Link issues may affect rankings, but first distinguish between lost links, broken destination pages, faulty redirects, and problems with link quality or formatting. They should not all be treated as “bad backlinks.” Neil Patel’s 2020 article states that the strength of a link profile correlates with rankings; this does not mean that finding a link issue proves it caused a ranking drop. First identify which link or destination page has a problem, then decide whether to repair, replace, or remove it.
After a redesign-related drop, start by checking old URLs and redirects
The same article warns that links can be lost when a website is redesigned, renamed, or moved. Deleting an old article may break internal links pointing to it and weaken the site’s internal linking structure. For content that still has value, the author therefore recommends updating it rather than deleting it outright.
- Repeated redesigns: Check whether redirects from older versions still work with the latest version, rather than checking only the most recent migration.
- Domain changes: Letting the old domain expire may stop existing 301 redirects from working, potentially causing traffic loss. A “permanent redirect” does not mean no maintenance is ever needed after setup.
- Broken destination pages: Determine whether to restore the old content, create replacement content, or remove links that are no longer needed, paying particular attention to high-traffic pages and information visitors still need.
Important pages with too few internal links are also worth checking
Broken links are not the only issue to address. Ahrefs’ 2023 article suggests considering additional internal links if you want a page to rank but it has only one dofollow internal link. Specifically, look for linking opportunities on other pages covering related topics, rather than indiscriminately increasing the number of links. This is a recommendation for improvement, not a guarantee that adding a certain number of links will boost rankings.
Treat lost backlinks and poor-quality backlinks separately
Neil Patel’s 2020 article lists link audits as a troubleshooting method but also warns that apparently normal audit results do not rule out other link issues. If another website has removed a link to your site, you can contact it to ask whether the link can be restored. However, the author also notes that most people may not respond, so outreach should not be treated as a guaranteed fix.
If the broken link instead points from your site to an external website, you can remove it and replace it with a link to content on another authoritative website. This is a different task from asking an external site to restore a backlink.
Tools can find errors in bulk, but their labels do not determine ranking impact
Semrush’s 2021 article recommends manually clicking links to check their destinations when there are only a few. For thousands of links, it recommends using Site Audit to identify broken URLs and the pages containing them in bulk. The article also describes daily or weekly scheduled audits; this reflects the product features described at that time.
Screaming Frog’s 2026 release notes for version 24.0 make another distinction: according to its research, Google may still attempt to parse nonstandard links that the tool labels “uncrawlable” to discover URLs. However, these links may pass link signals differently and should not be relied on. Being able to discover a URL does not mean link signals are passed in the same way.
Link issues: perspectives from across the web
What should you do if you find potentially harmful backlinks?
Start with an audit to identify problematic backlinks, rather than treating all link irregularities as the same kind of issue. In his 2020 article, Neil Patel recommends contacting the linking website to request removal after identifying a bad link, and treating the disavow tool as a last resort only if that request is unsuccessful. This is the author’s recommendation, not a statement of current platform rules. Audit results alone also cannot establish the cause of a ranking drop.
Do excessive footer links necessarily cause rankings to drop?
A single case cannot establish that they always do. In a 2012 article, Screaming Frog describes a client website that experienced a sharp drop in October 2011 after more than 150 footer links were mistakenly added. The author attributed the decline to those links and reported a full recovery within a week after promptly addressing the issue. This is the author’s assessment of a single historical case, not a universal threshold or a guarantee that other websites will recover within the same timeframe after a fix.
Can tools detect incorrectly formatted URLs?
Tools can check for syntactically invalid URLs, but the tool version and settings matter. Screaming Frog’s release notes for version 24.0 state that enabling “Crawl Invalid Links” allows the tool to parse, crawl, and report these URLs, including those with misspelled protocols. Results typically show them as malformed with no response. After finding one, you still need to confirm its intended destination before correcting the URL. A tool label alone cannot establish its impact on rankings.
References
- Here’s What You Should Do When Your Search Rankings Dropneilpatel.com · 2020-08-25T13:00:00+00:00 — Discusses: What should you do if you find potentially harmful backlinks?
- 16 Google Penalty, Update & Filter Visualisations By SEO Visibilitywww.screamingfrog.co.uk · 2012-05-28T10:06:46+00:00 — Discusses: Do excessive footer links necessarily cause rankings to drop?
- We Studied Over 1 Million Domains to Find the Most Common Technical SEO Issuesahrefs.com · 2023-08-31T05:03:17+00:00 — Source used in the article above.
- HTML Anchor Element: A Simple Guide for Beginnerswww.semrush.com · 2021-05-19T08:59:00Z — Source used in the article above.
- Screaming Frog SEO Spider Update – Version 24.0www.screamingfrog.co.uk · 2026-05-19T07:29:22+00:00 — Discusses: Can tools detect incorrectly formatted URLs?



