Start with a website crawler to identify broken links, the pages containing them, and the status codes returned. Check whether each link points to your own site or another website, and whether the content has moved or been deleted. Based on what you find, update the URL, restore the page, set up a redirect, or remove the link—do not simply redirect every URL that returns a 404. Internal links can take priority; for outbound links, make sure any replacement source serves the original purpose. After making repairs, click the links to verify them and schedule regular scans.
First, identify which page links to which broken URL
Start with a full site crawl to identify broken links. For example, the broken links report in Semrush Site Audit lists source pages, broken URLs, and HTTP status codes. Google Search Console’s 404 information can supplement this with nonexistent pages encountered by Googlebot, but it should not be treated as a complete list of outbound links.
- Record the page containing each link so you know where to make changes, rather than simply collecting a list of faulty URLs.
- Distinguish between internal and external destinations, and check whether the URL contains a typo, the page has moved, or the content has been deleted.
- Address broken internal links first: they hinder navigation and may also affect search engines’ ability to crawl the site.
Internal links: update links and handle old URLs separately
If you know the correct destination page, update the link on the source page directly. Even if the old URL already redirects, it is still advisable to link to the final URL to reduce unnecessary redirects.
- Pages have moved or content has been consolidated: Update internal links to the new page. If the move is permanent, or a replacement page serves the same purpose, you can set up a 301 permanent redirect from the old URL.
- A page has been deleted but is still needed: Consider restoring the content, then check whether the original links work again.
- The content no longer exists and there is no relevant replacement page: Remove the link. Keep the surrounding text if it is still useful; remove the passage if the reference itself is no longer relevant.
For example, if two tutorials are combined into one, set up redirects from the old URLs and also find and update articles that still link to them. If external sites still link to an old page, you can contact them to request a correction. This is separate from changing outbound links on your own website.
Outbound links: replacement sources must serve the original purpose
You do not control destination pages on external sites. If you can confirm that the content has moved to a new URL on the same site, update the link. You can also use a reliable resource on another website, but it must match both the topic and the purpose of the reference. For example, if the original text cites a particular study, another article discussing the same topic cannot automatically be treated as equivalent evidence.
If you cannot find a reliable replacement, remove the broken link. Keep the text if it can stand on its own. If the purpose or credibility of the entire passage depends on that source, remove the whole passage to avoid leaving unsupported statements.
Verify repairs, then schedule regular checks
Click the updated links to confirm that the new URLs and redirects lead to the intended content. When internal pages are moved or deleted, also update and submit the sitemap. Neil Patel’s maintenance article recommends scanning for broken links monthly; this can serve as a starting point for your schedule, not a mandatory platform rule.
Fixing broken links: perspectives from across the web
Do broken links always directly harm search rankings?
Not necessarily. One Semrush article argues that broken internal links make it harder for search engines to crawl a website and may interrupt the flow of link equity between pages. The same article states that broken outbound links do not directly harm rankings, but may worsen the user experience and reduce trust. Another article suggests that a poor user experience may negatively affect rankings. This is a possibility, not an inevitable outcome.
Who should fix links from other websites to old URLs on your site?
You can contact the external site and ask it to correct or remove the link, especially if it entered the URL incorrectly. If your page has moved and there is a relevant new page, you can also set up a redirect from the old URL. If the original content is still valuable, consider recreating it. You cannot control whether an external site cooperates, so first assess why the link is broken and how important it is, then decide how to proceed.
Is manually checking links page by page a good approach for a large website?
Large websites can start with a crawl-based audit to build an inventory; clicking every link manually is less practical. Manual checks are useful for confirming that updated links or redirects work as expected. If many pages still link to the same old URL, use the audit to identify the source pages and update them in bulk where possible. This scales better than searching and replacing page by page.
How can you ensure broken links actually get addressed after regular scans?
Do more than generate a list of broken links: establish a process for notifying page authors to update or remove them so the problems get addressed. In a 1998 article, Nielsen recommended regularly using link validation tools: small sites could consider outsourcing, while large sites could consider installing validation software on their servers. This was practical advice at the time, not a current platform requirement.
References
- 失效的反向連結會降低排名?4 方法修復失效連結!welly.tw · 2024-07-09T09:04:40.938Z — Discusses: Who should fix links from other websites to old URLs on your site?
- Fighting Linkrotwww.nngroup.com · 1998-06-14T05:00:00+0000 — Discusses: How can you ensure broken links actually get addressed after regular scans?
- Broken Links: Common Causes and How to Fix Themwww.semrush.com · 2021-06-07T21:58:00Z — Discusses: Do broken links always directly harm search rankings?; Is manually checking links page by page a good approach for a large website?
- The Ultimate Monthly Website Maintenance Checklistneilpatel.com · 2025-07-16T19:00:00+00:00 — Source used in the article above.
- Google Search Console Errors: Identifying and Fixing Themwww.semrush.com · 2024-03-20T10:51:00Z — Source used in the article above.
- 16 Best WordPress SEO Plugins (Free & Paid)www.semrush.com · 2023-06-12T10:44:00Z — Discusses: Do broken links always directly harm search rankings?
- The technical SEO checklist for search engines and AI searchwww.semrush.com · 2024-09-18T14:13:00Z — Source used in the article above.

