Keyword competition describes how difficult it is for a website or search ad to gain visibility for a particular query. Organic search focuses on the difficulty of achieving top unpaid rankings; paid search focuses on how many advertisers bid on the same keyword. Assessing competition is not just about choosing the easiest keywords. It is about determining whether the resources you can invest give you a chance of attracting worthwhile traffic, clicks, or conversions.
Organic rankings and ad bidding measure different things
Semrush distinguishes between two types of competition: SEO involves competing with other organic search results, while paid search involves bidding among advertisers. Greater competition in paid search generally means higher costs. So when a keyword is labeled as having “high competition,” first confirm which channel this refers to. Advertising competition should not be treated as a direct measure of organic ranking difficulty.
Tool scores also have limits. For example, Semrush’s “Keyword Difficulty” expresses organic ranking difficulty on a scale from 0% to 100%. It is a metric calculated by the tool, not a ranking rule published by a search engine.
Assessing competition helps you decide where to allocate resources first
Search volume reflects one aspect of demand, but it cannot tell you on its own whether a website can gain visibility. If competitors for a target keyword are far stronger than you are, seeing results may require more time and resources, even when search volume is substantial. Assessing competition therefore helps with three decisions:
- Keyword priorities: When starting out, you can target easier keywords first, then gradually tackle more difficult ones.
- Expectations for results: Highly competitive keywords generally require more investment, so you should not expect results as quickly as you would with easier keywords.
- Advertising budgets: For more expensive keywords, assess whether the expected clicks or conversions justify the spending.
Look at actual search results, not just scores
In a 2016 article, awoo recommended examining which competitors appear on the first page of search results, how well they perform in SEO, and how your website’s competitiveness compares with theirs. The article listed major e-commerce, nonprofit, and government websites as examples to examine. This was advice from that period, not a claim that any particular type of domain necessarily ranks higher.
Semrush also notes that competition for visibility comes not only from industry competitors’ websites, but also from paid ads, social platforms, and AI Overviews, which may reduce the visibility of organic results. When assessing a keyword, then, you should ask not only “Can we outrank other websites?” but also which placements on the search results page are drawing readers’ attention.
Low competition is not the only answer, and high competition does not guarantee results
Different sources offer different advice on keyword selection: codyhay on Warrior Forum recommends focusing on keywords with high search volume and moderate to high competition, while awoo’s historical article favors keywords with high search volume, strong relevance to the content, and low competition. codyhay’s recommendation is forum advice, and its optimistic expectations should not be treated as a guarantee of results.
A more cautious approach is to consider competition alongside your goals, content relevance, and available resources when choosing keywords. Targeting easier keywords first is one possible starting strategy for a new website, not a rule every website must follow.
Keyword competition: perspectives from across the web
Which keywords should you compare when evaluating search volume?
Start by comparing similar types of keywords rather than looking at a single keyword’s search volume in isolation. Using “Guam,” “Guam car rental,” “independent travel in Guam,” and “Guam itinerary” as examples, awoo recommends comparing keywords within related topics. Overall search volume for niche topics may be low, so looking only at absolute numbers can strip away the context needed for comparison. This is one approach to guide keyword selection; content relevance and competition still need to be considered.
Are keywords with high search volume and moderate to high competition always worth focusing on?
Not necessarily. Forum author codyhay advocates focusing on these keywords, but the available information does not guarantee that following this advice will produce results. Semrush, meanwhile, cautions that choosing the wrong keywords can consume resources if competitors are so strong that you have little chance of outranking them. Those just starting out can consider easier keywords first. Whether to invest in highly competitive keywords still depends on your goals and the time and resources you can commit, rather than search volume alone.
References
- High search engine rank, but low trafficwww.warriorforum.com — Discusses: Are keywords with high search volume and moderate to high competition always worth focusing on?
- A Guide to Keyword Competition in SEO & PPC [2025 Data]www.semrush.com · 2024-10-07T09:34:00Z — Discusses: Are keywords with high search volume and moderate to high competition always worth focusing on?
- 關鍵字行銷建議工具『天下無狗』運用篇之:什麼是好的關鍵字?www.awoo.ai · 2016-03-09T02:12:26+00:00 — Discusses: Which keywords should you compare when evaluating search volume?
