necessarily have the same cause.
They can address similar problems without one triggering the other
Semrush’s 2024 article quotes Google’s explanation that it detects content and behavior that violate its policies through automated systems and, when necessary, human review. The connection is that both can help combat spam—not that “an algorithm issues a penalty first, which then automatically becomes a manual action.”
The paths to recovery also differ. The article states that lifting a manual action requires Google to review the individual case. Some sites, meanwhile, may recover traffic after an algorithm update even without major changes to the site. This is only a possibility, not a guarantee of recovery, and the time taken in an individual case should not be treated as a fixed timeframe.
Manual actions and algorithm changes: perspectives from across the web
What should you do after receiving a manual action?
Start by checking the Search Console report to see what the problems are and which parts of the site are affected. Then address the problems and submit a reconsideration request. Semrush’s 2024 overview notes that lifting an action requires Google to review the individual case; fixing the problems does not guarantee approval. In one unnatural links case from 2018, the site operator reviewed and addressed its backlinks before submitting a request, and the action was lifted that year. However, the time taken in that case should not be treated as a fixed timeframe.
Why can algorithm-driven ranking changes be harder to address?
The cause may be harder to identify, and there is usually no single, simple fix. SEO consultant Marie Haynes says manual actions usually identify the main problem, but the reason may be less clear when an algorithm no longer prioritizes certain content. Another expert interviewed noted that sites can sometimes recover after a subsequent core update even with almost no changes. Keep improving the site, but do not assume that every adjustment will restore rankings within a specific timeframe.
Will a large number of similar pages necessarily trigger a manual action?
That cannot be assumed. In a forum discussion, Marie Haynes said a site’s 3,000 location pages might have been the cause, but she also thought algorithms might already be sufficient to handle this kind of doorway-like content. She emphasized that she was only offering a hypothesis at the time, that every site’s circumstances differ, and that some cases require deeper investigation. Page count alone is not enough to establish the reason for an action.
References
- Google Manual Penalty - Thin Contentlocalsearchforum.com — Discusses: Will a large number of similar pages necessarily trigger a manual action?
- How to Improve Your Google Rankings (Without Getting Penalized)neilpatel.com · 2023-05-19T19:00:00+00:00 — Source used in the article above.
- Essential Expert Tips on Fixing and Avoiding Google Penaltieswww.semrush.com · 2020-07-17T11:20:00Z — Discusses: What should you do after receiving a manual action?; Why can algorithm-driven ranking changes be harder to address?
- 【Search Central Live Deep Dive】Day3:品質與排名解密!從使用者意圖到 AI 時代的 SEO 新策略|awoo 活動實記www.awoo.ai · 2025-07-28T07:01:00+00:00 — Source used in the article above.
- A Comprehensive Guide to Understanding Google Penaltieswww.semrush.com · 2024-02-29T11:40:00Z — Discusses: What should you do after receiving a manual action?
