When rankings for specific keywords drop, first establish which keywords are affected, how far they have fallen, when the decline began, and what changed on the website around that time. Then investigate technical issues, competing pages, and algorithm updates. The discussions and reports below suggest what to investigate but do not establish why rankings fell in individual cases. A ranking decline after an edit does not prove that the edit caused it, nor should every decline be attributed to a Google update.
Distinguish a single-keyword decline from sitewide changes
In a public discussion, Rigpa reported that the site had long ranked on the first page for “psykolog horsens” before falling to pages nine or ten. Rankings for two other related keywords remained normal. This differs from several keywords declining simultaneously. Keep unaffected keywords as a point of comparison rather than recording only the one with the largest drop.
- List both declining and unaffected keywords, recording their corresponding pages and rankings before and after the decline.
- Note the date the decline was first observed. Review mobile and desktop rankings separately, and compare changes across different date ranges.
- If there are many keywords, prioritize tracking those that bring traffic, generate conversions, or support business goals, and set alerts for significant changes.
A 2025 tool overview by yesharris noted that rank-tracking tools can show changes by device and date; Semrush also recommended categorizing keywords by their importance to conversions. These practices help you understand ranking changes but do not directly establish the cause of a decline.
Put site changes and rankings on the same timeline
If rankings fell a few days after “Pricing” was changed to “Pricing/Policies” and policy content was added, first clarify whether the change involved the page name, title tag, or body content. Was only one page changed, or were other pages edited too? If the changes were reverted, also check whether any additional content edits were made during that process.
Participants in the discussion disagreed: some considered the title the main cause, while others thought a small change to one page was unlikely to cause a sitewide decline and suspected the algorithm update at the time instead. Neither side provided enough evidence to confirm the cause. The date of an edit is therefore a clue to investigate, not proof of causation. Reverting the changes is no guarantee that the previous rankings will return.
Passing a test does not mean the technical investigation is complete
Rigpa reported that the site had passed a mobile test, that no messages had arrived from Search Console or Analytics, and that speed and plugins appeared normal. However, the same discussion also mentioned that tests sometimes showed loading errors, with the number varying between tests. These reports described that particular case at the time; they did not establish that the website was entirely free of technical issues.
A September 2026 Search Engine Journal report quoted Mueller recommending a thorough investigation into widespread technical issues, such as the entire site being blocked. Check for clear problems of this kind rather than ending the investigation simply because no notification was received.
Check updates and competitors before deciding on a cause
Look for common characteristics among the pages currently ranking higher, then compare them with your own pages. However, normal rankings for other keywords do not prove that the decline was caused by competitors overtaking the site. The June 2019 core update mentioned in past discussions also cannot simply be used to explain a decline during another period.
The report cited above also placed a condition on its discussion of recovery time: if the decline did coincide with a broader spam update, it could take months to see results after the relevant issues were fixed. However, Mueller did not confirm the update dates for that particular case. Although Rigpa later reported that rankings had returned to the first page and remained stable, the cause was still unknown—recovering rankings does not mean the cause has been established.
Investigating keyword ranking drops: perspectives from across the web
Are backlinks worth checking when rankings drop?
They can be included in the investigation, but links should not immediately be assumed to be the cause. Someone in the discussion suggested investigating backlinks, and the site owner in the “psykolog horsens” case also mentioned three broken backlinks. However, that was only an observation at the time; there was no evidence that they caused the ranking decline. Treat the state of the links as a lead to verify rather than drawing conclusions solely from link counts or broken links.
What industry was the website with declining rankings in?
That depends on the case. The website associated with “psykolog horsens” was for psychologist services, and the owner explained that Horsens was the town where the business was located. The available information did not identify the industry of the other website, whose rankings for several keywords fell after its “Pricing” page was changed. Do not assume that the two websites were in the same industry.
References
- Keywords Suddenly Dropped in Rank on Google?www.warriorforum.com — Source used in the article above.
- Google Says Ranking Recovery Takes Months After SEO Issues Are Fixedwww.searchenginejournal.com · 2026-09-03T10:37:14+00:00 — Source used in the article above.
- Ahrefs教學:SEO必學5大功能、優缺點、費用指南www.yesharris.com · 2025-04-24T03:38:00+08:00 — Source used in the article above.
- Keywords Suddenly Dropped in Rank on Google?www.warriorforum.com — Discusses: Are backlinks worth checking when rankings drop?
- Ranking at page 10 in Google serpswww.warriorforum.com — Discusses: Are backlinks worth checking when rankings drop?; What industry was the website with declining rankings in?
- How to Track Keywords: Tips, Examples & Checklistwww.semrush.com · 2024-04-29T18:30:00Z — Source used in the article above.
- Keywords Suddenly Dropped in Rank on Google?www.warriorforum.com — Source used in the article above.
- Ranking at page 10 in Google serpswww.warriorforum.com — Source used in the article above.
- Keywords Suddenly Dropped in Rank on Google?www.warriorforum.com — Source used in the article above.
- Keywords Suddenly Dropped in Rank on Google?www.warriorforum.com — Source used in the article above.
- Keywords Suddenly Dropped in Rank on Google?www.warriorforum.com — Source used in the article above.
- Keywords Suddenly Dropped in Rank on Google?www.warriorforum.com — Source used in the article above.
